|
Point of VIEW. A purely analytical perception...
Updated April 25, 2003
Demographics At the moment, China is the world's
most populated country: somewhere between 1.3 and 1.7 billion people live within
its borders, nobody in China, or anywhere else for that matter can really be certain.
A number of years ago, the Chinese adopted an intense population restriction formula,
which allowed only one child per family. While
the government seemed in earnest about that law, if you are among the Chinese
elite, rules are for everyone else. In spite of the selective cheating that is
going on, India will probably surpass China in population early in the
21st century. Interestingly
enough, although only 22% of Chinese live in urban areas, there are 40 cities
in the country with over 1 million people.
Ethnic Han Chinese comprise approximately 92% of the population, followed
by Zhuang, Manchu, Hui and Miao peoples. The Chinese literacy rate is relatively
high: 78% of the population is able to read and write. On the other hand, advanced education
historically had required proof of allegiance to the Communist Party, which until
recently had restricted universal higher education and excludes a substantial
talent pool from the elite. Most
curricula throughout the system, stress courses in math and science because the
national leadership believes that the country lags in those disciplines, which
they believe are essential to the country's technological growth. However,
as new thinking comes into play and old ideas are shunted aside in favor of growth,
China is branching out intellectually to cover all of its basis. The have learned
after years of isolation that having intellectual resources readily available
represents a more constructive approach than constantly worrying about a revolution
among the more educated, one of Mao's theories. China has no state religion, and
the government make the claim that it does not stand in the way of people who
want to practice religion. However, if that
religion grew to strong and advocated major change such as is happening among
Muslim's in the southwestern region of China, regional authorities tend to dampen
religious ardor with numerous unpleasant techniques. Confucianism, Buddhism
and Taoism are the most common forms of organized religion, but in practice, people
seem to treat religion as a menu and often combine parts of all three in their
services. Ancestor worship is universally practiced.
Moreover,
whenever a religion begins to look
more like a political forum such as the hated Falun Gong, the Chinese are quick
to crack down and have gotten substantial bad publicity recently because of their
treatment of a number of religious minorities. Moreover, religious movements have
sprung up over the years in China, mostly offering a better life, inoculations
against tyranny or something better in the hereafter. The come and they go but
their attraction to the Chinese is almost magnetic. They have witnessed the rise
and fall of the Taoist Yellow Scarf Society during the Han dynasty in 184
A.D., the Wu Dou Mi Religious Society during the Jin dynasty in 399 A.D., the
Bai Lian Sect in 1796 and the Taiping Rebellion during the Qing Dynasty in 1850.
()
Economics With
a landmass of 3.7 million square miles, China is slightly larger than the United
States. Only Russia and Canada are larger. It contains the highest point in the
world, Mt. Everest, and one of the lowest, Takia Makan, an oasis, which is over
five hundred feet below sea level. The Yangtze River is almost 4,000 miles in
length and only the Nile and Amazon exceed it in size. The land for
the most part is unsuitable for agriculture, as mountain ranges make up much of
China's terrain. It has 22% of the world's population and only 7% of its arable
land. Yet, it is agriculturally self sufficient, due to the use of highly technical
production techniques. On the other hand, the food is only of the subsistence
variety, and as the country's wealth increases, it is likely that the population
will desire a more varied diet. Under those conditions it is doubtful that China
can maintain the delicate balance that it has established between production and
consumption. The
World Bank in a recent report indicated that while the world's economy was growing
at a rate of 2% a year in the first half of this decade, during that time, China
averaged a global high of 12.8%. Of the top nine countries in the study,
all but Kuwait and Jordan are from the Pacific Rim. The runners up were Kuwait,
New Guinea, Singapore and Malaysia, all literally in a dead heat, Thailand,
Vietnam, Jordan and Indonesia. However, some of these countries are starting from
literally a zero base and any growth at tends to be magnified dramatically. Neither
Vietnam or Jordan had virtually any economy at all a decade or less ago. As more countries join the list of industrial wanabees, there are
often certain strains that are put upon their systems. The sudden transaction
of a society from rural or agrarian to urban occurs more often than not without
a proper infrastructure development being put into place. Cities like Alexandria,
Sao Paulo, Calcutta and Mexico City are horrifying examples of what can happen
when too many people opt for what they consider are the better things in life
offered by the big cities
all at once. The normal problem of having a roof over ones head is more
or less of the superficial variety, but environmental after the fact concerns have turned magnificent cities into wastelands. Standard problems
of brought on by too many people trying to occupy a relative small area to quickly
cause, inadequate sanitary facilities, massive pollution, substandard drinking
water, insufficient and inoperative transportation, lack of police protection,
overcrowded jails and inadequate teaching facilities. Show me a city in a third
world country that is growing quickly and you will find all or most of these problems.
Many of these problems stem from the fact that these countries are democratic
and people are allowed, for the most part, to live where they chose.
AwarenessThis has not always been the case in China but to some degree it
is becoming true today. People in China are now aware of what is going on in the
world, they see television, they have Internet and they talk to their friends
that have traveled. For that reason they suffer the same delusions as everyone
else on this planet, that of aspiring to a better life. However, China is still
much more dictatorial than India, Brazil, Egypt and Mexico and at least has an
opportunity to see that its growth is to some degree controlled. China historically
has used a sophisticated identification system so that at least most of their
citizens are either where they belong or they are somehow or other otherwise accounted
for. Without these passports to a better life, moving from on place to another
is extremely difficult. China has industrialized and because of that reason has
become a nomadic culture. Depending upon the season or the industry, there can
be enormous shifts in the population of various places. The central government
is out to build a modern society and is trying to do what it takes to get there,
whatever the cost.
Until recently, China issued
residence cards to all of its citizens and only the chosen elite could meander
about the country as they choose. When China determined to relax those regulations,
an exodus occurred that shocked the country’s father/’s, it seemed that no one
really liked it down on the farm and everyone was anxious to see the big city
lights. Thus, the country was forced to attempt the impossible, to go from an
ox-cart/bicycle economy to that superhighways and jet aircraft overnight. In terms
of the road building the task was daunting especially because non of the modern
variety existed. In the last decade though, all major cities in China have been
linked together or are in the process.
Buses replaced the rickshaws
and oxcarts, but their society remained the same. As these modern prairie schooners
plied the inter-city routes buses were obligated to pickup literally anyone, anywhere,
carrying anything. These tramp steamers of the highways are filled to the brim
as the careen down the roads carrying an assortment of people with chickens, pigs,
food and other evil smiling luggage. While it serves as a means to an end, the
buses are old, the tires are bare and the dangers are severe for anyone not having
the ability to speak the language and a cast iron stomach.
There are approximately nine
million cars and trucks on the road in China with production at about 1.5 million
a year and rising like Topsy. The figures are somewhat deceiving though because
the great majority of the trucks cruising the Mainland's highways are military.
While 125 companies make these vehicles, 70% of the total are produced by only
seven manufacturers and only a tad over a million Chinese own and drive their
own cars. On the other hand production is increasing geometrically as incomes
increase and the highway system reaches maturity. Not to long ago even if
you had a car, you really couldn't drive it anywhere without taking your life
in your hands, today, almost all of China is accessible and everyone would like
to trade their bicycle or moped in for a car. The problem is that by far the majority
of the population can not afford the luxury of owning an automobile. On the other
hand car theft in Southeast Asia has picked up dramatically and for the most part,
the objects of the thieves’ affections are unloaded in China. The average
Chinese worker is making $500 per year and there is over $3,000 worth of raw materials
in a 2,000 pound automobile. The mobility of the average family in China will
be limited in the near future to how many people they can load on a bicycle,
As for rail transportation,
which has been the mode of choice for some time, long lines at train stations
greet ticket buyers and as the throngs push and shove for position, pickpockets
are able to relieve many of their cash. The rich, are able to hire either “line
standers” (those that will get tickets in exchange for an honorarium) or ticket
brokers who for some strange reason are always walking around with just the ticket
that is needed in their pocket. The price, about five times the going rate, but
it is certainly better if you can afford it than fighting the mobs.
Air-traffic though is a horse
of another color. An industry that has been growing at the rate of 20 percent
for a score of years is not to be overlooked. Between tourism and an ever more
mobile population, airports are being built and reformatted at breakneck speed.
The problem is that although an airport can be erected here or there, the air
traffic control system must address airspace relative to them all and the computer
capacity is just not present to do the job. Think about the logistics, the
air controllers in the United States have had a humongous time keeping track of
every plan and its flight pattern along with getting them up and down safely.
China is only a tad larger geographically than the United States but has a substantially
larger population. Just think about the logistical problem that they would face
if they had the same percentage of people taking to the air. Moreover, where would
they get the planes to transport them?
For the most part, air control
systems are not indigenous to China and the country is in the process of spending
billions of dollars in precious hard currency to get the job done. China is expected
to go from about a dozen airports with the capacity of handling large commercial
jets to 100 by the turn of the century, a monumental task. On the other hand,
their navigational systems better be in place and synchronized or a lot of metal
is going to strewn over the landscape. The major problem is the fact that airspace
in China is highly restricted and it is primarily reserved for the air force,
which controls over ninety percent. You can not have a situation where 90 per
cent of the air space is restricted and still safely fly people out of 100 airports
in a country only slightly larger than the United States. At present, on Beijing,
Guangzhou and Shanghai handle 40% of the nation’s air-traffic. The margin for
error becomes very small when the corridor that you are flying becomes clogged
or weather contaminated. How do you fly around the weather when you are obligated
to only travel in a straight line? Sounds like a kamikaze mission to me.
However, provincial leaders sometimes have interests that are diametrically
opposed to those of the central government. Although since the time of Mao, China
has had a policy based upon agricultural self-sufficiency, the fact is, farm products
dont pay the freight for infrastructure development. They provide sustenance
for the people but when you a country with over a billion mouths to feed, you
are lucky to keep their bellies full, forget about generating hard currency. Hard
currency that comes from the global sale of manufactured goods can provide the
people with enough to eat. The country not to long ago was basically a barter society with an
unwieldy language that does not allow a lot of computer latitude without a substantial
amount of tinkering. Things like calculators, computers and even cash registers
were rarely seen in this country until a few years ago. Because of the lack of
an imbedded technology bas, China suffers a perennial problem in their collection
of taxes from urban residents. However, when it comes to collecting real money
from farmers who mainly deal in the exchange of products, that is a horse of a
completely different structure. Moreover, China has recently had a problem with
the distribution of wealth and when you take a micro-economic look at the country,
it is literally divided into any number of slices, with a substantial amount of
overlap in numerous areas. As a generalization, the wealth is located in the eastern
part of the country and farming is done in west. The mineral resources are located
in the west but the shipping is predominantly in the east. Chinas customers
for their exports are located in the northeast and southeast and the products
that they buy are primarily finished goods which are produced in the east. However,
the raw materials that make up the finished goods usually come from the west.
China philosophically places very little value on raw materials,
farm output or energy. These essentials are contributed to those products that
create exportable items at what you could say are coolie wages. In
other words, the central government sets the values within the system at each
stage of a products production cycle. Because of the historic underpayment of
people from rural areas and the massive numbers of prisoners that receive no pay
at all, the basic stock for manufactured items is priced substantial below equivalent
world market prices. This could only occur in a system that is totally committed
to bringing in hard currency at any cost. In this case because of the logistics
involved, this usually comes at a substantial cost to those people living in the
western and southwestern regions of the country. The southeast has substantial potential but is almost an alien territory
operating within an otherwise synergistic society. What happens in the provinces
in the western and southwestern parts of the country is that they have neither
the income to help pay the expenses of the central government nor the ability
to even help themselves and thus live substandard existences. Because of this
anomaly, many of these provinces almost operate unilaterally relative to the central
government. In an effort to create goods that can produce income for the residents
of outlying provinces, their leaders often mandate the creation of their own factories
and in doing so more often than not, directly compete with the central governments
overall planning strategy. The factories are usually centered within quickly growing
cities where there has been little or no infrastructure planning. Worse yet, valuable
people are pulled off the farms in an effort to equalize the economic disparity
between regions. Sadly, this has resulted in the deterioration of agricultural
production, where China in less than a decade has gone from underfed to fed and
back again. While China can now purchase food in the worlds market with
its substantial hard currency reserves, the country is no longer agriculturally
self sufficient. Securities Stock prices in China have now been in the doldrums
for about a year to some degree following the lead of markets in the rest of the
world. The Chinese market has fallen approximately 30 percent from its highs and
the people of this country are not at all happy about what has happened. In spite
of this natural occurrence, stocks of state owned companies are still selling
a lofty price earnings ratio of 50-60 times earnings, about twice the price of
the Dow Jones. While a case can be made for the Chinese market to outperform its
more mature American counterpart due to the substantially higher projected growth
rate in Chinas gross domestic product, but in reality this market is for
the most part unregulated and hard numbers on earnings and sales are impossible
to come by. Moreover, there is a substantial fudge factor built into Chinese growth
numbers and the regulators still have much more work to do before investors in
China can be confident that what they see is what they are going to get. In the meantime, the Chinese Government has decided
to use the still inflated market as an alternative money raising vehicle. China
because they are supposed to be a Communist State goes about its privatization in a round-about manner.
Instead of selling state owned companies to independent buyers in an open market,
which would smack too much of free enterprise, they find that they can do much
better by floating these shares in the stock market and then selling whenever
they are in need of money for one project or another. Because of the fact that
this method of raising money is simpler than collecting taxes, a difficult job
at best in China, the rulers of the country are not particularly anxious to quench
the burning fires of speculation that exist within the population. As a matter
of fact, if anyone would raise their voice to harshly about Chinas stock
markets they could well wind up in jail or worse. Thus, the Chinese Government consistently twists
itself into a pretzel in order to communicate to the people their attempt at cleansing
the market place of evil doers and profiteers while in reality not doing much
of anything other than giving lip-service to its grandiose plans. However,
as long as they can collect enormous amounts of money by this bizarre form of
reverse taxation they will continue to work in the markets grey by feeding the
speculative passions of their people. If the government cant get the money
out from under the mattress in the form of taxes they can easily get their unwitting
citizens to take it out in order to invest in get rich trading schemes of stocks
that are controlled by the state. People that suggest that investors are throwing
their money away on overpriced securities or are investing in companies that they
know little about and which routinely have the accounting of their profits made
to order are routinely threatened by all segments of the population. God help
the stock market service that causes the substantial decline of one of the peoples
favorite investment choices. The can literally be burned at the stack for such
a blasphemous action in spite of the fact that they could be entirely accurate.
Interestingly enough, it is usually the American
educated Chinese that return to the Mainland as employees of large financial conglomerates
after getting a thorough financial education abroad that get the brunt of the
criticism. When these folks talk about the market being too high, they are blamed
for wanting knock prices down to buy up cheap shares and when they recommend a
security they are said to be doing it to dump their shares on an unsuspecting
public. This is indeed a risky company to be an honest securities analyst. The
Financial Times in an interview with Yang Fan, a senior researcher at the Chinese
Academy of Social Sciences, someone should have known better said, People
should be wary of certain returnees, They earn a high salary from
foreigners but do things which make individual investors suffer. Sounds
like the right kind of thinking to me. Corruption Shenyang is Chinas fourth largest city and
the home to over 8-million people. The politicians in this city are for the most
part, party hacks who conspicuously toe the line while continuing to ring up the
votes their hierarchy in Beijing whenever there are local and national elections.
Party officials in Shenyang, for this reason have always been highly regarded
by the senior politicians in Chinas capital. However, when it was found
that the mayor of Shenyang, Mu Suixin had secreted over $6-million in gold bars
within his two country houses along with hundreds of high-price Rolex watches
and an antique collection fit for the Taj Mahal, there were early signs that he
had gone a tad too far and his benefactors in the capital were sure to pull the
plug on the entire corrupt Shenyang political organization. What happened in this city was impossible to deny
as computer disks were recovered which gave chapter and verse as to the illegal
manner in which these assets were converted to the mayors possession. This
was especially disappointing to his associates in Beijing because of the fact
that Mu had originally been a graduate of Qinghua University, literally the top
school in China, he had been cited by the United Nations in 1999 for his work
in improving housing in Shenyang and had been sainted by western media for saving
many of Chinas unprofitable state owned industries by using modern economic
techniques. This in turn provided substantial employment to the area. Because
of similar problems throughout the country, the leaders in Beijing had always
pointed at Mu as being a sea of tranquility amidst a storm of bribery and deceit.
This did not play well in the Forbidden City. In addition, this public disclosure caused Beijing
no end of consternation because officials there were in the midst of another cleanup
operation in which thieves along with unethical politicians were being rounded
up and summarily shot. However, there was the ultimately determining factor that
Shenyang always had swung the
vote in the right direction in the past and for that, there was a debt that was
owed. It was at this point that the leaders in Beijing made a series of
strange decisions. Naturally, under the circumstances, the first that they ordered
done was the arrest of those that had brought them the evidence of the mayors
intransigence. Zhou Wei, a retired official who was 71-years of age was responsible
for blowing the whistle on corrupt police officers in Shenyang and for his efforts
he received a two year jail sentence to be served in a labor camp. His partner
in the crime of uncovering evil doers, Jiang Weiping, got an even stiffer sentence
as it was he, as a journalist that exposed the entire corruption machine in the
highly read Hong Kong magazine, Frontline. For this anti-Chinese action he was given a sentence
of nine-years in jail. The logic of Jiangs sentence seemed to send the message,
if there is corruption in this country, tell your story in Beijing first and dont go to the newspapers
with it. After the Beijings leaders had addressed those
whom they believed were the guiltiest in this affair, Zhou and Jiang, they got
down to the more serious business of how to show the people that they were taking
action but they had to do it without taking apart the well-oiled political machine
that had been delivering the vote. Naturally there were going to be certain untouchables.
All those that had closed ties to senior officials in the Chinese Government in
Beijing were allowed to walk without even being questioned no matter how involved
they were in this matter. Most Shenyang officials were allowed to remain at their
posts without even giving up a days pay. A new mayor was brought in that
Beijing felt could get along well with the entrenched political system without
notice of the fact that he too had been accused of protecting corrupt officials
in his previous job as mayor of Dalian, another large city in the same province.
This was a rather grievous situation and as the
Washington Post pointed out in a story by John Pomfret: Corruption in Shenyang involved
almost every government department and ran the gamut from smuggling, to buying
and selling official positions, to stealing farmland for big development projects,
to rigging construction contracts, to basic theft from government coffers. The mayor, his wife, daughter and
lover, his executive vice mayor, the police, prosecutors, judges, customs officers,
construction bureaus, private companies, bankers and local legislators were all
on the take, according to a government report. In his 17 trips to gambling dens
in Macao and Las Vegas, the executive deputy mayor, Ma Xiangdong, was executed
late last year, blew $4 million in public funds a source close to the investigation
said. And yet he was rather laid back in his efforts to
cull money from the public coffers when compared with others. Ma had an associate
by the name of Liu Yong who was a local legislator during the day but headed what
was probably the largest crime syndicate in province at night. His gang of toughs
were responsible under his direct orders for killing at least 35 people who wouldnt
willingly give up property that he needed to develop for a real estate complex.
He had become the largest dealer in smuggled cars from North Korea and once they
had made it safely over the border he would sell this contraband merchandise at
the local convenience stores which he owned. His astronomical profits were also
often spent at some of the plushest Vegas casinos. For unknown reasons he has
yet to be even be tried. The mayors wife was also in on the thievery
big time. When one of the higher bids was approved to build a highway around the
city, the contractor was granted it on the condition that the materials would
be purchased only from the Mu Suixins wife, Zhang Yafei, who in reality
didnt know cement from fertilizer. This was evidenced by the fact that within
six-months of the time that the highway was completed, almost the entire length
of this brand spanking new road split neatly down the middle and became riddled
with substantial potholes making in totally unusable. And the citys first
lady was not done yet. There is an old saying in China, like mother like daughter
and Mu Yang, was a spoiled child at best. When she grew up she was always demanding
the nicest things for herself and her parents were always condescending to her
wishes. However, her mother grew tired of being constantly
nagged by her daughter about getting a lot of money and talked her husband into
granting his brainless offspring the contract to beautify the city with brand
new lighting and billboards. When the citys lighting blew a fuse and the
billboards were wrecked in the first minor storm that hit Shenyang, an investigation
was hastily begun in spite of daddys best efforts to put the matter to rest.
It was found that all of the contractors were kicking back far too much to Mu
so that they couldnt afford to erect the billboards with proper materials.
Further research found the millions of dollars that had been paid off to her and
was now drawing interest in a convenient Hong Kong bank. Naturally, this caused Mu to catch the first available
plane headed for the United States and that is where she is still happily ensconced
even today. Intelligence relative to the supposedly quiet investigation
was like a sieve and soon everyone involved in the matter was heading in an easterly
direction along with their money. They now call the city of Las Vegas, Shenyang
East because of the numerous politicians from that city that now call the American
gambling capital their home. However, the Mayor himself developed an ugly case
of lung cancer from chain-smoking cigarettes for most of his life and the Chinese
Government seems to have determined that this was punishment enough for what he
had done. Thus, when all was said and done, the whistle blowers are now doing
substantial hard time for their cleanup efforts, a few senior politicians were
caught before they departed for the United States and will serve some time in
jail as well, but most of the characters in this untoward drama are now living
the good life in the United States, hardly a fitting punishment. Chinas
attempt to cleanup their political corruption still has a long way to go. However,
probably the casinos in Vegas will eventually take upon themselves to separate
these profiteering politicians from their ill gotten gains. In spite of the fact that many of the people involved
this fiasco got off lightly because of their political connections, Chinas
leaders are quick to point out that they have taken a much sterner hand when it
comes to corruption and other crimes. The Associated Press in piece entitled,
Chinese Law-Enforcement Officials Say Courts Dont Meet Expectations
written on March 11, 2002 had some interesting quotes primarily from Xiao Yang
president of the Supreme Peoples Court: Mr. Xiao said Chinas
courts handled 729,958 criminal cases last year, an increase of 30.8% over 2000.
Of 340,571 people sentenced for serious crimes, 150,913 got the death penalty
or at least five years in prison, he said
Prosecutors investigated 36,447
corruption cases involving 40,195 people and funds worth 4.1 billion Yuan ($496
million) in 2001, according to Mr. Han, the prosecutor. That compared with 45,113
corru0ption cases investigated in 2000. The Communist Partys top graft-fighter,
Wei Jianxing, said last week that the number of corruption cases peaked in 1993-1998
and is now declining. Still, many graft cases are handled outside the courts.
The official Xinhua News Agency said recently that 175,364 party officials were
investigated for corruption in 2001. "Last year, 20,120 people were
convicted of bribe-taking and embezzlement and 995 court officials were punished
for corruption or other crimes, of whom 85 faced criminal prosecution. Mr. Xiao
reported. He said prosecutors and police focused on rooting out officials allied
to criminal gangs or who offered protection to gangs, smuggling rings and producers
of fake products
In a renewed drive against organized crime, known in China
as black societies, Mr. Xiao said courts handled 350 cases of mafia-style
crime in 2001, a six-fold increase over 2000. However, in spite of the glowing statistics that
seem to show a serious attempt by prosecutors in China to reign in crimes of all sorts, the type of offenses that would tend
to hurt Chinas relations with bankers
have become increasingly more serious. A number of foreign bankers have been killed
in supposedly safe areas of China. Retail Sales One of the problems that has historically plagued
China is the lack of any national branding. The problem which has been brought
about primarily because of Chinas previously, almost feudal system of transportation,
a lack of specialty outlets and the historic anathema towards national advertising.
An advertiser that does national advertising is playing to a market for the most
part that he couldnt even get his goods too even if the people that saw
his commercials wanted to purchase them. For most part, advertising in this country
most be directed towards those cities which form the national distribution system
itself. These would be those cities primarily on the national highway grid and
would therefore be located primarily in the Eastern sector of the country. Beyond the pure logistics of the matter is the fact
that local products are produced by regional workers. Political chiefs in these
regions are not anxious for their citizens to be thrown out of work so that a
certain brand loyalty to local products has become instilled into the population.
Those that load up in the larger cities with more economical national brands can
be severely criticized and most unload their vans when they get home in the darkness
of the night in order to avoid being ostracized by their neighbors. This is not
to say that the urbanization of the entire country is not happening at a break-neck
pace, but for the time being, certain concepts can be premature and resistance
can be high especially when local jobs are on the line. This thinking to some
degree has hurt the national effort to bring down the price of unit sales even
further but there are so many people already on the grid that this has not become
for the first order of business for the nations leaders. However, there are certain areas of endeavor in
which there are no regional or national products available and in those sectors
there is unlimited opportunity for entrepreneurs to ply their trade. One of the
early success stories is a Chinese company called Babycare which was founded by
a young American expatriate living in China. Babycare specializes in three distinct
product categories all of which have been overlooked in this bourgeoning economy.
The first is a wide range of nutritional products that carry the Babycare label.
Matthew Estes the companys thirty-five year old founder who formerly worked
in China as a salesman for SmithKline Beecham Pharmaceuticals, arranged to bring
in some of the best known Chinese nutritionists and doctors to push the product
on television, the news media and in the form a Chinese multi-level marketing
setup in which everyone is an evangelistic employee not a commissioned agent.
The food products themselves are more mundane but
they are branded and through the success of the nutritional supplements, the name
Babycare has developed substantial cache in this country. Moreover, everything
with that brand name on it is assumed to be a notch above what one can purchase
at the local store. This branding has also given a substantial push to the companys
toy divisions which is geared to toddlers of the age of six or less. These toys
are a technically an improvement above what is usually available in Chinese stores
as most of them have degree of educational value attached to them. Education to
one child homes is a significant buzzword. The entire product line is enhanced by the companys
website which provides vital information to expectant mothers and those women
with young children on subjects that many in China believe to be taboo. The site
has educational forums, a series of chat rooms on diverse subjects that allow
peers to converse with each other and specialists who are brought in at varying
intervals to talk about specific problems that may be facing various women with
children or who are pregnant. When compared to the only available alternative,
the state run clinics, which are about as personal as a frog, Babycare is providing
a valuable service to young Chinese women who literally have no where else to
go. The companys products are sold through distribution
centers located in many of the larger cities which also double as classrooms.
The women are taught about the type of nutrition that their children will be needing
and then can conveniently load up on Babycare products in the back room before
they leave. This unusual distribution characteristic sets the company apart from
other retailers who manage to get by because they may be the only game in town.
Equally important are the facts that large families are no longer the rule in
China and the economy has provided substantially more disposable income to new
parents. Having only one child is reason enough for parents to attempt to do the
very best possible for their progeny. In a one child country, this translates
to the fact that there are four grandparents for every offspring, and Chinese
grandparents have a history of being very doting when it comes to their grandchildren.
Success in this country can often be measured by
the schools that the young people eventually attend and the number of degrees
that they are able to accumulate. For this reason, Babycares largest seller
has become Nutrimed which is a supplement aimed at the market for brain and eye
development. Because of focused marketing, the elimination of the middleman
and a zealous sales staff, Mr. Estes along with his corporate investors, which
include Bank of America have been able to bring a substantial cash return to the
bottom line while avoiding so many of the pitfalls in the Chinese Marketplace.
The company is expanding like Topsy and doing it primarily on its enormous cash
flow. Television The glue that binds China together is television and in spite of the fact that shows originated
in this country have had a tendency to be bland, uninteresting and dogmatic, they
have been the only game in town. Dull serials have dominated Chinese television
from the very beginning, for the most part carrying some form of moral message
that tends to make the shows unpalatable to even the most self-confessed stay-at-home.
However, as we have pointed out earlier, many people in this country are utilizing
cable and getting through to the rest of the world. Thus television in China was forced to compete with the fare offered elsewhere and most recently
television in China has become more commercial and at the highest end of the pecking order
are what are called the reality shows. These are shows that are filmed live and
pit individuals, couples or groups against each other for what, by Chinese standards
are substantial prizes. These prizes can be cars, homes and even cash awards of
over $100,000. Moreover, to the Chinese these are extremely substantial rewards
and the demand to get on these shows has become overwhelming to say the least.
While a number of them are already in the can, the
problem from the beginning was the fact that in order to win one of these Survivor
type contests, it took not only a strong physical durability but also a character
that included the ability of doing your competitors in by any means at your disposal.
This concept was originally totally alien to Chinese life which at least superficially
taught that everyone should pull together to get the job done. Ratings for those
shows which left out the darker side of human nature did not seem to fare well
as well on television as did those that contained none of the good things in life
such as scheming, conniving and underhanded dealing. Eventually, audience ratings
determined that human nature at its very worst should be exposed for what it really
was and the programs ratings proceeded to explode. The original show in that genre, Shangri-La was
changed to allow for the watchers more basic natures. The eventual success of
Shangri-La led to a new rush to air these types of shows and in a recent article
in the Wall Street Journal by Leslie Chang, they were described as follows: Escape to ancient roads
will feature 16 contestants racing in jeeps in the uninhabited reaches of northern
Tibet. In each daily segment, one person gets voted off the show by the others;
the fastest driver each day wins a car. Another show, Panning for Gold
will plunk four Chinese contestants down in the U.S., where they will sell Chinese
products while regularly tallying their financial status. China
Central Television, the state-owned national broadcaster, last month started airing,
The Golden Apple, a weekly series that sends two teams on a treasure
hunt, with the winners getting a $1,200 scholarship. The shows creator,
a private company called Beijing Qiuxian Advertising Arts, is reworking it to
sharpen the head-to-head combat between the teams. We want the two teams
to resemble two armies facing each other, says Wang Wei, the companys
managing director. It takes some concessions
to the cautiousnessor prudishnessof officialdom to survive on that
frontier. (Reality shows with personal conflict) For example, Strategy of
Love, Chinas nod to the Fox networks Temptation Island,
will feature only two couples among the 20 contestants, with the others unattached.
In contrast, the express point of Temptation Island was to tempt couples
into romantic liaisons with attractive singles. Mr. Chen (The head of Beijing
Weihan Cultural Broadcasting Company) says in China, the prospect of breaking
up too many couples would be seen as morally unacceptable. It would seem that the Chinese are getting their
act together on all fronts. They will soon become aware of all of the bad things
in life that the rest have known for many years. Perhaps this will make them even
more ferocious competitors in the economic arena. This is could turn out to be
a fate worse than death. Fast Food American Style Years ago, no one would ever have thought that the
Chinese would become more American than Asian in their thinking, but strangely
that is what has occurred. As China embraced the rest of civilization it was a
stretch to believe that this historically inward leaning country would have ever
chosen western ideas over those of their neighbors. However, the American life
style has become cache to the now substantial middle class that has arisen in
China. Fast food seems to fit their lifestyle while Chop Suey and Sushi have almost
become passé. All you have to do is look at the statistics supplied by the
New York Times in late February of 2002. There are now 80 McDonalds
in Beijing alone, a figure that has accelerated greatly in the past two years.
The number of Kentucky Fried Chicken outlets has increased by 100 a year for the
last 2-years to about 600. Shanghai and Beijing each have more than two dozen
Starbucks. Most Chinese never drank coffee until Starbucks came to town in 1999,
selling small lattes for over $2
It seems that for whatever the reason, the Chinese
have fallen in love with things American. This s particularly odd when you consider
the great distrust that Beijing held America in. However, the flip side of the
coin is the great entrepreneurial skills that have been demonstrated by American
entrepreneurs for breaking down the doors of a market once consider closed to
the west. Other American businesses have performed equally as well as the above.
Price Smart, Pizza Hut and Coca Cola have done sensationally making products previously
unheard of in this country into household names. They have done so well that according
to Beijings Horizon Market Research, nearly half of all Chinese children
under 12 identified McDonalds as a domestic brand. Political views aside, China in sociological terms is rapidly becoming an annex of New
York City and a traveler here would find little to stare at in the major eastern
seaboard cities that he wouldnt find in his home town. While this
may becoming a problem to Chinese politicians that on occasion have been know
to paint the United States as the Worlds bully, the people have developed
a love affair with things American. By combining high quality products with unique
western style down-home marketing, the west has won the hearts of the Chinese
population; however the jury is still out when it comes to the people that really
count; those living in the Forbidden City. They are the only ones that really
count when the votes are all in and they can turn off the spigot as easily as
they turned it on. The
Law and Fast Food In
spite of the fact that China has developed a love affair with American Fast Foods,
once in a while the love affair and Chinese laws come to a harsh separation of
the ways. From a fundamental point of view, China was never big on deals
being reduced to writing and if the local politicians and the entrepreneur could
agree on terms, this was more often than not sealed with a handshake and there
was never a particular need to delve further into the transaction. As the legal
system in China became more sophisticated because of business expansion, foreign
influences and the confluence of both and the import and export market, many of
those matters which were previously left to handshakes and the honor system have
been rudely altered and unless they have been meticulously reduced to writing,
totally in conformity with the existing code, there can be serious problems. As
times have changed many of those that got into the game early failed to see the
handwriting on the wall and did not revert from handshakes to written contracts,
naively believing that China would continue to stay with its old ways. However,
this could not happen in a modern state and has caused no end of confusion.
The
New York Times did a story on this change entitled, "The New China Can Look
Like the Old", by Chris Buckley on May 2, 2002. In part it went like this:
"Frank Miu, the holder of the A&W
franchise here, may have met his match early Monday morning,
and it was not McDonald's or KFC. After a decade of building up a chain of American-style
root beer and sandwich stores, promoted here as "the father of American fast
food," and surviving an onslaught of competition, Mr. Miu found himself staring
in bewilderment and shock as a squadron of 30 officials from a local court swept
into one of his outlets in a busy commercial district in northwest Beijing. While
police officers videotaped the small crowd of restaurant workers and passers-by
gathered outside, the court officials seized the restaurant's tables, chairs and
cooking equipment and sealed the doors. At the bottom of this case is a lease
dispute, and those can turn thorny almost anywhere, of course. But Mr. Miu's predicament
illustrates a larger danger facing Western companies here: crosscurrents developing
in the traditionally vague, indirect and informal way business deals are often
done here and the requirements of a more legalistic court system that sometimes
intervenes precipitously in disputes." Interestingly
enough, Mr. Miu should have known better as he is a Harvard-educated lawyer and
he and his partner were trying to do business in what they call "Beijing
style" a form of agreement that is understood between the parties by not
memorialized on paper. This was a rather serious mistake for a person that had
always argued with his clients to "get it in writing". However, the
fact that the agreement was not in writing would not have made a tad's difference
if it were not for the fact that Miu had tied up a valuable piece of property
at a fraction of what it was now worth. People with better connections than Miu
obviously wanted the property and went to the landlord and inquired about a lease.
The landlord indicated that he had a handshake with Miu. They correctly indicated
that a handshake wasn't worth the paper that it was printed on in a Chinese court
with a trumped up case and a paid off judge. They also correctly informed the
landlord that cash speaks loudest and offered him an amount that he could not
refuse. The
landlord went to court and complained that Miu had not been willing to renew his
lease in spite of constant requests and that he should be dispossessed from
the property. The court seemed to buy that argument and another piece of
Chinese history had gone by the boards. While handshake agreements are still all
the rage here, they do leave the parties to the agreement open to outsiders who
know how to manipulate the new-fangled system to their best advantage. Having
a Harvard Law Degree here is an inferior position to knowing city officials and
having some big bucks. Undoubtedly a new fast food palace will arise from the
ashes of the shuttered A&W store here in spite of the fact that officials
have said that the property would be converted to a drug store. You Bet. Rental Cars So what if a Chinese couple decide to see the countryside
around them on a lovely weekend and have no car, what do they do? Well, there
are a lot of busses around that will drop them off pretty much anywhere and if
they are in the right place at the right time, they can even find one going in
the opposite direction so that they can head for home when their day is over.
In addition, there are trains in China but they are much less punctual and the
stops are few and far between and usually when you are left off, you still have
quite a ways to go so this is not a good solution. There is an occasional hotel
around, but travel between cities is only something that has come upon the scene
recently and as the country starts spreading its economic muscle around, some
accommodation must be made to the future. As tourism increases the number of western
style hotel accommodations will dramatically increase but for the moment, they
are not part of the national strategy other than for the very large cities. The future for middle class car-less families in
China may well be Hertz or Avis Rental Car Companies. As part of the recently
arrived at WTO agreements, the Chinese Government has allowed the two rental car
companies to set up shop in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou. Living
in the United States one really has to wonder how salesman in China really got
around before the rental car initiative got going. Well, the answer in actuality
is that they didnt, up until recently roads were poorly paved, gas stations
were few and far between and bad weather could inundate the highways for days
at a time. Effectively the salesmen was forced to work small territories that
were located close to their home base. However, the fact that the rental car companies
are moving into China will not be any panacea for international travelers anytime
soon. It seems that at the beginning at least, travelers will be obliged to drop
off rental cars wherever they are picked up. International drivers licenses will
not be honored so if someone really wants to drive through China they are going
to have to pass the local driving exams and most of them are only given in Chinese.
However, in spite of this, there is some light at the end of the tunnel as China
has indicated that it will allow foreign renters to start using their international
drivers licenses sometime in the unforeseeable future, whenever that is.
Tourism is probably the ultimate use for a rental
car in this country as they have a road system that was created far in advance
of any possible usage. The best available statistics seems to indicate that they
are not destined to be fully utilized for the next several decades or even longer.
Thus, highways here are a dream, modern, multi-laned, non-access and few restrictions
of any kind. Movement that only a few years ago was restricted by both regulations
and terrain is now a vision to behold. As tourists start to pick up on this breathtaking
opportunity, China will be forced into the pleasant task of creating fast food
shops, tourist hotels and mega-gas stations sprinkled along the countryside to
please hungry and tired travelers. Who knows, they might even decide to make the
truly western traveler feel more at home by charging for driving on their magnificent
highways. However, as this unfolds, it will only help push Chinas economy
even faster as the tourist dollars, now only a trickle start to really roll in.
However, while the countryside is a dream, the cities
can be a nightmare. Chinas indigenous traffic is still in a bicycle mode
and cars will be forced to vie with their two-wheeled competition for parking.
Traffic patterns that contain endless streams of bicycles is also much slower
moving and the rental car contingent will have to bear with it as the torrent
slowly moves along. The bicycles in some instances have taken to the superhighways
as well and this tends to cause some dangerous conditions. I for one would not
want to be the foreign tourist that knocks down a cyclist and is forced to explain
what happened to the local Chinese Police. These folks can sometimes get very
cranky and jails in China are not for the weak. In the meantime, rental cars may for a while still
be the hobby of the salesmen working for large corporations with lots of money
or for only the flushest of foreign tourists. Cars are much more expensive in
China then they are most anywhere else because of enormous tariffs that the country
charges and because of that, the rental companies will be forced to pay high prices
for admission into the business. And yet, as prices eventually fall as they are
predicted to do, the car rental companies may not be able to receive anything
near the economic price necessary to cope with rental fees as we know them when
selling their used merchandise. In the United States for example, most of the
time car-rental companies no almost to the penny what they are going to get for
their surplus cars when they sell them in about 2 ½ years. This is added into
the price charged for rentals and the companies are able to project a tidy profit.
This is harder to do when taxes are in a state of change and prices a thought
to be going to drop precipitously when these artificial barriers to commerce are
removed. Thus, rental fees will originally not be set at a price that can be afforded
by the faint of heart and getting proper insurance may be an even greater problem.
However, all that aside, China does not have a national credit card network and although this is not
a deal killer that will stultify rental car use until they system is established.
There is little question though that this as with all other problems in this enigmatic
country will get worked out and at this rate, China
is soon going look a lot like everywhere else. Better get there early. The Political Process As a youngster growing up in Chicago, I read in the daily papers
headlines about a phantom payroll scandal. These turned out to be people that
had died and were buried in various cemeteries around town. In spite of this fact
they were a very active part of the cities voting contingent and in addition to
voting they were also paid a significant sum to work for the City of Chicago. This was the era of the
elder, Richard Daley who ruled the city with an iron fist and if you werent
for him and the Democratic Party, you were thought to be the enemy. I thought,
What better why to get through college than to volunteer to a phantom parole
and I wouldnt even have to share a cemetery plot to get involved.
I naively marched into city hall, nowhere near old enough to vote and announced
to my prey, an overstuffed ward healer that my family had been voting democratic
for 30-years and I had been voting the straight ticket for the last five. I was
in law school and needed the bucks to pay my tuition. Without the slightest hesitation,
the overly fat man sitting in a rocking chair at city hall leaned back while clinching
the largest cigar you have ever seen with both his uppers and lowers and announced,
Kid if you want to be on a phantom payroll, you have to work for the party.
I was about to question him relative to those that were getting weekly checks
while buried under 6-feet of sod and living in various cemeteries around town
but thought the better of it and decided that if you cant beat them join
them. That was a true story about a time long past and
an American political system that worked because it was both corrupt but extremely
flexible. Politicians around the country knew that Dick Daley could bring home
the bacon and he did it year after year after year. I voluntarily became part
of that system in spite of the fact that everything that it stood for was diametrically
opposed to my upbringing. However, this indeed is the way things still operate
in China. In order to be elected to office, it is almost suicidal to run unless
you are a card carrying member of the party. The party in China usually contains
the acronym, The Peoples this or the Peoples
that. Sadly, none of the ruling partys platforms have anything at all to
do with the people. They only are a methodology of perpetuating a life style that
has become comfortable for Chinas leaders. Historically, anyone that was motivated to take
on the politically entrenched and was not a card carrying Peoples This
or Peoples That was historically taken aside by their employer and
told that it would not be healthy to run for office and that if one did, their
working career might abruptly end abruptly or even worse. Occasionally someone
was stupid enough or given that, passionate enough to want to do some good deeds
and ran in spite of those threats, veiled or otherwise. After all in the Chinese
system you only needed a few people to sign your petition to be put on the ballot.
Surprisingly in China the magic number of petitioners seems to be only ten but
for the most part finding ten people that would be willing to lose their jobs
in exchange for a nebulous endorsement were very few indeed. The catch seemed
to be that those people that signed your petition usually wound up disappearing
into political retraining centers. And even if all of your friends did not vanish,
five will get you ten that you lost your job and without financial means could
no longer campaign. However, in the rare case that you would get as far as the
election, all voters were definitively told that a vote for you would result in
their becoming irrelevant in the workplace. Obviously there were not a lot of
non-party members that could stand up to this kind of pressure. Historically there
have been literally none, that is until very recently. However, China to some degree has recently liberalized
its voting process and in spite of the fact that most elections in the country
only have uncontested ballots with life long politicians running for offices that
they cannot lose because they are unopposed. Today every once in a while someone
comes along that seems to have no fear of retribution, delivers the requisite
number of signatories to his petition and miraculously makes it through the starting
gate and gets elected. For the most part though, these wild cards create utter
havoc within the system with their constant cries for liberalization and honesty,
two of the most hated things in the Chinese hierarchy, but yet, there has been
a small crack in the dam and the countrys political climate is starting
to undergoing dramatic change ever quickening change. Not a lot yet, but the trickle
may soon become a torrent and when it does we may well see a country that has
become an anarchy not a government. Li Yujing, deputy secretary general of the Guangdong
Peoples Congress put the matter into prospective. Ten years ago, whatever
the local government submitted to us we would approve. Even if we saw great need
for a certain type of legislation, all we did was wait. Now not only do we review
laws, weve started to write Laws on our own. We call in outside experts.
We hold open hearing. We demand to see budgets. China appears to be
coming a democracy of sorts. I am sure that they will eventually find it as difficult
to deal with as we have. China has a rather unique political situation somewhat similar to
when an American plaintiff is not represented in court by counsel (pro se).
The American justice seems to adjust to these hapless souls and becomes especially
forgiving when dealing with these people. There also seems to be an ad hoc appeal
process for anything that happens in Chinese life. The trouble with the process
is that it is often thankless, unrewarding and frustrating but nevertheless it
is there and it remains a way of life. You can literally petition for anything
you want in China and can start at the lowest level bureaucrat in your district
and carry your project all the way up to the top of the ladder. It is somewhat
like the American Federal Court system appeal process, where if you are not satisfied
with a decision at a lower level you are welcome to continue on up the ladder
until you have exhausted the process. In China, the system is more open ended and can
go on as long as the appellatives have the appetitive to endure endless frustration
and ridicule. Possibly one case in a hundred receives redress in China using the
petition methodology but eventually certain hardheaded people have made the process
something more than one of trial and error. They have learned the in and outs
of the process and found out that by becoming an enormous pain in the butt they
have increased that chances of being heard and possibly succeeding. However, there are substantially risks within the
system for being too vociferous in crying foul. The penalties can range from getting
locked up in either a penal or mental institution to disappearing from sight altogether.
The ideal situation for someone that wants to get something done using this
process is to gradually work the petition up the line while relentlessly papering
everyone in sight. Eventually, if properly thought out the paperwork should be
eventually taken to a reliable newspaper and an article printed about the terrible
situation that the petitioner is concerned about, which is more often than not,
local political corruption. Once armed with copiousness public relations material along with
numerous signatories to ones petitions, the petitioner must then appear
in Beijing during an important conference. The best time is usually during the
National Peoples Conference. This is the only time when the higher-ups
might pay attention to us. I knew it was dangerous, but this is the only road
open to us. Similar sentiments were offered by dozens of petitioners here, clutching
heavily thumbed files filled with accounts of murders and rapes gone unpunished,
wrongful imprisonment and torture, gross medical neglect, unpaid wages and compensation,
confiscated land and livestock, unchecked corruption and political vendettas. Many of these petitioners eventually become hardcore.
They just dont know when to give up and turn to begging to be in close propinquity
to the office that they are allowed to visit with their complaints on a once a
month basis. Interestingly enough, in spite of the hardships endured by
these people, the number of visits by petitioners is constantly rising and last
year hit almost 200,000 individual visits which is up over 30% from the previous
year. However, while the numbers continue to rise, the patience of the government
is getting shorter and eventually, these nomads will wear out their welcome and
are then sent in many different directions. For many, this will permanently end
their quest for justice. The land is seemingly filled with frustrated Don Quixotes
that similarly to the fictional character are in a never ending battle against
the inanimate windmills that make up the Chinese justice system.
Wealth
DistributionIn a country with no middle class, the average urbanite earns more
than twice as much money as his rural cousin. In real terms, farm wages are substantial
less than they were as recently as five years ago and the people are unhappy to
say the least. To make matters even worse, the price that Chinese farmers are
getting for their products has been dropping like a lead balloon while the amount
that both the central and provincial government are trying to collect from the
farmers in taxes has spiraled nearly out of control. And in the unkindest cut
of all, the farmers have started vocalizing their dissent and in the past, that
has eventually led to bad things happening to the central government, and no one
is more aware of what happens in China when the farmers are up in arms than those
in the Forbidden City. Nervousness abides but solutions remain fleetingly obscure.
In order to head off disaster, China willing to try anything, went
to a flat tax of 8.4% and eliminated all of the other taxes that local bureaucrats
were want to throw into the mix. In many cases, this made things even worse. In
most areas, there was no longer enough money to run the local governments so on
the sly, officials initiated what might be called off-the-books taxes. When the
effect of the flat tax and the off-the-book extras that were being charged were
added together, it literally turned out that the more successful you became, the
sooner you went bankrupt. Because of the insensitivities of the system, most small
farmers have been forced into taking another job to support their families. However,
in the areas where there is no prospect of another job, this becomes a horse of
a different color. WaterIn the old days, China used of system of well borings to bring up
the much needed water that fed the crops. When water ran low, the well was dug
a little deeper or a new one was sunk relatively close to the old one. This would
only work for so long and as time went by, the water tables gradually dropped
and deeper and deeper wells had to be drilled. Moreover, there were very few water
treatment plants so that the reservoirs, the rivers, the lakes and the wells had
become increasingly polluted as heavy industry dumped contaminated water back
into the system. In addition, there was no system of water recycling and no pipelines
or canals to move the vast amounts of water necessary for irrigational requirements.
In short, China had become highly industrialized but had not provided
the most important item for its continued growth, the careful utilization of its
water resources. In many areas of the country, water rationing has already commenced
and after several years of substantial drought, there are millions of people without
adequate drinking water. Back to back crop failures have occurred in numerous
areas because of the countrys inability to shift its water resources to
other locations during dry periods, China is probably more susceptible to weather
driven economic dislocations that any other semi-industrialized country on the
planet. This situation will only get worse as more people leave their farms, a
wealthier country demands premium crops that soak up more water while the industrial
complex continues to lubricate itself on H2O. Redistribution of water resources comes at a heavy price and for
example, the cost to insure that Chinas capital Beijing is not caught short
of the precious liquid will come to a tidy $3 billion in the next several years
all by itself. One of the reasons that China was so late at attacking this problem
was the fact that its own statistical data was highly flawed and did not show
that this problem would occur for several more decades. However, not many years
ago, had you asked a Chinese economist whether the kind of economic growth that
is occurring in China could either happen or be sustained, he would have reported
you to the authorities for being crazy. Moreover, in this type of system, there are substantial rewards for
meeting and or exceeding the goals set by the central government. As the provincial
leadership was serendipitously moving out of agriculture and into heavier industry,
they still had to report to Beijing that they were continuing to follow the
plan. Thus, national agriculture production continued to meet lofty goals
in spite of the fact that smaller areas were being cultivated by less people producing
undesirable crops not called for in the grand scheme. As an example of how skewed
these statistics can become; China has 31 provinces and each of these provinces
must report its gross domestic product to the central government in intimate detail.
In spite of this quest for accuracy, even though the country reported an increase
in gross domestic product of 7.1%, every single one of Chinas provinces
reported that they beat this number. This is an extreme case of the hyperinflating
economic statistics. With figures like these, it is a stretch to believe that
any number that comes out of China can be relied upon for anything serious. IndustrializationChina meads out heavy penalties to those that dont make their
numbers but because the figures that are reported to the central government have
become so skewed because of the incentivization, China has been forced to create
new legislation outlawing the fudging of statistics. The China State Statistics
Bureau in the summer of 2001 announced that there would be severe penalties and
prosecution of any bureaucrats that fudged numbers in either direction. They also
warned provincial leaders that they would be conducting in depth on the spot surveys
of the statistics that were being provided and substantial jail time could result
if the governments survey orchestrated figures were substantially in variance
with that of the province. However, it has become more difficult for even the regional bureaucrats
to keep up with the fast paced changes in China. Local leaders had long ago figured
out that Maos idea of a planned economy did not work any better in China
than it did in Russia. These were chalked up as interesting dreams with no reality
attached to them. In spite of specific government mandated objectives, the system
is rapidly spinning out of control with central government planning being allocated
to the garbage pail by the provincial and local leaders. Recent statistics show
that almost 1,000 new and for the most part illegal businesses (red-hat firms)
are started everyday by industrious Chinese entrepreneurs that are sick and tired
of working for state enterprises. In spite of the fact that these businesses are not part of the plan,
they are more than tolerated, they
are encouraged by government silence. The provincial leaders see this swing to
the right as the creation of tax paying entities, but at the same time are aware
that production goals in certain areas become compromised. The current thinking
though is that if provincial leaders can bring home the economic bacon while both
supporting themselves and sending a little something in the form of taxes to Beijing,
the guys in the Walled City will not quibble. However, in spite of the benefits
that may be provided by the red-hats, they are only discussed in hushed
tones because they operate in opposition to the basic system.
These contemporary capitalists in China have become so successful
that in many provinces, state companies have been permitted to totally atrophy;
something that was inconceivable only a few years ago. As the state companies
close or just plain die of neglect, their workers go to work for the new entrepreneurs
in many cases who have created businesses that produce the same items that were
produced in the states now shuttered facility, but manufacture the items
profitably. Everything works better and as the quality, the quantity and the tax
payments to the state improve heads, are turned the in the other direction as
not to notice what has just transpired. Thus, whos to complain. It turns
out that the answer is not a soul, but just dont get caught talking about
it. Statistics show that these privatized companies are now producing
almost 20% of Chinas gross domestic product up from literally zilch just
a decade ago. Moreover, when this statistic is combined with the production that
has emerged from foreign joint ventures along with other non-indigenous sources,
it shows that almost 50% of all Chinese goods and services come from businesses
that not only didnt exist only a short time ago but were illegal.
In addition, each one of these enterprises probably took a small
piece out of a state-run business and yet, we have not really heard a murmur from
the central government relative to reigning in this practice. While in principal
their is probably a lot of mumbling going in private at the highest levels of
government, but the Chinese are practical people and were well aware that their
state run businesses were producing products that were not needed, were continually
adding to inventories of obsolete goods and were paying no taxes. The hell with
the old principals but lets not change the rules is the order of the day
in China and as long as everything continues to operate smoothly, it will stay
that way for some time. Moreover, there is another advantage to the state. PrivatizationThe name of the game today among Chinas more successful entrepreneurs
is to purchase the governments production lines, privatize them and use
the current facilities to bring in efficiencies of scale, production geared to
demand and to provide the business with intricate forecasting and planning. These
principals were not required in a society that was more concerned with having
people produce for the pure sake of mere production. However, even today there
is no adequate government communication with state run facilities. If a widget
is desperately needed in Beijing, no one has a clue of which factory might have
it in inventory and a new one is produced in the nearest factory in spite of the
fact that the product might well be lying covered with dust in inventory down
the block. The amount of wasted production under the old system was colossal and
nobody has a clue how much was produced, where it is located, what its condition
is or whether or not it is even usable even today. And in truth, the provincial
leadership is not really interested in having Beijing find out. In order to make
their state set goals, a lot of items were produced that just were not needed,
and if they were not needed then you can imagine what the demand for them would
be years later. The unquestioned leader in this march to free enterprise is Jiangsu
province which has seemingly danced to a somewhat different drummer for over a
millennium. The province is and has always been a hotbed of privately owned and
operated businesses with the percentage in some cities such as Suzhou amazingly
running close to 100%. Even for so-called China watchers, this is an amazing statistic.
Moreover, there is yet another benefit to this privatization by popular demand
that is rapidly sprouting on Chinas East Coast. Whenever a state run company
is taken over by a private business, the province pockets the money charged for
the takeover of the factory which is often substantial. In spite of the fact that
the privatized property is not worth much, a high price is often paid just for
the legitimacy the protection the certificate of privatization provides. As the
process speeds up, the amount of money that will be going into local governmental
coffers will skyrocket and most logical be thrown right back into infrastructure
improvements which in turn will be helpful to business. Naturally, this comes
after the bureaucrats take a reasonable cut of the pie. Thus, at least the eastern
part of China they are evolving the ultimate self fulfilling economic prophesy
with everyone getting a small piece all the way down to the most unimportant bureaucrat.
In addition, some of that money goes to keeping those unemployed
by this economic streamlining off the streets and other portions of the funds
are funneled back to the banks for use in providing capital to other entrepreneurs
to pursue their useful ideas keeping employment relative full. In order to justify
this totally illegal form of enterprise, local bureaucrats often quote a press
release that came out of a meeting with the top
Chinese Communist Officials in 1999 which indicated that the countrys success
was based on, promoting various forms of ownership, fair economic competition
and equal development. This seems to have been all that was needed to be
said to allow the changes that are now occurring at a breakneck pace. The
1999 statement had little fanfare attached to it and at times people were literally
looking for an interpretation in order to know that the message had been clearly
sent. This came at the time of the parities 80th birthday celebration when no
less than President Jiang Zemin formally indicated that private business owners
could join the 65-million other members of the Party.
PoliticsNaturally this raised constitutional issues and
this were quickly eradicated by the indication that in September of 2001, at the
Parties meeting the constitution would be changed to allow for the new, more aggressive
thinking. Having something like this in the constitution would theoretically conflict
with some of the major tenets of Chinese Communist Philosophy, among other, state
ownership of the basic means of production and the theory of "class struggle."
However, it was pointed out that Carl Marx lived over a century ago and was not
privy to the nuances of today's global economies. Furthermore, the Chinese Government
was being realistic in making this concession; should they not do it, the capitalists
would find other ways to make an impact on the Central Government and that may
come a rather high price. Furthermore, with membership in WTO now concluded, having
the help of top industrialists to assist in folding in that membership with the
Chinese Culture would only be a major benefit. The results of this union will not all be pretty.
In order for the harmony and continued growth of the country, induction of capitalists
formally into the culture will undoubtedly take bureaucratic corruption to another
level. Moreover, there has historically been a single mindedness within the Chinese
Communist Party which will vanish with the wind. Rather than being a philosophical
organization thinking deep thoughts about how to create a more equal society,
quite the opposite will be the order of the day. The more aggressive of the former
group of deep thinkers may well jump ship and turn the country into a bed of capitalists
having little interest in the old doctrine. After all, the party has said that
Marx's Manifesto was for a different age, one long past, at least in terms of
modern technology and economics. The economic climate in China is rapidly evolving into a true liaise
fair type of environment, but it is happening with unbelievable velocity.
However, just as the industrial revolution in China has outstripped the available
water supplies, the environmental conditions and tax collecting abilities of the
state; the unplanned privatization, although a boon for business has created a
need for a greater economic safety net for Chinese citizens. Increased government
revenues will go a long way toward solving the problems of the unemployed but
not far enough. Keep in mind, in the rural China, social security was non-existent.
Historically, the land and the children were meant to provide for the old and
infirmed, not the state. Of course that was in an era when almost everyone lived
on a farm, that is not true today by a long-shot. China is meeting new sets of unforeseen problems recurrently as it
is forced to cope with impediments that were not inherent in the original system
put in place by Mao. The country in almost every respect has joined other of the
worlds economic powerhouses and will have to adjust to these new sets of
problems. However, because China has moved more quicker toward these goals, their
adjustment will have to take place over a shorter period of time, but when you
are driving a monolith, they can sometimes be difficult to maneuver at the last
second. Charity
Begins At HomeBureaucrats
are always looking for new avenues that might provide additional payoffs to augment
their austere salaries. Charities in China have not been immune to their heavy-hand
but for the most part, the government has been so embarrassed over these types
of disclosures that they have not been widely disseminated in the press. However,
as the Chinese news services become somewhat more aggressive in their reporting,
the facts have gradually seeped out into the public view. The most recent but
albeit slightly aborted pronouncement was scheduled to be published concerning
the terrible things that were going on with Project Hope, one of the country's
biggest charities. Southern Weekend a large Chinese newspaper had literally gone
to press with a massive indictment relative to internal theft inside the charity
when the Ministry of Propaganda stepped in and had the presses rolled back. Charities
in China are really anomalies of a sort. They are supposed to be totally independent
from government but in reality, unless some department of the government sponsors
them, they cannot exist. In this case, Project Hope's sponsor is the China
Youth Development Foundation, an affiliate of the Communist Youth League, a very
powerful party organization. The story of the pilfering had been all over the
Hong Kong press for weeks that the charity was really being run for the benefit
of its top officials and instead of donating money to various youth organizations
around the country, the charity's funds were being diverted to speculative investments
benefiting the charities officials. Moreover, the donors to the charity were primarily
foreign nationals but the great majority of the funding came primarily from
large American businesses and Chinese-Americans living in the United States.
In reality, while the donors thought they were giving financial assistance to
poor children that would keep them in school, the money was being channeled into
speculative investments controlled by the charity's officials. There
was no secret made by the Southern Weekend, which is owned by the Guangdong Provincial
Communist Party and produces a tidy profit for its officials, that the article
wasn't going to print. AS a matter of fact, the newspaper had published the fact
that they were going to be doing a massive piece on the reality of what was going
on in the charity. Moreover, Southern Weekend thought that too some degree they
were sacrosanct because of their historically aggressive award winning reporting
along with their ownership by the local Communist Party, but that was hardly
the fact. The Propaganda Ministry became concerned at the 12th hour about the
effect that such an expose' would substantially put a damper on foreign hard dollar
donations and explained to the newspaper's editors that if the almost five-page
story ever saw the light of day, the editors would be working in China's coal
mines, if of course they were lucky enough to live that long. This statement substantially
dampened the newspaper people's ardor for the exposé and the issue was summarily
tanked by the paper's officials. Moreover, the people at the Propaganda Ministry
further reminded the news people that they would not be allowed to print stories
that would cause "ideological confusion" or ""social instability"
and that they were obligated to figure out for themselves what was meant by those
statements. There
are not a lot of charities in China and the ones that are there do not have a
lot of money. This is primarily because the people don't have a lot of disposable
income and that for decades everyone's welfare had been cared for by the state.
This era has come to an end and the Government of China is looking in whatever
directions it can at other potential alternatives to a social security system
that has literally broken down. Obviously the leaders in Beijing feel that foreign
donations especially by ethnic Chinese living abroad could substantially help
a bad situation. In this instance, they were certainly not going to allow their
benefactors to believe that the money they were giving to help Chinese children
was being used to further the interests of Chinese bureaucrats in spite of the
substantive evidence to the contrary. Public
RelationsHowever there is always a solution to any kind of problem. What is
the first thing you do when you first become an economic Goliath whether you have
everything together or not? Thats right, you run some kind of event to take
everyones mind off of the slightly soiled underpinnings that are being left
unaddressed. This should most probably be an event of such proportion that the
worlds press will be obligated to be there and to cover it in depth. The
opening of new factory wont do it, a walk on the Great Wall is old hat,
showing over 8% compounded economic growth wont cut it anymore, but holding
the Summer Olympics in 2008 in Beijing would give China a chance to show off its
wares to the rest of the world leaving its tattered linen hidden in the basement
and this would act as a coming out party at the same time. The competition for
the award was fierce with Osaka, Istanbul, Paris and Toronto telling everyone
that would that they were more entitled than China was based upon if nothing else,
Chinas absolutely miserable record on human rights. While that line did
not make a particularly strong impression when mouthed by the Mayor of Istanbul;
Paris, Toronto and Osaka on the other hand were able to make a deadly case.
These
cities threw just about everything they knew how at China and just when everything
was looking really bleak, Amnesty International almost killed them off altogether
by releasing a study that showed that China had executed more people in the previous
three months than the rest of the world together had accomplished in the past
three years. In addition, Amnesty wasnt through, they went on to say that
their tally of the number of people executed in China was only taken from publicly
available sources, the number of people that probably were put to death under
an anti-crime agenda that the Chinese called strike hard, was more
likely a geometric multiple of that number. However,
Amnesty who does not believe in capital punishment under any circumstances, was
by no means finished with their tirade, they went on to say that China was not
just executing people for what we would call capital crimes but for more minor
things like petty theft, bribery and the crime disrupting the stock market as
well, whatever that is. Fundamentally, they were literally charging that the Chinese
Provinces had been given marching orders to make the executions look serious and
the leadership was up to the challenge. The rights group pointed out that the
determination to prove that the country was not soft on crime had been ordered
at the highest levels of government. These mandates were passed down by high ranking
government officials to provincial authorities who were expected to show concrete
results. Thus, Amnesty believes, that numerous innocent people may have been exterminated
in this rush to judgment. This bomb was dropped just one week before
the Olympic Committee was to make their decision and that wasnt all. In addition, there was the case of the American plane downed by the
Chinese Air Force, then there was the ever-festering situation in Tibet, what
about the ongoing problem with Taiwan and the dynamics of WTO membership? Worse
yet, many were saying that by granting the Chinese, with their system of prison
labor and position as the worlds leading supplier of medical body parts,
we would be replicating the grant of the Olympics in 1936 to Hitler and his gang
of thugs just before World War II. Moreover, in the most unusual twist of all,
the United States strongly backed Torontos bid because it would give NBC,
who had spent billions purchasing the Olympic rights, the ability of beaming the
sports coverage back to its constituents, live and during prime time. The broadcasts
coming from China would be a day earlier or a day later depending upon where you
were or something like that.
Things began to look really bleak for China but they had a solution
at least for local dissent. They began to threaten media people that were saying
anything bad about the country and if they continued to mouth non-Beijing orchestrated
platitudes, they would throw the bums in jail and close their publications. And
in a most unusual move for China they involved themselves in a public relations
blitz, the three tenors no less, Placido Domingo, Jose Carreras and Pavarotti
were paid really big bucks ($10 million was the cost of the event) to appear at
an event in the Forbidden City before 30,000 screaming citizens. Pavarotti was
paid a tad extra to especially extol Chinas virtues and extol he did it
with panache. Think about what he said. I think Beijing deserves the Olympics
in order to be with all the rest of the world recognized and hopefully these Olympics
are bringing here a different kind of feeling and hopefully is the first step
toward peace in the world. Whatever that means but I am certain that it
was well thought out. Well, maybe Pavarottis impassioned pleas made a difference
or maybe it didnt but China got the nod and when all is said and done, they
will probably put on a great show. We hope that they will stop doping their athletes
though so that we can get something close to a legitimate accounting. However,
no matter whether they supply their people with drugs or not, you can bet that
they will absolutely run away with the games and bury the likes of the United
States and Russia because this is their chance to show the world where they are
coming from, and they are not about to blow it. Like it or not, this is going
to be the propaganda show to end all propaganda shows and they are going to take
advantage of it in a fashion that Hitler and Goebels could not imagine. Take my
word for it, the rest of the world is going to come in a poor second to this colossus.
Global
RelationshipsHowever, for the present at least, the Chinese seem to be getting
their way in spite of minor obstacles and we certainly are entering into a new
era with China becoming a full fledged member of the world of global economics.
While this is much akin to putting a shark into a goldfish tank, it is what it
is and time will only tell whether the disaster is survivable for the rest of
us or not. The world has given China access to their trade, the Olympic games,
and after substantial compromise and negotiation, membership in the World Trade
Organization. Their success has not gone unnoticed and in cases like Japan who
had been providing a substantial amount of reparations and a lot of plain old
economic assistance, the situation had to be reevaluated. Japan has recently come
to conclusion, as they face certain economic annihilation by their former inept
sparing partner, that it is rather foolish to continue to pay for the opportunity
of being economically destroyed. China is gradually doing to Japan in an economic
sense what Japan did to China in a military sense. However, they are using the
Chinese water torture and doing it a drip at a time. However, strangely they have not entirely cut out Chinas allowance
money and while being eaten alive they are still paying for the effort. The United
States could have pulled the plug on China when they forced our spy plane down,
but once again, made only a half hearted stand. Taiwan, who China threatens nearly
every day, is literally financing a huge part of their economic growth and yet
all of this is going on while China plays footsie with North Korea who is exporting
sophisticated weapons of war all over the globe to anyone with the price of admission.
If you are a rogue nation, you can bet your last dollar that you are getting some
of the worlds most advanced missiles directly from them.
However,
China is walking the tightrope even closer to the edge when they religiously seem
to jail U.S. citizens based in China. The stories of Gao Zhan and Qin Guangguang
have been all over the American press. These folks have literally disappeared
from sight and have been cut off from communications with anyone in the outside
world including their families. Gao has not been heard from in about six months
but Lis fate may be worse if that is possible. Chinese authorities have
circulated the story that he has confessed to spying for Taiwan and that is not
considered a good thing to do in these parts. American authorities are convinced
that if he did confess, it was probably beaten out of him as routinely happens
to Chinese prisoners. Once he confessed he could possibly have been executed for
his trumped up crimes. The United States has responded to the Chinese by fearsome
President Bush hitting them with a limp noodle. We have expressed our concerns
to China, sometimes they listen, sometimes they dont. Hey man, thats
serious diplomacy. The guy sure sounds like Teddy Roosevelt and his big stick
to me. However, in spite Chinas reputation as jail keeper to the world,
they dont just lock up whoever seems to offend them at the moment. They
are most selective jailers. Chinese officials are painfully aware that they are
supporting a ruthless and out of control government in North Korea. They are also
aware that the country does not produce enough food to even feed a portion of
its starving population. In addition, China is a signatory of the United Nations
convention that bars the forcible return of political refuges. With that as the
background material it is extremely difficult to make a case for Chinas
sending these starving refugees back to certain execution in North Korea when
they are caught crossing over the border looking for food, shelter and a chance
to start life anew. This hardly seems the proper action for a country that is
trying to enter the global brotherhood. Accepting Chinas use of slave labor
is a stretch but conceivable, returning these hapless people who are nothing but
hungry is quite something else. With allies like North Korea, China doesnt
need a lot of enemies. From a political point of view, the whole region is up for grabs
and this doesnt allow the sanctity of a lot of security;. Jane Perlez of
the New York Times put the picture into perspective with her August 5, 2001 story:
In most countries including China, where a succession looms next
year political leadership is in flux. In Indonesia, one president was pushed
out and another was sworn in during a transition that remains an unfinished story.
In South Korea, Mr. Powell (Secretary of State) met with a lame-duck president,
Kim Dae Jung, while North Koreas leader, Kim Jong Il, trekked off by train
to Moscow, ignoring an invitation by Washington for talks. And while the Japanese
had just elected a popular new prime minister, Junichiro Koizumi, their countrys
economy remained tormented by a decade of stagnation. As we have said before, Japan has taken a tad of Chinas allowance
money from it and that has caused no end of trouble. Not only does China believe
that it unfairly cut its allowance but it also believes that Japan is being restrictive
in the products produced by China that are allowed into the country. Kind of a
carrot and a stick approach which China is more than offended by. However, it
may well be that there are two sides to the equation. From Japans point
of view, the Chinese were dumping various products, and beyond that, their belief
was now that China was now a grown up and was entirely capable of supporting itself.
Furthermore, the wily Japanese had come to the overdue conclusion that China had
one more agenda, that was to protect its own rapidly expanding industrial base.
Historically, everyone knows that Japan has been a rather poor sport when it comes
to international trade. They are always wondrously happy when their balance of payments figures
show that they are sticking it to everyone else, but let someone else try to enter
their tightly closed markets and it is as though a volcano has just erupted in
downtown Tokyo. Last year, China, in Japanese terms certainly was not playing
the game fairly and had almost a $22 billion trade surplus with them, the largest
of any country in the world, and the locals didnt like it one bit. This
year, that surplus is going to look like small change, however a change has taken
place, the formerly negative consumers in Japan now find that they are being blessed
with substantially lowered prices on these items and realize that over the years
they had been ripped off by their own companies. This has caused the wall to come
down and the Japanese government doesnt know what to do next.
Peter Wonacott in the Wall Street Journal put the matter into total
perspective, Chinas Strong-Arm Trade Tactics Prompt Concern Over WTO
Entry. China last year exported to
Japan $150 million of shiitake mushrooms, leeks and the rushes used for floor
mats the items that were hit by import curbs. After Japan adopted emergency
safeguards to restrict these products, China retaliated by announcing it would
impose 100% punitive tariffs on imports of Japanese autos, air-conditioners and
mobile phones. These exports brought Japan about $515.8 million last years. However,
with Japan now moving more of its production to China, those companies will suffer
no dislocation whatsoever. This is a form of selective torture that the Chinese
are applying. They are creating a double bang for their tariff buck. They are
frightening Japanese companies that are not manufacturing their to move the production
in that direction and they are sending a strong message to Japan that restrictive
trade is not going to work. However, their recent admission into the
World Trade Organization has prompted international trade organizations to adopt
a wait and see attitude as to whether another shoe will fall. This situation is compounded by the fact that the Chinese items that
are being embargoed are all agricultural products and that segment of Chinas
population has started to make waves over the fact that they are being treated
like poor relatives in an economy that seems to be benefiting everyone else but
them. China does not need a revolution on their hands and if the Japanese have
to suffer over Chinas internal problems, thats just going to be Japans
problem. And as far as the rest of the world is concerned, it certainly doesnt
appear that Japan has made a lot of friends. Japan becoming more than a little
concerned has started beefing up its military and changing some of the restrictive
regulations in its constitution. However, they also seem to have rewritten
some of the history of World War II in the process and this time they seem to
have won. This has not sat well with those oppressed by Japanese aggression at
that time. Japan is acting clumsy to say the less as it deals with China.
While South Korea never had China on an allowance, they also felt
the wrath of the Mainland. As a matter of fact the Chinese might have even done
a tad worse to the Koreans as imports of chemicals, textiles and metals were banned
entirely from that country. However, China did not get up one day on the wrong
side of the bed and determine that South Korea was no longer their friend. No
way, South Korea has a well deserved reputation for being available to be anyones
friend for a price. As a matter of fact, South Korea is known as one of the best
friends money can buy. No, it wasnt that at all, it was the fact that South
Korea was trying to protect its minimalist garlic industry and made the fatal
misstep by raising tariffs on this truly unimportant product. The rule in dealing with China seems
to be written in stone, dont mess with their agricultural sector.
Would
You Believe Salt?One of the products that China had enough of but was not utilizing
properly was salt. A lack of the iodine that is a salt by-product can cause serious
illnesses and create substantial downtime within the population. Health problems
such goiters and would you believe? low IQ is a result of not getting enough of
this readily available substance. Historically, salt had been a monopoly in China
over two millennia ago and so the situation remained for quite some time. The
people were aware of the fact that without iodines bare essentials, there
would be substantial health risks in overall community. Over the years, the country
had gotten away from the monopolistic aspects of salt distribution and village
elders seemed to forget that salt wasnt just a nice seasoning for food.
This serious problem was pointed out to the central government officials a number
of years ago and they took immediate action. Somehow or other, we fail to see
why a monopoly would have better provided this essential element to the people
but then again this is China and who are we to say. The scenario unfolded something
like this: It was determined that the monopolistic approach was best because
by giving the job to one company, if everyone in the community did not get their
proper salt rations, there was no question of where to place the blame. (well
now this is beginning to make sense) In the meantime, all other salt distributors
were put out of business by the government. The next move was to raise the price
of salt so that the conglomerate controlling its distribution could make a profit.
(That would certainly seem to make it more available to everybody) While this
worked fairly well, with the price rise came black market dealers offering the
product at more competitive prices. (free enterprise at work) China seeing that
this could cause even more serious problems then had existed before formed what
they called the salt police, a totally independent police agency with
extensive powers to make sure that the monopoly continued to function in the manner
that its charter demanded and that those that sold unauthorized salt would be
treated as criminals and subjected to whatever punishment the salt police
believed to be fitting. (selling salt illegally and at lower prices should be
punished at least by death or something even worse in our opinion) The program
has become a substantial success and the only people that are unhappy over the
results are the small independent salt manufacturers and distributors that are
no longer in business. We are loath to point out that this may be the first time
in history that anyone ever sold a black market product of this nature at less
than the market price. I mean, copies of movies, music or other electronics, but
food and medicine? Really! Family
LifeWhen China sets their mind to change their society, they often attempt
to accomplish their goals literally overnight. While this no nonsense approach
shows that they are serious about doing constructive things, the distortions that
are created by the programs which are not fully researched can have disastrous
results. The countrys elders determined, probably rightly that their population
was growing to fast and that if it continued at that rate, it would sap the economic
strength of the country as a whole and it would ultimately relegate China to a
fourth class status. A program was embarked upon which limited each family to
one child. This law was forcibly regulated, however it wasnt long before
the results became somewhat skewed. The Chinese family had always been lead to believe that the boys
in the family would always stay to till the plots of land that produce the food
that sustains their kin. They were also the ones that had the obligation to take
care of their parents when they become infirmed. The daughters on the other hand
would always move in with their new husbands family and take care of them,
often having little contact with their own parents from the time that they marry
and move out of the house. Because of this fact, the was little question that
boys were favored over girls but because Chinese families tended to be large,
there was no reason to become prejudicial over the matter.
Having only one child on the other hand created a new situation.
If the one child that the union produced was a girl and when she moved away, who
would take care of the parents in the old age? This was considered to be a very
serious problem because in China there was no social safety net under these folks,
especially those from Chinas rural areas. Abortion soon became commonplace
and female fetuses were disposed of and the attempt to have a son was reinstituted.
There is a much more in depth discussion of this later so we will not deal with
the whole subject at this time. Obviously the results of this selective process
was the fact that China soon had substantially more men than women in its population
causing a social crisis. United Nations figures show that no less than 50 million
women are missing from the population. Statistics show that there are 120 boys
for every 100 girls among rural couples. This has caused a spate of kidnappings
in China, after all, how could families produce sons if they did not have girls
for wives producing boys for families that have not yet produced a male heir?
This became a philosophical problem that even the ancient Greeks could not have
dealt with. The feudal practice of paying dowries has once again reared its ugly
head in China but it is really a form dowries in reverse. Rather than the womans
family paying the man money or goods upon
the completion of the marriage ceremony, here the process is totally reversed,
it is the mans family that pays the brides parents, and if they are
not able to come up with a substantial enough sum, the deal is off. The girls
are not thought to be anything more than bargaining chips as no matter who gets
them, the parents will probably have little further contact with them. Thus, the
girls have become commodities, are given little schooling, and are thrown into
backbreaking work around the household at an early age. Once they are married
there is little change in the situation, they not only have to take care of their
own household, but they are obligated to take care of their in-laws as well.
More importantly though, from the mans point of view, with
dowry prices ballooning out of sight, it is cheaper to buy an abducted or kidnapped
bride than be forced to deal with parents that have an over optimistic view of
how much their daughter should bring. One way or the other, rural women are treated
as chattels and have little to say in the entire matter. If they are kidnapped,
often they are taken to villages far away from their homes and lose all contact
with their parents or even where they are. There are now telephone booths in rural
China nor any Western Union offices so communication is next to impossible. The
police are of little help because the girls are often taken to live in neighboring
provinces where local officials have no jurisdiction. Once these girls have children
they most often lose the incentive to move back home. It may be that they can
leave the village but more likely than not, they cannot take their child with
them. Faced with a Catch-22 they remain where they are at.
Interestingly enough, when the kidnappers strike they make no discrimination
between the women that are married and those that are single. Thus, many of the
women that are abducted are already married and already have families. If the
womans husband knows where she is, he can organize a paramilitary team of
his cohorts in an attempt to retrieve her. This often can lead to substantial
bloodshed, as they would be trying to pry her loose from a village that is the
home of her new husband. More often than not, early on in the abduction, the woman
is handcuffed to the new husband so that she is not able to run off again. Those
that are not shackled often become unruly and run off again and again. This certainly
applies if there is not enough work in the village where they live. Home life
in rural China is hardly what it used to be. Money
and TaxesWomen arent the only commodities that seem to vanish in todays
China. Money vanishes regularly in China, which literally robs the country of
its ability to collect taxes and take better care of its people. Magically disappearing
money is a really good trick especially here where the penalties for playing around
in the international banking business are a very serious crime. On the other hand,
because no one in China willingly pays taxes and because of the fact that the
Chinese Government tends to be a little overbearing at times, it is considered
to be a good strategy to have a large bankroll abroad. The Chinese Government
does not make this an easy thing to do. However, where there is a will, there is a way. One of the most successful
methods of moving money offshore used by Chinese entrepreneurs is the old; gee
I put the wrong price on that item trick and would you believe that I sold it
too cheaply?. The way it operates is that, when an item is sold by a Chinese
company to a buyer abroad, more often than not it carries two prices, the first
being the price that the government sees that the goods are being sold at. This
price usually substantially below market for the item but this is not something
that is carefully looked at by those Chinese government personnel engaged in monitoring
the export markets. (this is an area in which the government usually stays out
of, it is left to individual companies to determine the price at which they will
sell goods, unless they are state enterprises and they too have a lot of leeway)
The second price is the difference between the orally agreed upon price
and the posted price that government officials see. The difference is more often
than not deposited into the account of some nominee Hong Kong company into a bank
in that country. The evidence supporting this fact is rather convincing; last year
alone according to Hong Kong banking figures $64.3 billion flowed into Hong Kong
in the form of foreign direct investment (FDI). The term, foreign direct investment
is usually meant to define money that is going into a country for investment there.
If that much money were to be invested in Hong Kong in one year, the country would
come apart at the seems. As a matter of fact, it couldnt absorb that kind
of money in a decade. Obviously something else is going on. In addition, inconceivably,
that figure is almost double the amount that flowed directly into China itself,
the country that received more foreign direct investment that any other country
on earth. Moreover, that figure is over 400% higher that the total FDI that flowed
into Hong Kong one year before China took over in 1999. Moreover, even in that
year, there was substantial money flowing into Hong Kong illegally from the Mainland.
While there are other potentials for hiding the real profits accrued by Chinese
companies, this one is the most logical and as we well know, its brother, transfer
pricing is probably used by every major multi-national on earth as a way of bringing
down its taxes. Stock
and BondsHowever, there are other ways; Chinese companies have on an off and
on again basis, become the financial darlings of the investment community. After
all, in what country on earth is there the raw potential that exists in China.
When investors and brokerage firms spot a Chinese company that appears to have
potential, a line starts to form and the bidding process begins. More often than
not, these companies are financed offshore, in places like Hong Kong and the United
States. By and large, the vehicle that the company uses for its domicile for these
underwritings is usually a tax advantaged location where
no one asks a lot of questions relative to the names of the sellers or
from where they come. This money can also be substantial and usually wends it
way back to Hong Kong and then seeps into the mainland as foreign direct investment.
This methodology is heavily utilized by both the government and private sector
so that they will have a nice bundle secreted abroad when the time comes either
for retirement or a hasty exit due to some unforeseen circumstance. Many people have expressed some concern that the amounts leaving
Mainland China are so prodigious that the structure of the economy itself could
be endangered in the same way as occurred in Russia when money left that country
as though it was scooped up by a giant galactic vacuum cleaner. However, the difference between Russia and China is substantial,
at least in terms of perception. While little or no FDI is coming back into Russia
from its own people, there is a regular and substantial inflow to China, through
foreign entities. Much of this is attributed to the same people and companies
who took it out illegally to begin with. This is money laundering at its most sophisticated because the Chinese
are not particularly concerned about reinvesting money as foreign entities but
are deathly concerned of doing so under their own names. So although the situation
is serious, because it continually returns, at least in part, it has not reached
the panic stage and as long as it continues coming back even though totally laundered
and disguised, China will not blow the whistle. There seems to be no question
that the amounts in question would not be possible without substantial assistance
from government officials who for a price either close their eyes to what is going
on or participate under aliases with accounts in off shore banks. The amount of
bribery of officials and bureaucratic shakedowns have become legendary in this
country; thus, why not an account in a friendly offshore bank? Investing
By the EnemyThere is a unique wild card in this already complex equation. Taiwanese
are not allowed by law to invest directly in China but anyone that has observed
what is occurring in the Pacific Rim knows that there have been substantial investments
in Mainland China made by Taiwanese investors. As a matter of fact, in many instances
there has been no attempt to cover-up this action at all. However, in spite of
this, the law is the law and this money is probably commingled in Hong Kong all
of the rest of the money that is simultaneously coming out and going into China.
In the total scheme of things, Taiwans investments represent only chum change
in the overall scope of things. Banking in Hong Kong has been likened to the ocean
tides in that what comes in once again goes out and the process repeats itself
over and over again. Meanwhile, back at the ranch. Investing in Chinese companies, everything
that glistens is not always gold, as a matter of fact, to stockholders, very little
of it is gold or anything like it. There really are no independent auditors in
China, no GAAP, no transparency, no Securities and Exchange Commission fillings,
no nothing. If one of these little gems is underwritten in the United States you
can bet your last banana that there is going to be transparency a fair shake for
the investors but as far as most the rest of the world is concerned and as far
a China in particular, there just isnt anyone at home watching the store.
Take the example of one of the hottest stocks that the Chinese market has yet
produced, Guangxia Industry, a little gem that says they are making big money
exporting a Chinese herb and vegetable extract products used for medical relief.
Watching The StoreThese guys didnt make up much other than how much they were
selling, how much they were making, who they were selling it to, who was working
for the company or just about anything else. This company has become the example
used when the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC), Chinas answer
to the Americas SEC, talks about the bad things going on in the Chinese
market. There is no question that the stock markets of China are akin to the Wild
West in the United States where anything was ok with the exception of telling
the truth. Interestingly enough, that fact is oddly coupled with the fact that
the Government of China owns approximately 75% of the shares listed on the country's
exchanges. Thus, one could make the extreme case that not only is the country
condoning illicit actions in its securities markets but it is indirectly participating
in the problem as well. The real difficulty in China though, is not the lack of precision
on the part of the CSRC, it is the fact that there are no third party journalists
involved in evaluating the prospects of Chinese public companies on an objective
basis. In several instances there have been questions raised relative to the merits
of some of these companies by outsiders. The stocks have dropped due to these
opinions and the authors in some cases have barely escaped with their lives as
they caused precipitous drops in share prices. In the meantime, China has been forced to adjust to another fact
of life. They are a world class economy and as such, there is a need to
legitimately hedge various elements of their economy in the international markets.
Foreign exchange, metals and grains are certainly logical items which lend themselves
to this type of activity if for no other reason than to smooth the ups and downs
of the economy and allow for more accurate central planning. The problem that
China faces is that almost every time they have allowed one of their agencies
to become involved within the international financial markets, something seems
to go wrong. It almost seems that the people trading for the Chinese lose their
cool the second they get started and the government has suffered enormous losses
coupled with international embarrassment o numerous occasions when no risk
transactions have gone south. Because of the nature of the business, in the future
we would tend to see more of the same but the Chinese will not allow their missteps
to be publicly acknowledged this time around. There is a fundamental fact; that
is China is a country of innate gamblers and most of the population would bet
on which fly would leave the table first, if they had the money. So it is with
international markets. The race track in Hong Kong is by far the largest in terms
of dollars wagered in the world and the gambling tables in Macau are ten deep
on an off night. As China becomes more sophisticated in terms of worldliness, a certain
amount of interaction is required. The more interaction the more that China begins
to learn the downside of opening up their country to quickly to the rest of the
world. The Chinese are a susceptible to intravenous drug use as the next guy and
with it comes HIV. In addition, modern China is seeing an ever larger gay community
as its society becomes more sophisticated. The number of people that have been
infected with the malady is hard to pin point because high-tech testing for this
disease has not been utilized and even if it were, it would not cover the rural
communities. Be that as it may, whatever the exposure may now be, Chinas
highly transient population with over 100 million migrant workers traveling the
length and breadth of the country is a causation for the rapid spread of all diseases.
China is neither equipped or of a mind to put a halt to this nomadic work oriented
migration nor is it equipped to handle the downside that it brings. The spread
of diseases is greatly magnified under these circumstances and there is little
question that this type of mobility can result in epidemics. China is at present
unable to pay the economic price for treatment nor is it truly willing to admit
how out of hand this problem has gotten. Hard
FeelingsThe Falun Gong headed by the highly
revered Li Hongzhi who is now living a secluded life in America, started simply
enough as a spiritual movement. Their leader who had some charismatic qualities
was not above changing the facts to suit the situation. One of the key messages
that he espouses is the fact that he is the living Buddha and has substantial
supernatural powers that will protect his followers. In order to insure that his
flock could more easily accept that view, he changed the date of his birth to
coincide with the birthday of Buddha. Given a substantial public relations push,
Li determined that the group should go even further in getting their message across.
Many people in China see membership in the group as being an easy way to obtain
an American Green Card as a religiously prosecuted minority. This seems to be
about the only logic that can account for some of the heavy-duty thinkers that
have joined the religion. The Falun Gong staged a massive protest
in April 1999, which drew substantial attention from Chinese officials. Moreover,
one thing lead to another, and literally a war was declared between the religion
and the national government. The Chinese government has not shown a proclivity
to handling descent well and as the stakes were continually raised, the sentences
handed out to the faithful became substantially more severe. Instead of reorientation
along with job demotions, we are talking about long prison terms at hard labor.
But what is this religion all about and why is that China is so dead set against
it?
Gong? The movement has been drawing
attention in the West for the last two years. Some Western China scholars are
even praising it for the scientific basis of its principles. Falun Gong has drawn
the attention of Chinese intellectuals too, particularly those searching for a
spiritual movement that is grounded in traditional Chinese thought but takes account
of rational, scientific and modern considerations. Whatever their educational
background or technological knowledge, all Chinese lean towards wearing a Confucian
thinking cap, Buddhist robe and Taoist sandals. I am no exception.
()
The hardly seems to qualify as a
contemporary combination of science and religion. It would seem that Li Hong-zhi
has established a pot pourri of witches brew by mixing some reasonable
facts with some of the most outlandish statements made since Kansas banned the
teaching of evolution. He teaches his followers that illness and misfortune are
caused by the evil deeds that they do. He also teaches that inanimate objects
such as stone, wood, earth, steel and air are purveyors of morality.
He envisions tall buildings standing on sea bottoms, Atlantis style and
is certain that people populated the earth hundreds of millions of years ago.
If these cockeyed concepts werent enough, it appears that he is readying
a wheel to implant in the stomach of his followers in order to protect them from
harm. Naturally, Li has been able to protect his disciples from harm and whenever
an example of a miraculous escape or cure crops up, the leader of the Falun Gong
steps up to take credit for it. Li writes:
These incidents are so common that they are no longer worth counting
You
might or might not encounter
them, but I will guarantee that you will have no danger. That is what I will give
you. My saintly body will protect you until you are able to protect yourself.
We would wonder what his followers that are being tortured
in Chinese jails fell about Lis gospel. In reality, so far, there has been
little backlash and if anything, the number of his followers is increasing. However,
this is exactly what the Chinese were afraid of and their war against Lis
clan increased dramatically. This escalation in turn brought a greater reaction
from the Falun Gongs irrepressible leader who felt substantial comfort when
cajoling his flock to withstand in whatever ways available the governments
onslaughts against.
However,
he was issuing his fighting words from half way around the world by e-mail, hardly
front line duty. His cries for action achieved the desired result and a number
of religiously orchestrated self-immolations took place in the name of the Falun
Gong, which received worldwide press coverage. Each side would continually raise
the stakes in their poker game and neither side has come even close to a victory.
Nevertheless, one thing is certain, this tiny religion has come closer than any
other group in China since the end of World War II, to becoming the mouse that
swallowed the elephant. Lis statement can be well categorized with the following:
For example, some students
were arrested and imprisoned. When they couldnt endure the severe torture,
they wrote repentance statements. But in their minds, they were thinking: This
is to fool them. Ill still practice after I get out, Ill still go
out to validate the Fa (another name for the Falun Gong) and Ill still go
to Tiananmen Square in Beijing, the site of protests. But this is unacceptable.
Its because this kind of notion is something developed in the human world
after humans have become depraved. But gods arent like that. They dont
have thoughts like these. Once theyve decided on a certain path, theyll
definitely stick with it to the end.
()
A Strange
DietWith a landmass of 3.7 million square
miles, China is only slightly larger than the United States. Of all the countries in the world,
only Russia and Canada are geographically larger.
China, contains the highest point in the world, Mt. Everest, and one of
the lowest, Takia Makan, an oasis, which is over five hundred feet below sea level.
The Yangtze River is almost 4,000 miles in length, and only the Nile and
Amazon exceed it in size. The land
for the most part is unsuitable for agriculture as mountain ranges make up much
of China's terrain. It has 22% of the world's population
and only 7% of its arable land. Yet,
it is agriculturally self-sufficient due to the use of highly sophisticated production
techniques. On the other hand, the food is only
of the subsistence variety, and as the country's wealth increases, it is likely
that the population will desire a more varied diet.
Under those conditions, it is doubtful that China can maintain the delicate
balance that it has established between production and consumption.
Chinese eat many foods that may appear
strange to westerners such as Birds Nest Soup, which comes from the secretions
of the cave or cliff swallow and is considered a delicacy, or jelled blood, a
concoction made from pig or duck blood, which has a gelatin like appearance but
has a salty flavor. However, when you are in a particularly festive mood, bull
penis is always recommended but is usually reserved for holidays and special events.
Nevertheless, more expensive but excellent is drunken shrimp which is served live,
swimming around in a bowl of rice. At expensive restaurants, the shrimp are allowed
to swim around in a highly flammable liquor which first gets them higher than
a kite and when they are plowed, they are then set ablaze, and the shrimp are
consumed piping hot and while still alive but totally off the wall.
If this exciting palate tempting
morsel doesnt do it for you, then we are certain that boiled fish flotation
bladder would be an acceptable alternative or if not, certainly monkey brains
would do the job. In order to get the full flavor, the brains must be eaten directly
from the open skull of a live monkey. This is something that is sure to tempt
the palate of the most adventurous eater. However, many people have an aversion
to eating live animals and perhaps you would prefer to have your dinner not attempt
to get off the plate while you are eating it. Dead, cooked rat fits this scenario
to a tee. Rats are said to have an excellent flavor and at one time were highly
abundant in China. The fact that their taste is so much in demand has diminished
both their population in China and to a larger extent, the diseases that they
normally carry. You say that still doesnt to it for you. We are sure that
we can please. Well then how about Sa Kuo Yu Toe,
or fish head soup. The heads bobbing about in the soup tureen give off a sensational
flavor, but looking into another animals eyes while eating can become slightly
disconcerting. For an aperitif after a great meal, there is nothing like fine
snake wine in China. It is only a bottle of fine wine containing a small snake
that has been immobilized and drowned in an alcoholic bath. After the wine has
been served and the bottle finished, the snake makes an excellent morsel for dessert.
An alternative desert that is highly
prized by the natives is Cho Do Fu which means smelly tofu Many have
said that the only problem with this dish is that it smells like an outhouse.
()
()
An even more important part of the Chinese diet is the exotic camel tendon chowder,
which most gourmets have put in another league from cow tendons, which tend to
be grainy. Another Chinese dish that has taken the country by storm is the ever-popular
Tiger Penis Soup, which originated in Korea. This hard to come by delicacy is
only available to the very rich and is probably the most expensive dish served
in the country. The gentrification of China has literally
occurred overnight and while most feel that the new China provides substantially
more opportunities that the old one. However, in order to get in on the potential
you have to move to where it is happening, that is the big cities. The young people
in China who are historically, very family minded; suddenly find themselves without
their traditions and without old time friends. In order to fill that gap an alternative
is springing up and taking the country by storm. In rural areas, surrounding the
bigger Chinese cities a new and very successful business is burgeoning. Old style
cooking down on the farm style. Resorts similar to those that had sprung up in
the Catskill region of New York are growing like Topsy in China, bringing the
people back to their roots, but primarily only on the weekends. Below is a story
of Mr. Liu, one of the entrepreneurs who has become very successful in bringing
the city slickers back to the farms. His main aim, he says, is to
give the guests what they demand. Mostly, that means such nostalgic
mainstays of Sichuan life as rice scooped from a communal wood bucket, cold plates
of local pork and rice liquor straight from the clay jug. But it also means setting
out tables amid the greenery for games of mahjongg the favorite pastime
here. Sometimes, work units Chengdu rent the entire place for parties, especially
at Chinese New York, in a home-spun version of the corporate retreat
I May,
you cant find a spare chair to sit-down, says Mir. Liu. Even on chilly
winter weekends, with hardly a leaf on the sycamores, lunch tables are full, the
gardens packed with game players in overcoats.
Social
SecurityHistorically, the country had been
like a big brother, with all workers theoretically being employed by the state
in some capacity or other. These state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in turn would
take care of the people, literally from the cradle to the grave. As China moves
towards a more market oriented economy in which the SOEs are not the only employers,
another system had to be substituted. China has now determined to go with something
more similar to the American Social Security system in which the people make direct
contributions into a fund run by the national government and when they retire,
they are in turn paid out of that endowment. The fundamental reason for the change
is the fact that, as in most other countries, the Chinese population is getting
elderly and the SOEs are no longer able to take care of the workers and remain
competitive at the same time. However, the system will primarily function only
for those people that live in the cities where the industries are located. It
would appear that no particular consideration has been given to the 800 million
rural peasants who live on farms. Apparently, the central government believes
that they these people can continue to live off the land, the same way that they
have been doing all of their lives. Chinas Minister of Labor
and Social Security, Zhang Zuoji said: In rural areas
the main form
of insurance is still provided by families, which completely conforms to the national
condition and ethics of China (). However, it seems that China has
missed the point. They are trying to bring the country into the current century
and have chosen to move people off the farm and into the cities to work in industrialized
facilities. As the young people are uprooted, or in the alternative uproot themselves,
looking for a better life, they may be leaving the infirmed behind, thus unable
to take care of themselves. However, it would appear that there is method to the
Chinese madness, it would seem that with this one move, they have addressed the
nomadic population that has taken hold in China, moving from job to job, and from
city to city. Living in the rural areas has now become a road to nowhere and loyal
family members are going to think twice about looking for the good life and leaving
their revered parents behind.
The World Bank in a recent report
indicated that while the world's economy was growing at a rate of 2% a year in
the first half of this decade, during that time, China beat all comers by averaging
a global high of 12.8% but this of course was a from a very low base. Of the top nine countries in the study,
all but Kuwait and Jordan are from the Pacific Rim. The runners up were Kuwait, New Guinea, Singapore and Malaysia
in a dead heat, Thailand, Vietnam, Jordan and Indonesia. The Female of The SpeciesChina
has even shown some improvement in how it relates to the female of the species.
Historically, as prosperity arrives, so does a mans interest in expanding
his relationships of the sexual kind which increase geometrically. Having
a wife along with a lover of two is a male sign of high level of testosterone
or in lieu of that, a super-sized ego either one of which shows that a person
has truly arrived at an elevated station in life. And so it has been flaunted
over the years in places like Paris where every politico is expected to have a
mistress or two or in the Arab countries where it is a sign of great wealth and
prominence and in England where the royalty would dry up like prunes with political
scandal. The
early kings kept harems, and marauding generals took the most beautiful women
in the territory they had conquered. Through the centuries, the accumulation of
attractive and sexually active women has readily followed the male accumulation
of wealth, as night has followed day. It is not necessarily the handsome or the
strong that win the battle of sexual accretion, it is always the powerful. King
David, one of the earliest historically annotated womanizers, was able to back
up his amorous interests with an entire army. Everyone at that time strongly believed
that David had done the decent thing or they got a spear in the labonza.
Nature,
too, has prescribed that to the powerful should go the spoils. There seems little
question that this is good for the genes and, in the long run, for the species
as well. In nature it is often inherited guile and conniving that really wins
the hearts of the herd, as opposed to sheer force. If sheer force was a factor,
The Rock or Tyson the Carnivore would have accumulated
more than their fair share of lovelies. However, as we have grown
more civilized, man has become more monogamous, not by choice, but by law, and
nowhere does this present more problems than it does in the worlds newly
emerging economies. The anomaly has two causes. First, multiple women act as a
statement that a man is powerful, and can what he wants whenever he pleases. This
syndrome is as much a part of the male psyche as death and taxes. Sadly for the
rest of us, there is only one alpha male in each herd. But back to our story.
However,
womans roll has changed as well. Formerly, women were shackled to the home
and to multiple children that were necessary to till the soil and provide for
their parents old age have become passé. Womens roles have changed
and their attitudes have matured with their education. In turn, they have also
learned the to deal with exigencies of birth control and family planning. No longer
in emerging societies are women population factories, they have become individuals
and more importantly, in civilized societies, they have become voters. Women make
up the majority of the global population and vote in greater numbers than their
male opposite numbers. Women
have different views of the world and need are not of sexual security as opposed
to sexual conquest. This security can be provided by either a loyal husband, a
successful job or the sale of her body to the highest bidder. Women are not the
first ones hired in emerging economies so that statement is of no consequence.
However, as economies emerge, bidding becomes more frequent and more intense with
the price rising and falling with the underlying national economics. In those
countries where opportunities for women are limited and where there is still a
degree of male domination, the sale of their bodies is still the rule and not
the exception. If
nothing else, China is a unique place. However, in many respects it is extremely
democratic. Maybe this would be better put if we had said that in China, everyone
is equal provided no one is rocking the boat. To a large degree, Chinas
laws protect men and women almost equally, but the countrys power is vested
within politics and the politicians are for the most part alpha males. In China,
politics does not pay well, but then again nothing else does either other than
innovate thought and entrepreneurship coupled with superior execution. Laws
and All That JazzSpeaking
about law in China and we evolve into a must peculiar subject. Laws on not followed
to the letter all of the time and for the most part, they are reactive in nature.
When the country's leaders feel that a particular problem has gotten out of hand
or that the country's tax base has been seriously eroded, a crackdown is ordered.
Such was the case with smuggling a decade ago, which interestingly enough was
primarily a diversion of the People's Army A number of years ago, the government
indicated that arrests, convictions and executions should be made and orders went
out around the country. After a time, as news of the executions spread throughout
China, the smuggling to some degree was alleviated and the government went on
to more important venues. Then problem that had become an epidemic was corruption
and the Government proceeded to handle it in exactly the same way, arrest, execution
and publicity are currently the guidewords that is until the Government finds
another crusade. Usually they come one at a time to maximize the public relations
value of the situation. China
has been averaging over a dozen executions a day and there are currently 68 crimes
in that country that are punishable by death. Oddly, 28 of them are not related
to violent crimes and they include what we would call "white collar"
crimes of tax fraud, embezzlement and graft. Interestingly enough, bribery does
not become a capital offense until $12,000 or more changes hands. This brings
us to the ultimate difference between laws in China and those in much of the rest
of the world. In China, it is not the crime itself that is the critical element
in sentencing, it is the effect that crime had on others that seems to by the
guiding factor. The current political climate is the critical element that is
taken into account in sentencing. Is the government currently on a campaign to
eliminate graft by politicians, if so, the sentence could be death, if that is
not momentarily on the government's agenda, the culprit can get off with an admonition.
Courts in China have tremendous latitude when it comes to sentencing but they
are expected to follow the government's lead. An
interesting case was recently heard in one of China's outlying provinces where
several buildings were blown up and a great number of people were killed.. Neither
the reason for the blast or the person who committed the crime are of any importance
in this story. In the village where the bombs were purchased stands a large quarry
which provides building materials for numerous construction projects that are
being conducted simultaneously by various builders. . A cottage industry has sprung
up in this small village that allows the people to produce blasting powder
for the quarry. This powder was usually made in the homes of the villagers. The
man that blew up the building happened to buy the powder from the home of a widower
with children to support. Justice
is swift in China and both he and she were summarily executed. He for killing
numerous people, she for supplying him with the powder with a shot to the head.
The industry is still pervasive within the village and business goes on as usual
with the people still producing the powder in their homes. Nobody else has been
arrested nor will they unless another incident like the one we spoke of happens
again. There was nothing unusual about the purchase but this women just happened
to sell her production to the wrong guy, it could have happened to anyone else
in town. She was just unlucky and paid a capital price. In China, justice
is the luck of the draw. Graft
and the Better Things In LifePoliticians
in China control the high calorie end of the food chain. Graft, something almost
unheard of in China only a short time ago, at the local level has become legendary
and as the countrys economic prowess evolves, the amount of graft that can
be levied increases geometrically. Thus, the local politician has by default become
king of all he surveys and his territory has become more like a fiefdom than that
of a political unit. He tends to view his domain as his personal property and
that has indeed caused a major problem in China as a substantial part of the countrys
gross national product is winding up in the pockets of bureaucrats and the funds
are not being re-circulating within the economy. Politicians
become attracted to local beauties and are more often than not able to afford
a number of them. This is something that neither the other men are jumping for
joy over nor are the women that are left at the starting block. More important
to the Chinese Government though is the fact that a harem can be expensive and
political leaders in order to support their habits have found it necessary to
increase the tolls in their communities so to speak. There is always a breaking
point where more graft become economically disintermediating. In other words,
the higher the price the less able to pay, the more the local economy will head
south. The local leader, unwilling to give up his assortment of beauties must
resort to other means to feather and pamper his nest and more often then not,
raises the ante one more level by stealing from the local treasury or worse.
The
problem was becoming overwhelming from both an economic and a political point
of view and the men in the Forbidden City were really starting to feel the heat,
from the men, from the female advocates, from the taxpayers and from the tax collectors.
The system was breaking down and sex was the devil that was causing its demise.
The wise men in the City thought long and hard about what to do and although there
was a law on the books against bigamy and one against cohabiting with someone
other than ones wife and against behavior that is not conducive to monogamy,
the penalties for any and all of them were not strong enough to send a married
man with hundred woman harem to jail for even one day. The
old men thought long and hard about Xu Qiyao, the 57-year old head of Jiangsu
provinces construction department who lavished nearly $2 million on his
20 mistresses buying them Cartier watches, stereos and sequestering them
in several love nests dotted throughout eastern China. I am not sure that this was the
straw that broke the camels back for them, I think it was the fact that
he did it on a salary of less than $100 per month. While Xu had always been known
as a big saver, this was beyond anyones comprehension. They talked about
the fact that Chen Xitong, the former mayor of Beijing itself and a man held out
to be a model citizen, husband and father was able to maintain a harem the extent
of which has never been properly delineated on miserly salary. An they debated
long and hard over what Gao Changli did. This man was a justice minister for the
government who had kept his mistress on the ministrys private payroll. All
of these men were severely punished for their indiscretions but the punishments
were not for having harems but were for stealing money to maintain them.
The
wise men acted, they determined in their infinite wisdom that it was an accumulation
of women that make men steal and do ghastly things in the workplace. If women
could some how be made to become mens equals or something similar, perhaps
the bribery and thefts that were so severely eroding Chinas economy could
then be brought under control. The government agreed and China has now made it
official, men are no longer allowed to have extra marital affairs or at least,
they were not longer allowed to bet caught in the act. We believe that this shows
that China has truly become joined with other developed nations all of which whom
universally make a practice of passing useless laws that assuage the electorate
and yet remain as worthless as the paper they are written on. We applaud both
the old men in Beijing who no longer care about sex and the young and powerful
men that will continue doing exactly what they were doing before these laws went
into effect without missing a stroke so to speak. We must join in praising China,
a country that has now truly joined the civilized world. The
Financial Times on August 2, 1998 ran a story about what happened to Chen Xitong
entitled "Jail looms for Beijing's once Mighty Mayor" and it is worth
quoting a paragraph as it talks about the fact that he received bribes, a gold
ring, a silver carriage and horses and a house in the countryside equipped with
massage chairs, It then goes on to say: "But these may, in fact be mere trinkets
in the Chen Xitong affair. More than 40 officials connected with Mr. Chen have
been arrested so far and an internal report last year said he had amassed a personal
fortune of $24m. He was also implicated in a series of financial schemes which
may have totaled $2bn in value." Relatively you are talking very serious
numbers here. History
and International ParanoiaChina has a long and worthy history,
which includes a substantial number of major, globally important innovations,
in spite of the fact that for a good deal of its recent history, China was basically
isolated to the outside world. Since the early 1800s, the country to a large degree has been
in turmoil, with power largely decentralized and revolutionary movements becoming
the order of the day. Historically, China could well have
fallen into a series of fiefdoms without Western assistance in suppressing these
revolutions. Witness the Boxer Rebellion in 1900, which was brought under control
primarily by the United States Marines.
In spite of Western attempts to keep the country on an even keel, Imperial
China (the Qing Dynasty) collapsed in 1911, leaving China in chaos.
Chinas allegiances shift with
the wind; this is evidenced by the fact that they were on the side of the Anglo-French
during World War I, for whatever little that meant. In exchange for mostly vocal support
of the Allies, which is about all they could give, they were promised the German
concessions in the province of Shangdong at the end of the war.
As often occurs with these types of things, someone screwed up big time
and the Treaty of Versailles and gave the property to Japan.
Enraged, the people gathered in Tiananmen Square to protest on May 4, 1919. This event marked the beginning of
what became known as the "May Fourth" nationalist movement.
Chiang Kai-shek took over the leadership
of the Nationalist Party (KMT) in 1925 and began unifying the country by force.
This created the conflict between the Nationalists who were pitted against
the Communists. As often occurs in these types of encounters, the Communists eventually
won control of the countryside and the Nationalists, the urban centers.
As Chiang Kai-shek's troops were closing in on what could have been the
decisive battle of that long engagement, in 1934, the Communists used a great
deal of sense and turned tail and ran. They didn't know where they were headed
but they didn't stop moving for over a year, and by that time, their forces had
been diminished by over 95%. This
became known as the "Long March" and it went for such a length of time
because local leaders, who were basically warlords, were not overjoyed
to see this motley crowd setting up camp in their regions and the group was asked
to move on. Among those on the march
were Mao Tse Dung and Deng Xiaoping who ultimately became two of the most important
leaders of modern China. Meanwhile, the Japanese were busily
occupying Manchuria and by 1937, much of China itself. If it were not for Japan's attack
on Pearl Harbor in 1941, China might well have become a part of Japans empire. However, Japan was forced to turn
its attention to the advancing Americans, who after a slow start soon began leap-froging
the Pacific. Before the American forces had finished
decimating Japan, the Japanese had killed at least 20 million Chinese and had
ravaged China's industries. During
that period, the American Commander in that region, General Stillwell, tried to
get the United States Government to supply materials to help the communists fight
the Japanese by using the seemingly logical argument that the Nationalists were
inept and corrupt. In spite of the
argument's logic, the General was turned down because the United States Government
was backing the Nationalists, probably for all of the wrong reasons.
On the other hand, as soon as World
War II had ended, the Nationalists and Communists resumed their conflict with
a vengeance. The Nationalists courted
disaster by their continued corruption and mountainous debt. The corruption endemic to that entire
regime was never addressed. The Chinese
Nationalists solved their debt crisis by printing mountains of worthless paper
money. This phase of the war was short and
by 1949, the Nationalists were ensconced in Taiwan (Formosa) and the Communists
were solidifying their hard-earned victory throughout Mainland China.
However, not everything went well
with the Communists either; Mao's "The Great Leap Forward, an attempt
to make China agriculturally self-sufficient in 1958, ended in failure with 30
million people dying from hunger. His
government blamed the weather, but the facts argue correctly that it was a case
of very poor planning. In
1962, China broke with their former communist ally, Russia, and in 1966, Mao began
what was called, The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution, unleashing the plague,
which eventually became known as the "Red Guards.
In bizarre fashion, the Red Guards soon began attacking everything in sight
but when they took on the Chinese Army the Government began to have second thoughts
relative to the monster that they had created. The Red Guards had become an equal
opportunity assaulter and when they were not indulging in beating up on the army
itself, needing new worlds to conquer, they started attacking each other,
causing riots throughout the country in 1967. The Cultural Revolution ended by
proclamation in 1969, and the country returned to relative calm. Mao died in 1976 and Deng Xiaoping,
who himself had been purged twice during the Cultural Revolution, assumed leadership.
Deng had been a work-study student in the early 1920s. He joined the
Chinese Communist Party in 1924. When fighting between the Chinese Communists
and the ruling Nationalists broke out in china in 1927, Deng threw himself into
revolutionary work. As on of the military leaders who led the Chinese Communist
Party (CCP) to victory in 1949, he developed a reputation s an outstanding military
strategist as well as a skilled administrator. After the revolution succeeded,
Deng worked briefly in his native province in southwestern China before moving
to Beijing, the capital , where in 1956, he was appointed general secretary of
the CCP, then one of Chinas highest posts. Although Deng was closely associated
with Mao Zedong during the revolutionary years, he was always more practical than
the visionary, indeed utopic, Mao. As Maos policies became more radical
during the late 1950s and early 1960s, Deng increasingly found himself
at odds with the top leader. When Mao launched the Cultural Revolution in 1966,
which was an attempt to return Chinese society to Communist principles, Deng,
after president Liu Shaoqi, became the second most prominent victim of Maos
purges of party officials. While exiled from power, Deng worked part-time in a
tractor factory in rural Jiangxi province in south-central China. ()
He immediately instigated reforms, primarily in the field of
agriculture, eventually making the country nutritionally self-sufficient. The people took Deng's more benevolent
leadership as a sign that reforms had become the order of the day in China. However, they soon learned that repression
was still alive and well. In May
1989, it appears that the people overstepped the unspoken guidelines that had
been laid out for them in secret by the Government. The Tiananmen Square massacre
occurred, sending a very clear message that those in power in Beijing were not
yet ready to accede anarchy to the populace. Deng died at the time China initiated
its own Industrial Revolution, and at one point the country was utilizing fully
one-half the concrete poured in the world.
Moreover, during this period, control over the city-colony of Hong Kong
and then Macao reverted to China. When
the story of the first half of the 21st Century is written, it will
state that China in a relatively short period of time became the leading producer
of industrial products in the world. As
to this potential industrial prowess to create even greater achievements from
here, we have no doubt. To realize the potential, China, must
overcome the problem of internal population dislocations.
The globe has been recently been
faced with enormous temporary movements of people seeking work in wealthier countries.
At times, this process causes massive dislocations when conditions suddenly
change, such as when some very rich countries in the Pacific Rim like Malaysia
discovered that they could no longer afford the luxury of foreign laborers and
had to send people packing to all corners of the globe. Serious problems developed
when many of these foreigners choose not to leave and when the countries of original
origin became unhappy taking back vocally unhappy refugee groups. Some 1.6 million Asians and citizens
of the Middle East were working in Kuwait and Saudi Arabia before they fled Iraqi
War in 1991, and naturally they all also wanted to leave at once. This caused
severe breakdowns in the area's transportation systems as these work-nomads conflicted
with the logistics of the war effort. Tens
of millions of global workers have left destitute regions for more affluent ones,
in pursuit of higher wages and improved opportunities.
At least 2.5 million undocumented Mexicans live in the United
States, let alone millions with visas or naturalization papers. A
Land Of NomadsChina is a country where millions
of people recently began following seasonal employment throughout the country
in order to better themselves. This
recent phenomenon has taken hold more so in China than anywhere else on the planet;
dissimilar income distribution also has raised crime rates and driven international
migration. It is currently estimated
that there are over 100 million nomadic workers in China.
Obviously, any deterioration of the economy will create a need for social
support services that could seriously disrupt Chinas attempts at economic
stabilization. In addition, any major slowdown in the economy will obviously dislocate
itinerant laborers first and cause a massive disgruntled segment of the population
that the government will have to delicately deal with. State companies in China have admitted
that there are 27.53 million surplus workers (redundant and jobless according
to the Ministry of Labor) being forcibly carried by the government. This is an increase of over seven
million since the previous time these statistics were released, and it is commonly
believed that even these redesigned numbers substantially understate the bureaucratic
nepotism practiced by managers to keep the people from becoming discontented.
China had already acknowledged the
existence of over 20 million unneeded workers in the ailing state sector, which
is now undergoing radical restructuring.
The commentary emphasized that the new figures did not include about 130
million surplus rural laborers. It
is difficult to harmonize these almost unlimited numbers of Chinese Gypsies nomadic
wandering the country as most of the rest of Asia still for the most part lies
in economic ruins. Yet in spite of nomadism, the Chinese
leadership has taken an inflexible position relative to its currency: "There
will be no devaluation despite growing pressure to do so, Deputy Prime Minister
Zhu Rongji, said in a newspaper report.
Because of the recent depression
that infected other countries in the Pacific Rim, foreign investment in China
dropped a substantial 35% in 1998. Other
countries in the area devalued their currencies and because of it, now may have
become economically more competitive than China.
China's export advantage to some part is derived from unpaid prison labor,
may soon be lost to a tougher foe in the form of the devalued currencies of its
neighbors. However, we believe that China poses
a serious challenge to the entire globe should its economic machine grind to a
halt, civil unrest will grow and the country loses its already waning agricultural
self-sufficiency. At this point,
China could once again become isolationist and withdraw from the global economic
arena. The disastrous consequences for its
domestic economy can be easily imagined. While this scenario is highly unlikely,
China is now in a position to undercut world prices in literally every manufactured
product. Globally, nations are being beaten
up by skyrocketing oil prices on one hand, unemployment on another and Chinese
competitiveness making up the third corner of a deadly triangle. Should things
get even worse, China has plenty of room to lower prices even more sending even
more Latinos and Europeans into the unemployment lines. As unemployment increases,
tax collections diminish creating an economic death spiral for all countries involved.
Sooner or later, this will be the unpleasant scenario that we will all have to
face. This problem is hardly limited to
China, but Chinas problem is of a much larger dimension than that of other
countries. As opposed to the orderly
migration of the past, which in its greater sense, historically resulted in personal
transference of allegiance and the ultimate permanency of citizenship,
the migrations or dislocations of today have created an itinerant workforce that
wafts dangerously from one country another country.
This transient army survives by plying
the globe, scavenging work from indigenous populations for what would be considered
to be locally unacceptable compensation with little hope of governmentally approved
permanent residency within either the national or the regional borders (). These will be the new mercenaries
()
of the 21st century, and as population problems intensify, borders
that are flexible when people leave may not be open when it is time to return.
In Asia, workers can be allowed in and thrown out as the need for additional bodies
waxes and wanes. In Europe the situation is not so
simple, borders are porous for several reasons, the first and foremost is the
fact that the people of all of the European Community countries have equal access
to each others borders. Thus, the laborers in Portugal, Spain and Greece
have gravitated to the higher wage paying countries of Germany, France and the
Nordic countries. The EU will eventually only tend to equalize the suffering of
Europe, The second reason that Europe acts as a ready home for nomadic laborers
is the fact that many countries on the continent either dont or physically
cant their borders because of corruption or geographic impossibility. Italy
is one such country and peoples from all over the world are able to slip in Europe
by heading in that direction. In the Pacific Rim, the richer countries
had imported millions of workers from the poorer nations. Malaysia and Thailand
were particularly big in bringing in foreign workers to do the more menial work.
When their economies collapsed, the respective governments determined that it
was time for these migrants to return from whence they had come and it was so
ordered. These poorer nations by this time were in even worse shape, places like
Indonesia and the Philippines could not reabsorb such prodigious elements of their
population and resisted taking their own people back. In addition, the transient
laborers were not exactly excited to going back to poverty and they also did not
line up for the ferry ride home. This created serious problems with many people
being killed during this period of time. The United States in all of its prosperity
is not exempt from not having a clue relative to what to do about it immigration
problem. With unemployment at record low levels, the approach that the United
States has been using recently, of excepting professionals that have particularly
needed talents no longer seems to fly. It is the menial laborers that are now
in demand and as the population of the United States becomes even more upwardly
mobile, the problem will become more intense. The immigration regulations are
now undergoing an extreme tinkering and a dramatic shift in the type of people
that immigrate will be seen in the near future. But what happens here when the
economy starts to back up which it looks like it is doing now?
This
process of nomadic migration is gaining momentum with the occurrence of a particularly
unique trend. Whereas previously women never migrated,
at least without a male partner, but they are doing it today and in greater and
greater numbers. As productive land becomes less and
less available to indigenous populations and the rural poor also become part of
the itinerant poll of migrants. Both
of the above factors have accelerated as poverty, at least on a relative scale,
becomes worsened. PopulationIndia, with a population of 949 million
people, and estimated to be on target to overtake China as the worlds most
populous country by the year 2047, with a then population of 1.62 billion, certainly
represents an appetizing target for global business; a market with pent-up demand
for almost every kind of product and a middle class that can afford to purchase
them. Before your mouth starts watering
too much, lets look at the situation, as it exists today.
It has been perceived as strange
by the uninformed as to why China has peaked the interest of so many of the world's
major industries and India, similarly positioned, has been treated by global investors
as a pariah. The global perception
and the actual facts in this case are one in the same. Pure and simply, the Indian
government is extremely reluctant to go through the painful process of creating
a favorable business environment, which in turn has resulted in a startling relative
constriction of foreign direct investment.
This is illustrated by offshore funds infused into China last year were
twenty times more than those earmarked for India. Although China is not exactly
free of bureaucracy, India has created new meaning for the term and stultification
has risen to a level heretofore unheard of in global business relative to democratic
country. This is not unusual when analyzing
the attitudes towards business normalization practiced by the diametrically different
governments. Whereas China until
recently had no infrastructure, Indias has fallen apart from abuse and can
only be restored at a staggering cost. In
spite of the fact that India had a national phone network decades ago, by the
turn of the century, callers will be able to reach almost all of China and literally
none of India. What roads China had were literally,
only usable by foot traffic, animals and some bicycles.
Today, China is putting the finishing touches on a band of four lane highways
connecting the length and breath of the country, while Indias congested
thoroughfares make traveling any distance a painful experience.
China has embarked on massive projects
to create power, dams, and grids while energy plants can be seen rising throughout
the landscape. By contrast, the absence
of adequate power supplies acts as a major deterrent to factory construction in
India. Any attempt to attract foreign labor, financing or other assistance is
met with unconscionable bureaucratic bungling, political paranoia and restrictive
regulations. While China is not necessarily idyllic when it comes to bureaucracy,
India has given bribery and indolence new meaning. China has gone from agrarian state
to industrial one in less than two decades.
It used to be a nation that could not meet its own peoples needs. Now it wants to supply the globe. Through the use of low wages, forced
labor and modern, more sophisticated production equipment, the country has seized
many markets from its neighbors/competitors, Thailand, The Philippines and Malaysia. However, China in their rush to a
market economy has seemingly forgotten their vaunted healthcare system for the
rural poor. The free clinics that once serviced the medical needs of the farming
communities and the so-called barefoot doctors have all but vanished.
In decentralizing its system, Central Government planners attempted the shift
the burdens of healthcare and education away from the federal government and unto
the provincial bureaucrats. Welfare
or a Lack of It.While this was a logical concept,
there are 800 million Chinese peasants in rural communities who mostly do not
earn enough to even pay for food and taxes and the outlying provinces are hard-pressed
to afford anything let alone expensive subsidies such as these. The rural health system has become a hodgepodge
of hospitals and clinics that are often privately run and almost always prohibitively
expensive, where treatment for a cold can eat up two months income and giving
birth in a hospital tow years of hard-earned cash. ()
In Chinas new, pay-as-you-go
economy, the government clinics that formerly dotted the countryside are still
there, but they have now been privatized and have been turned into profit making
institutions. Doctors visits that used to cost 60 cents, still do, but it
is the extras that eat your lunch, important things like medicines have gone through
the roof. Even formerly free immunizations now costs money and a system that provided
for everyone is now producing a recurrence of tuberculosis which has quadrupled
in the last 15-years. Giving birth in a hospital can take up to two-years income
and the only alternative is to have children at home. However, for the most part,
there may not be any running water or sanitary conditions. Infant deaths have
risen substantially in recent years because of this fact. If is both the lack
of available educational and health facilities that are causing many, whose families
have tilled their own land for hundreds of years, to leave for the cities and
a potentially better life. It couldnt be any worse but maybe China figured
this out as the only way to fuel their massive factories and production quotas.
With this type of steamroller competition,
there is no longer any margin for error in the economies of China's Pacific Rim
competitors. China now suffers excess
capacity problems in many industries, and factory prices have fallen over 10%
in just over a year, and are headed lower.
Having built and maintained industrial facilities that are adaptable, it
can convert relatively easily from one production line to another.
This is not the time for other macho governments in Asia to prove who is
has the biggest credentials; it is time for their leaders to
take a constructive stand before they are eaten alive by the Chinese.
A Serious
ProblemAnother
disease that in a relatively short time has become literally, a plague within
the interior of China is AIDS. Many villages in China have the highest rates of
HIV in the world and for good reason. Local bureaucrats encouraged citizens to
both sell and contribute their blood to government sponsored pools that retained
that blood within a pool for the donor should he or his family have the need or
sold it if they felt that there was an excess. However, the sanitary and medical
precautions that should have accompanied these massive donations were either wanting
or unknown. The selling of blood had become so commonplace that many have estimated
that as many as 95% of the Chinese population within certain districts were involved
at one time or another. As many as 60% of these people have been stricken with
the disease.
"In
the early 1990's, Chinese biological product companies -- some with foreign partners
-- started relying on China's isolated impoverished heartland a an ideal place
to get cheap, clean plasma, the part of the blood that is used to make medicines
like gamma globulin and clotting factors. Health officials in the province (Henan)
often became enthusiastic middlemen, setting up blood-collection stations. Some
profited personally from the trade, while others saw it as a harmless way to bring
cash into a destitute region with few resources. Because of the plasma collection
methods routinely used at the time throughout China, even those who donated only
a few times ran a high risk of becoming ill, experts said. Blood from dozens of
sellers was pooled and put into a "huge centrifuge," the villagers said,
where it was spun to separate the desired plasma. The remaining fraction, mainly
red cells, was divided up and transfused back into the sellers, who felt the process
to be healthful because it limited the blood loss." "That
highly unsanitary process meant that once one blood seller in a village was infected
with HIV or hepatitis, the rest were quick to catch the disease, since the viruses
from other people's bodies rode along with the unwanted red cells back into their
veins. Since the sellers were not losing red cells with each donation, which would
have resulted in severe anemia, the method also disastrously meant that the farmers
could sell frequently -- raising their chance of infection." (New York
Times 5-28-2001 Deadly Shadow of AIDS Darkens Remote Chinese Village. The
saddest part of this whole situation is the fact that the villagers received on
about $5 dollars for each pint they donated and when they got sick, no one really
knew what they had or how to treat it. Officially, the Chinese Government is treating
these villagers as having the plague. In other words they are really not interested
in the outside getting the notion that the disease even exists here. However,
it does exist and it has become a big-time problem in spite of the fact that bureaucrats
wish that it would go away. In addition, the people that were originally
infected because of unsanitary needles or being re-injected with tainted red cells
did not realize that the disease could be transmitted by other means even once
that stopped selling their blood. This double whammy has recently begun to infect
another generation and has caused an epidemic to say the lest. Most interesting
of all, the medicines that are used to great effect in Africa to prevent mothers
transmitting the disease to their children have not seen the light of day here
in China. Some
people in Henan Province became aware of the HIV related problems that the unsanitary
collection and sale of blood was causing earlier than others. One of those people
was Dr. Gao Yaojie, who in spite of government resistance worked tirelessly to
help the villagers coupe with literally unsolvable problems. Dr. Yaojie literally
toiled alone due to the fact that the Provincial Government did not want to bring
outside attention to what this highly profitable but morbid business had produced.
However, in spite of China's attempts to hide the truth from the rest of the world,
the good doctors efforts were ultimately noticed by outsiders. When
the international community came to realize the magnitude of her accomplishments
in helping AIDS sufferers, she came in for substantial global acclaim. However,
bringing this serious medical problem to the worlds attention by vocally
fighting for medical help for the people of Henan she stepped on some important
toes of the governmental agencies did who did not even want to admit that
the problem existed. Many bureaucrats in China were displeased to say the least.
In attempts to discredit her, local governmental officials tried every trick that
they had available including the indication that she was sponsored by foreign
governments that were seeking to undermine China. They also indicated that these
unnamed enemies of the state were footing the bill in her fight in spite of the
fact that they were well away that the money had come from her own meager resources. For
all of these things, Dr. Gao Yaojie was had bestowed upon her the highest acclamation
in that field of science, the Jonathan Mann Award for Health and Human Rights
awarded annually by the Global Health Council. Fittingly, Secretary General Kofi
Annan of the United Nations was to be the presenter, but sadly, this great humanist
will not get her public 15 minutes of fame, as the Chinese Government attempts
to create an iron-wall around the entire affair. They have refused to allow Dr.
Yaojie the opportunity of traveling to the United States to claim her just deserves
because it was felt that this would only magnify the publicity of this dread diseases
spread. Adding insult to injury, while publicly China now talks about the wonderful
work that she has done, privately, she is forced to work alone within a massive
sea of intellectual darkness. The
fact that Aids or HIV were not particularly well known until recently is not an
oddity in this country. After all, sex was seen as something not to be talked
about during the early years of communism. Parents didn't discuss it with their
children and it certainly wasn't anything that you learned about in school. Premarital
sex was unusual and it was a literally taboo subject in the media. There were
no centerfolds or playmates in this era, There were hardly any cases of
sexually transmitted diseases in China until at least the middle 80s when a rapprochement
with the West was commenced. This relationship brought along everything the West
had to offer which included both the good and the bad. An
interesting example of this is the fact that there were almost 500,000 cases of
sexually transmitted diseases in China in the year 1997. In 1985 there were only
a tad over 5,000 sexually transmitted cases recorded in the country. However,
during this time of increasing numbers of diseases that are sexually oriented,
private clinics have sprung up that give quiet consultation and medication to
those that can afford it so that the state does not become involved. If these
often unspoken figures were added to the previous number, there is little question
that the final amount would have been substantially larger. While
sexually transmitted diseases are becoming increasingly a problem in China, strangely,
the blame cannot totally be laid on the fact that many of the people were only
trying to pick up a few extra dollars. Getting shots is almost a cultural happening
in China and they are given for literally everything and anything and from cradle
to grave. However, there is a difference between the conditions under which shots
are given in China and the way they are administered in the rest of the of the
world. The United Nations Common Country Assessment for China in 1999 indicated
that this is exemplified by the chilling statistics that show that no less than
60 percent of total Chinese population is infected with the deadly hepatitis "B".
As a matter of comparison, their Japanese and American counterparts only have
a 1 percent infection rate among their populations. Thus, the number cases
of liver failure and cancer are geometric greater in china than in other countries.
As a matter of fact, while cancer of the liver is extremely rare in the west,
it is the preeminent cancer killer in China. Even
those medically oriented people in China that practice conservative medicine,
that is the giving of one shot from one hypodermic needle and than discarding
it are really unable to stop the flow of Hepatitis "B" from infected
needles. In reality, the country of China has become a gigantic materials recycling
machine and while that is environmentally sound and economically logical, there
is a potential downside. Somewhat similar to the anecdotal story about the fact
that when the meatpacking companies in the United States got finished with a pig,
they had made use of everything but the oink and were trying to find a way to
capture that as well. In China, when the garbage is thrown out, all of its component
parts are subdivided and then re-subdivided once again. In
the case of the materials used in the giving of shots; there is no legitimate
method of monitoring the progress of the needle's dismantling along with
the plastic IV tubing as it wends it way from one recycling facility to another.
Often the process in China becomes derailed when a substantial bid, that is too
good to turn down comes in for the still blood stained total product. Statistics
in China show that that the number of cases of Hepatitis "B" and HIV
are directly correlated to the number of shots a person receives each year, condemning
the needles themselves. China has become a massive production line turning out
endless quantities of infected people because they seem to be unable to stop practicing
poor medicine. Body
PartsPeople
were ostracized in those years if they even talked about the subject of sex in
public, but then communication began in earnest with the rest of the world and
sex reared its ugly head. Today, sex shops are as ubiquitous as vegetable markets
all over the country with their strange assortment of rubber products, the subject
is taught in schools, discussed in the media and prostitution abounds. Viagra
is a big seller and herbal remedies that promise sexual Nirvana are plastered
on billboards all over town. It is no wonder though that when sex arrived in China,
the gory details of what it brought with it were not subjects that the government
was interested in exposing to its own citizens. They no have become quite adept
at it but are not sure yet what it is. However, this does not change the fact
that China in many cases has literally no labor cost because their factories are
often located on prison sites. In
such plants, the only fee a criminal gets is bread, water and another day on earth.
Despite these low labor rates, China has been caught in the vortex of down-drafting
currencies. For many prisoners, bread
and water in exchange for 20-hour workdays is the good news and life sometimes
can get even worse for those incarcerated under the Chinese system.
When a prisoner's production falls below acceptable levels, he is no longer
considered useful by the state. At that point, his body, which is thought
of as state property, is summarily reclaimed sometimes even before the prisoner
has official been pronounced dead. Interestingly enough, the mining of peoples
body parts against their will is illegal in every country in the world with the
exception of Iran, but this doesn't bother Chinese officials in the least. And
in spite of the fact that many organs are in short supply worldwide, kidney donors
stand outside of hospital rooms in both India and Iraq offering to donate for
a $1,000 or less. While not always of the bargain basement variety, kidney donors
seem to be readily available in the especially, Palestinians from Jordan, and
locals in Philippines, Turkey and Singapore as well. Turkey and Iraq have also
become a focal point for organ transplant surgery. The hapless Chinese convict is executed,
usually by lethal injection, which tends to preserve organs for export more effectively
than competing methods. The old method
of skinning, quartering and chopping people in half at the waist
does not cut it when internal organs are needed. The victims organs are medically removed and packaged
for resale internationally or if required, the recipient can receive his new organ
within China itself. Chinese parts salesman are
discreetly sent on global marketing missions in search of those in need of body
upgrades. In a recent New York City arrest of
Chinese organ dealers, the available menu was found to include kidneys, corneas,
pancreases, skin and lungs guaranteed to come from non-smokers, all neatly catalogued
with prices attached. The traveling parts salesmen also
offer cut rate transplants if the buyer wants to have the surgery performed in
China. As body component orders in this industry
increase, crimes that the government considers capital in nature have been substantially
expanded to meet production demands. Currently,
according to the New York Times, robbers and counterfeiters sit
on death row. The growth rate has been prodigious
thanks to industrious and sophisticated sales and marketing techniques employed
by the Chinese. Amnesty International stated that in 1996
that China executed more than 4,300 people, which would mean that it did away
with more criminals than the rest of the world combined and made a shambles of
the runner-up Ukraine, which could only dispense with several hundred.
China sentenced an additional 6,100 to death, thus insuring an adequate
supply of organs for international sale in the ensuing years. While china has
indicated that it is changing its ways, international organizations have seen
little change in their policies. Of particular interest to
Chinese economists are the facts that this industry has not suffered capacity
problems and sales are made almost exclusively for hard currency.
The materials are readily available in whatever quantities are desired,
at little or no cost, and the economic crisis in the Pacific Rim has not impacted
business. Socially, the business makes even
more sense, as society's undesirables are eliminated at a profit to the State. Although Amnesty International, the
United States State Department and other governments are upset by the
practice, China appears not to give a damn one way or the other. Before getting to sanguine about the Chinese transplant process,
it would be interesting to point out that while Americans have an aversion relative
to going overseas for organ transplants, American hospitals are leaders in allowing
both live donors and organ recipients into their operating rooms. As opposed to
most other countries, there is no national legislation regarding this and therefore,
it has become primarily an economic consideration when local hospitals determine
to do the medical procedure. The
United States does have a law against the sale of organs and it is a felony to
negotiate their purchase or sale on American soil according to a Federal law passed
by congress in 1984. Nevertheless, this has not stopped people who are desperately
in need of violating these provisions in spite of the fact that the penalty for
getting caught is substantial and includes up to five years in jail and/or a fine
of up to $50,000. Furthermore, and probably just so that no one gets the wrong
impression, it is illegal for a person convicted of a crime residing in an American
prison to donate or agree to donate an organ currently or after his demise. Moral
and legal considerations that motivated this law; its intent is logical and its
meaning crystal clear. However, if you live in China and are convicted of even
a minor crime, you face the removal of any and all of your organs.
China,
a country that executes more criminals than all of the other countries
on the face of the earth combined, often holds mass executions if only to send
the message that they are being tough on crime. In China this is known as killing
the chicken to scare the monkey. To maximize press exposure, the authorities
often schedule executions on national holidays. It is at these times of the year
that everyone who could possibly profit from organ transfers queues up to get
a share of the spoils. Mass killing are often organized for army budgetary reasons.
The
organizations that benefit from organ harvesting from executed prisoners observe
an inflexible pecking order. The army gets first choice and probably receives
up to 70 percent of the total number of organs removed. In China, as opposed to
most other countries, the army is basically on a pay as you go basis, and must
come up with various for profit schemes to support itself.
However, its influence within the central government is substantial, and
it enjoys unique perquisites. Moreover,
there is a tacit agreement between the army and the government that these outside
enterprises are meant to enhance the senior military pay scale and to relieve
some of the tax burden of the civilian government, which has been none too successful
in the collection of taxes. This relationship also tends to keep the army in the
governments pocket and the balance of power firmly entrenched in Beijing.
However, the army, is forced to kick back part of the fees that it receives to
those who make available the fresh corpses for harvesting. To insure quality control,
most of preliminary medical analysis occurs in military hospitals to which prisoners
are transferred before execution.
Money from patients purchasing organs is dispersed among those
who provide access to the prisoners body. Hospitals even pay judges to tip
them off when they sentence a suitable donor to death. The money goes to officials
all of the way up the line. It goes to the courts, the people in charge of the
prisons. It goes to the doctors, the hospitals, everything. () However,
it is at this point that the orchestration really begins. The execution must be
carefully timed so that it will conform to the scheduled transplant surgery. The
more quickly that the organ can be transferred from one body to another, the more
likely it is that the procedure will succeed, an important ingredient in the word
of mouth advertising in this underground occupation. While the subject is taboo,
this is unquestionably big business in China, and nobody wants to get a reputation
for a botched job that would kill off a substantial income stream. In these cases
it is critical that all of the participants in the genocide, the army officials,
the judges, the hospitals, the surgeons and the recipient,
coordinate the time of the prisoners execution in order to maximize
the probability of success. An appeals process would throw this whole intricate
mechanism into a cocked hat, and therefore is discouraged by the actors in this
obscene drama. There are no last
minute reprieves for the condemned when the executions time and place have
been set.
In China, human rights groups say, citizens have been executed
for nonviolent offenses like taking bribes, credit card theft, small-scale tax
evasion, and stealing truckloads of vegetables. Political dissidents have also
been sentenced to death
Forced labor from Chinas laogai has
always been a source of cash for the countrys rapidly advancing economy.
And punishment doesnt necessarily end at the point of death, usually a single
shot to the back of the head. Families are often forced to pay for the bullet
used. But the laogai turned into Execution, Inc. less than 20 years ago
after the introduction of Cyclospoine, an immunosuppressant drug that prevents
rejection of organs by the recipients body. ()
The
inmate is terminated in a manner that will not jeopardize the particular delicate
organs that have already been pre-sold; after all, you wouldnt want to shoot
a man in the heart of your were going to do a transplant of that organ or in the
brain if you needed corneas. More often than not, a shot in the head will suffice,
when a liver, kidney, spleen or the like is needed and one to the heart should
there be demand for eyes. Thus, the demography of each unwilling donor must be
carefully analyzed as to which of his body parts would do the best elsewhere and
these are carefully cultivated with consideration given to the relative synergy
of the body parts in question. Whether
or not the victim is in good health is critically important to the recipient and
surprisingly in Chinese jail, apart from any other countries in the world, the
healthy have a much higher accident rate than the ailing. Non-smokers
have a much shorter life expectancy in prison than smokers and unbelievably, people
with incurable cancer and AIDS seem to live much longer than healthy young men.
However, in China, if you are a wealthy person desiring the better things
in life, you can get various perks for a price, these menu items include but are
not limited to better accommodations, the designation of a particular surgeon,
a more careful surgical match to avoid the possibility of rejection and a choice
execution date. However, this sword cuts on both ways; heaven help you if you
get your transplant and during your recovery, your funds suddenly run out. More
often then not, you would find yourself without the necessary anti-rejection serum
and you too could suddenly become a candidate for being someone elses salvation.
No one ever said that life in China was easy. Bullets
are considered a luxury in China and are not always wasted on the condemned. If
the organs can be quietly removed while the convict is still alive, it makes for
a garden-fresh transplant and can command a premium press. Moreover, in these
cases the prisoner is heavily sedated, the desired organs are removed and the
unwilling benefactor is buried, whether he has expired or not.
Occasionally
the highly orchestrated procedure comes unglued and the army doesnt discover
an upcoming execution. This is when the locals can get into the act and really
clean up. First, the local head of a prison where the condemned man is awaiting
execution pays him a visit and discusses the fact that he could, for a price be
allowed to sell his organs upon his death. In this way, he is told, he will be
able to leave his family the money that is earned on the sale which will undoubtedly
help them immeasurably. However, the warden or his bag man must be paid a fee
for going to all of this trouble, and the fee has to be paid upfront by the mans
family. More often than not, the hapless prisoner acquiesces and his family, borrowing
from everyone in sight, ultimately comes up with the cash.
The
prisoner is executed and the organs are transferred to an anxiously waiting beneficiary.
Moreover, it is at that time that the convict is immolated according to a prearranged
plan. This, though, is the stage at which the rub comes in; the victims
family attempts to collect the fee derived from the organ sale and is told that
the prisoners body did not produce a salable harvest and his innards could
not be utilized by the donee and that the entire matter has become a disaster
for which the family is directly responsible for because of his inferior interior.
Furthermore, they are told that the State went to great expense to see that this
medical procedure was finalized, only to be left with a massive problem, a failed
surgical procedure. It is indicated to them that if they do not shut up about
the situation that they have personally caused, they will be charged for the botched
job caused by their relatives inferior innards. The shamed family skulks
off in permanently insured silence. Ask
a Chinese official if this organ harvesting for pay practice even exists and you
will be met with either a denial or no comment at all. If the official would say
anything, he might quote directly from one of the Chinese laws which states, for
a prisoner to be a donor, prior consent must be given by that person or remaining
family, unless the body is unclaimed. The bodies of the majority of executed
persons go unclaimed because, more often than not, the families have no clue as
to where their loved ones are held or of what crime they stand accused.
Moreover, for health reasons unclaimed bodies are normally cremated. Unclaimed
means that about five minutes after the desired organs have been harvested, the
body is taken to the oven and converted to ash for use as fertilizer on nearby
farms. Life
is comparatively cheap in this part of the world and everyone wants to get in
on the act. As a matter of fact, the Chinese as even established a procedure that
must be followed to the letter in these cases: Surgical vans must not display
hospital logos; surgeons must not wear hospital uniforms when at the execution
site, guard must be present until the organ is removed; and the corpses should
be promptly cremated following the removal of the organs. Essentially what
these procedures envision is keeping the practice as far from prying eyes as is
humanly possible. Supply
and DemandHowever,
while Americans gladly get their transplants from China, they want to get their
post operative treatment and anti-rejection drugs from the United States. More
often than not, the reason simply put is that no matter where the organ came from
and no matter how illegal and immoral the procedure was, the patients are entitled
to not only treatment in American hospitals but to Medicare, Medicaid or whatever
other insurance they may have. Furthermore, if they can not afford to pay (which
would seem unlikely if they had the money to fly to China, buy an organ and have
the surgery there) they cannot be denied treatment in U.S. Government-operated
hospitals. However
as much as the Chinese wish to cover up the fact they are indeed the largest supplier
of organs to the human market, folks like ex army doctor, Wang Guoqi continually
undermine their attempts at stealth. It seems that Wang somehow or other got out
of China and one of his first stops was testify in front of the House Committee
on International Relations June 27, 2001. What he said left little to the
imagination. He stated that he was an army burn specialist by training and as
such he was assigned to run a unit that would remove both the skin and corneas
from the bodies of over 100 victims of executions in China's prisons. Wang proceeded
to tell the American Congressmen that once the court officials had been paid off
their standard stipend of $40, the prisoners were given a dose of anticoagulant
heparin and were then summarily executed. If
you have the stomach for it you can read Dr. Wang's description of how his work
was accomplished in gory detail. "A circumferential cut was made around the
wrist, the ankle and the shoulder joint as deep as the subcutaneous fat layer
or the layer above the muscles. A longitudinal cut was made on the inner side
of the upper limb linking both circumferential cuts, either from top to bottom
or in the opposite direction. After twenty minutes or so, what was left was an
ugly heap of muscles, the blood vessels still bleeding, or all viscera exposed.
The skin was processed and chilled for use in later transplants in which patients
were charged 100 Yuan for each 10 square centimeters of skin, the other organs
were also sold." Dr.
Wang who couldn't take it anymore and stopped doing the body unbundling and resigned
after first signing a stipulation that he would never talk about what he did to
anyone else. He sneaked out of China and now is waiting tables at a restaurant
in New Jersey. A Chinese spokeswoman when told of Wang's charges only indicated
that these procedures were approved by the country's highest court in 1984. Currency
FluctuationsThere are not enough niche markets
available to deflect the recent currency devaluation of Chinas neighbors,
and there is not much question that the Yuan had become relatively overvalued. China now faces a situation where
they have over capacity in most areas of production, a gypsy labor detachment
of over 100 million people wandering the country looking for work, and a currency
that has effectively appreciated in value 50% on a comparative basis.
Although Chinas economy has held up admirably under the circumstances,
the jury is still out as to how much long that this can continue in the dog-eat-dog
competitiveness of the Pacific Rim.
Moreover, China, which does not have
excessive foreign debt, is holding the line relative to devaluation,
more because of face than practicality.
On the other hand, there is not much question that if China devalued at
this vulnerable time for the region, it could well bankrupt almost all of its
Pacific Rim competition and send the countries back into the Stone Age.
China's leaders seem to by aware of this delicate balance and are rightly
concerned, it would appear that they are waiting for the Pacific Rim to recover
before further considering if and when they may devalue the Yuan.
The risks involved are tremendous,
and the other countries know it. Korea which is going through a Japanese style
reorganization because of their inherent system of supporting under-managed companies
that have managements that could not make money if they were given the keys to
Fort Knox and a wheel barrel, has taken the position of offering buyers long-term
contracts at substantially reduced prices. This is what it is going to take to
stay competitive with Chinas newly discovered instincts for economic survival
make it an awesome competitor. When
the time comes to close the trap, it is likely that its leadership's timing will
be impeccable. Chinese Vice Premier, Zhu Rhonji,
in a meeting with then Deputy Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers told him that,
Chinas unequivocal commitment to hold the current Yuan exchange rate
was in cast in stone. But you had
better believe that in some places stone doesnt last as long as it does
in others, and this particular stone may be of the short-lived variety.
Fraud Just as everywhere else, China has
its share of fraud in spite of still being a communist nation where extreme wealth
stands out like a sore thumb. On
the other hand, the bureaucrats that run the country need their creature comforts,
and who can blame them. It seems
that during the building of a series of dikes along the Yangtze River to protect
the hundreds of thousands of people who live along its banks from flooding, officials
who had to visit the area as part of their work were extremely inconvenienced
by a lack of five-star hotel facilities near the construction site.
All being of the same mind, they
plucked $120 million from the dike allocation funds and built a hotel at which
they would be proud to stay. This
money represented almost forty percent of the total allocation towards the system
of dikes and forced workers to use inferior products to finish the work.
On the other hand, the hotel has become a major money loser because no
one in the region has the money to afford one night, let alone several. Thus, when the dike bursts because
of the inferior products that went into it, the downstream hotel along with vacationing
bureaucrats will probably be swept into oblivion, a fitting end to this saga.
But this is life in modern China. The Chinese Government insures the
availability of food for its population by buying agricultural products and storing
them in various warehouses around the country until they are needed for transshipment
to their final destination. These
purchases by the State literally are the lifes blood of 900 million people
whose livelihoods are agriculturally based.
The basic problem with the system is the middlemen.
The system is highly complex and its nuances are so substantial that they
do not lend themselves to repetition in this commentary. However a short form
explanation of the process would be as follows: the provincial governments borrow
money from the State to make purchases and these loans have to be paid back when
the agricultural products are sold. A recent audit by the Finance Ministry
and the Central Bank has shown that the Chinese equivalent of $25.8 billion has
literally vanished from these state grain-purchase funds over the last six years.
This is surprising for several reasons.
The first is the enormity of the disappearance, and the second is the government's
admission of an internal error, an admission that highlights the Government's
view of the gravity of the problem. Feeling secure in the inventory figures
that they were receiving, the Central Government initially had no concerns regarding
agricultural self-sufficiency. It was only after early audits showed dramatic slippage that
the government went into orbit. Now, the Central Government was faced with their
second problem. In China, the provincial governments
function autonomously. While everything
is eventually reported to Beijing, this can take substantial time.
In addition, regional leaders sometimes feel that when they owe money to
the Central Government, the stated amount of the debt is only a guideline, not
an obligation. Thus, in the course of the investigation
it was found that the money had been spent on things regional leaders viewed as
more pressing, fun things such as cellular phones, cars, stocks, futures trading
and investments in apartment buildings and hotels.
Buying high and selling low is where most of the money went when bureaucratic
novices though that they could beat the markets. The extreme oddity of this situation
is the fact that this wasnt the action of one rogue province run by a maniac,
it was pattern that repeated itself within all regions of China almost like spontaneous
combustion. In reality, the fault
lies to the some degree at the feet of the Central Government. While the rules stated that all agricultural
production had to be sold to the State, when the bottom fell out of prices a decade
ago, the government turned a blind eye to farmers selling their products directly. When prices recovered, the Chinese
Government never reined in the practice.
As a result, two virtually diametrically opposed policies existed for a
period, side by side. Farmers went where they could do the best. If prices dropped, they sold at a
"floor" rate set by the Central Government to the Central Government. If prices rose, the farmers would
sell to the highest bidder. That,
coupled with the poor administration of the State Grain Bureau, caused much of
the problem. Still leaders in Beijing are at a
loss to explain how these billions of dollars could have gone up in smoke under
their very eyes. Worse yet, the offenders
seem for the most part to be the leaders themselves, the provincial governments
and the farmers. Playing
The GameMoreover, the Chinese stock market
has become a legitimate method of separating the hopelessly naïve pheasants from
their hard earned money. Inconceivable amounts of currency were removed from mattresses
and other hiding places and the funds used to purchase securities in the emerging
Chinese securities markets. The only problem with this that the regulations governing
the marketplace in China are toothless and for the most part not enforced. The
bad guys, using Internet and countless other strategies are able to spin stories
about Chinese companies and their prospects which would put Ponzi to shame. Unbelievably,
a common chicken-breeding operation with about as much growth opportunities as
rock was touted as the second coming in the Chinese stock markets.
The stocks price went into
the stratosphere and it was at this time apparently that the companys management
started to believe their own propaganda. They raised $250 million from local banks,
telling them that the money was for
expansion purposes and proceeded
to use the borrowed funds to prop-up the chicken ranch stock when it started to
go south. Eventually, almost everyone lost,
the banks, the company and the investors. A number of senior executives of the
Chicken company felt obligated to beat a hasty retreat from the country.
The Chinese equivalent of our Securities and Exchange never monitored the
companys growingly optimistic announcements, the banks never checked to
see where their money was being used and the poor investors werent even
certain what business the company was in. Moreover, no one really knew
where to go to find information about the company in spite of the fact
that the chicken operation was listed on a major Chinese exchange. Chinese stock
markets are the Wild West of the global securities industry and no
one is watching the store. The money that has been already lost is incalculable.
Little Time PoliticsWhile China in theory has joined
the ranks of global leadership, its political infrastructure is little changed.
The local Communist Party Chief is in charge of all small towns and rules
dictatorially. The local police who
act as his right arm back him up. Salaries for Party Chiefs are not
high and they augment their earnings through extortion and other sundry crimes. Effectively, each city, town and hamlet
has a similar feudal system, with the Party Chief acting as a Lord and exacting
tribute; the police are the knights that enforce its collection.
The Lord's coach is almost always a black limousine, and paying jobs are
sold to the highest bidder, set at a predetermined scale based on the annualized
bribery related-income of the home office. The Central Government states this
type of corruption is rare. However,
an article in the March 11, 1999 New York Times indicated otherwise:
corruption is now
virtually built into the middle levels of Chinas vast authoritarian apparatus,
under an ideology that has become a hollow shell while the new market economy
swells around it. Westerners often decry human rights
conditions in China, citing political restrictions on writers and intellectuals
in the large cities. But for hundreds of millions of ordinary
Chinese who live in towns and villages, it is the unrestrained authority of a
local party chief that is usually most oppressive.
Hu Angang who is a professor
of the School of Public Policy and Management at Singh University stated that
illicit siphoning of funds from projects and companies wiped out the equivalent
of 13% to 16% of Chinas gross domestic product, or about $150 billion, over
the last decade
it is of the Governments top challenges. They are fighting
a kind of social pollution
Last week; authorities in South Chinas Guangdong
province sentenced seven people to death for tax fraud. Among them were two tax
officials who used fake tax receipts to claim rebates on exports. Dozens of senior
Chinese officials have also become entangled in smuggling scandals uncovered in
the coastal cities of Xiamen and Shantou. ()
Guangdong Province sits in the important southeastern tier of China. Because of
its strategic location and substantial resources, fully fifty-percent of China’s
export earnings come from this area. While in theory, all of China is equal; there
is not much question in anybody’s mind that Guangdong has been more equal than
others. This equality manifests itself in the provinces historic independence.
Some say that this came about through an arrangement made between Marshall Ye,
a General who was a leading figure in Guangdong in the 1970's and Deng Xiaoping,
who was involved in a power struggle for control after Mao Tse-tung’s death in
1976. As the story goes, Ye was asked for his support by Deng. Ye said he
would go along but wanted a little something in return. This arrangement purportedly
solidified an arrangement whereby the Central Government of China was to let the
administration of the province alone. The agreement cast in stone a system
of corrupt leadership that traversed the province from one end to the other. Whether
the story is factual or apocryphal is not an issue; the province is run by the
politicians with an iron hand and for a while they believed that they could do
no wrong. The
province created a for-profit private company with the auspicious name of the
“Guangdong International Trust and Investment Company (GITIC)"; soon the
company became the envy of all China. Its shares for a time were the highest fliers
on the stock exchange. Hong Kong raised debt financing for them any number of
times, bringing in Western investors by the score; institutions from all over
the globe were buying the stock. But sadly, GITIC and other companies set up by
the province created international and internal debt that exceeded the province's
annual gross revenues. Things might have turned out ok in the long run, but the
collapse in the Pacific Rim doomed Guangdong's experiment. Provincial revenues
were no longer enough to pay the freight and GITIC sunk into bankruptcy taking
the savings of half of the people in the province along with it.
China’s entire budget was thrown into a cocked hat and Beijing’s leadership quickly
invaded Guangdong, installing new leadership that would report directly to them.
One collapse followed another. The savings of the people was literally eaten
away by the demise of so many companies in the stock market and by so many enterprises
that had gone bankrupt. This led to mass layoffs with numerous people thrown out
of work. Historically, another negative result of this hanky panky was the fact
that liberal foreign loans were no longer rolled over automatically international
and China has suffered a black eye along with a lot of face by not taking control
of the matter early on. The Chinese Central Government became so mesmerized by
the commerce generated by that province and the income that went into the Government’s
coffers that they were unwilling to pull the plug. As a result of this dalliance
, China was no longer able to get credit at the drop of hat. Worse, when
money is made available, the price for loans to anyone with exception of the Central
Government is now sky-high. Unless China cleans up corruption throughout its provinces
on a timely basis, the collapse of Guangdong may be repeated elsewhere in China. Rampant fraud is now getting so out
of control that it literally has to be addressed. China, a country that has not
even been able to figure out how to collect taxes is now being pulverized by high-tech
tax cheats. Moreover, they have been getting away with in massive numbers. However,
on March 1, 2001, the Central Chinese Government sentenced seven people to death
in the province of Guangdong for tax fraud. This turned out to be easily by the
biggest case of corruption in the Communist era. The fraud was relatively simple
to pull off due to the fact that China has little or no controls in place. A former
prosecuting attorney and two high ranking tax officials along with four others
have been accused of using shell companies with no offices, employees or business
to issue fake tax receipts effectively collect rebates from the central government
for non-existent exports.
BANKING The
Chinese, traditionally a frugal people, on average manage to save almost forty
percent of their income. People in China tend to place their funds in local banks
that are either run by the provincial or national government, chiefly because
alternative investment opportunities are rare.
Chinese banks are run a lot
like politics in that under-educated and unqualified bureaucrats are appointed
to senior positions. These political appointees are often only aware that they
must insure that their patrons are well treated when they need loans. Because
political repayments make up a substantial percentage of all loans made in China,
some economists are now estimating that fully fifty percent of the loans that
are on the books are either non-performing or bad.
Although the IMF and World
Bank issued warning signs some time ago, two recent incidents caused Chinese authorities
to address the issue. Their delay in facing the facts may have caused a hole in
the banking system today of more than $400 billion. The people had been sanguine
as well because banks just did not fail in China; the Government would step in
and flood the failing institution with dollars until it regained monetary health.
Suddenly the band stopped playing that song.
Hainan is an island located
1,500 miles east of Beijing in the South China Sea. The State owned a bank there
that particularly catered to a wealthy land speculator who was very close to the
Hainan Bureaucracy. The bank began making loans to the speculator because of his
connections and because of the cash gifts that he bestowed on bank employees in
gratitude for the loans that they were kind enough to supply. Before much time
had passed, the land speculator slowed his repayments and ultimately stopped paying
altogether. When the damage was assessed, over $200 million had gone down the
tubes, a prodigious amount for Chinese banking. This, in turn, caused the
bank, which had a capital base of $3 billion, to fail. When the final tally was
made, twenty-eight credit unions, which the investor also used for credit lines,
went down the drain.
Officials of the bank (Haifa
Bank) have been charged with everything from soup to nuts, including but not limited
to, accepting bribes in order to make loans, paying customers illegally high interest
to deposit money, and falsifying all of the bank’s books and records. National
Banking Officials in an effort to assess the damage have written legal letters
to most if not all of the bank's credit customers, most of whom have not responded.
Depositors, as is the custom in China, were repaid by the successor bank, Industrial
and Commercial Bank of China, one of only four state-owned commercial banks.
The collapse of the Haifa
Bank happened almost simultaneously with the GITC fiasco in Guangdong. So many
companies have been allowed to just close there doors without state intervention
or assistance, that it is too early to access the totality of the catastrophe.
Only massive intervention by the national government will save the provincial
banking system from total failure.
The New York Times on February
18th, 1999 wrote the following; “The real estate glut in China is at
the heart of a banking mess perhaps more serious than anywhere else in the world.
Chinese banks have lent heavily to construct buildings that are now largely vacant
and worth little. Three of the four major banks are effectively insolvent by a
huge margin, even though these are boom times. So long as depositors keep their
money in the accounts, the banks can keep functioning indefinitely. But the moment
depositors start asking for their money back, the banking system in China will
face the possibility of collapse.”
“China’s bad bank debts are
staggeringly large, totaling about 40 percent of gross national product, compared
with 3 percent in the United States during the savings and loan crisis. Non-performing
loans are about 25 percent of the total at the big banks, significantly higher
than in other countries when they were hit by the crises.” The Times concluded
the article with a special concern about the multitudes of people that will lose
their jobs as companies that are unable to repay their creditors are shuttered.
It would take a miracle to save the economy.
Finally, China created a new
government agency formulated by the four major banks to take over bad loans from
closed institutions and repackage them for sale or write them off as the case
may be. This will be the first time that banking problems have been dealt with
at the national level in a realistic manner. Chinese economists have proposed
floating a bond offering to increase indigenous bank capital back to acceptable
levels while simultaneously addressing loans that should have been written off
long ago. All
of these proposals are admirable, but until China stops tying banking and politics
together with one ribbon, the problem will continue. Political cronies will
continue to minister to the needs of their friends under the guise of making sound
banking decisions. The price that China will ultimately have to pay for their
fiddling while the banking system burned will be extraordinarily high if the do
something soon. If they don’t, there may be nothing left to save. Taxing
TimesChina has a policy of supporting
local industry by offering substantial rebates on their 17 percent value-added
tax, which is normally levied on the production side in exchange for hard-dollar
exports. So far, tax officials in Beijing are already talking about the fact that
the fraud has already eclipsed the 50-billion Yuan ($6 billion) threshold and
is rising. A series of cases of export tax rebate fraud are under investigation
which may involve 50 billion Yuan, an official from the Shanghai Customs
Office told Reuters. For the most part, this particular scheme was unique in that
it addressed non-existent companies and goods, but it is common practice by Chinese
companies to receive their export credits and then resell their products into
the domestic market. This is quite a common practice,
you simply sort out the export papers and then sell the stuff on the domestic
market. Its money for nothing. () Interestingly enough, the Central
Government caught on to the fraud by a ninety-five percent increase in export
tax rebates. In Guangdong, the rebates soared
a startling one-hundred-eighty-five percent, a number so large that it
could no longer be ignored. Meanwhile, back at the ranch, national police chief,
Li Jizhou was placed on trial for acting on behalf of smugglers and taking bribes.
This was a case in Xiamen in which eighteen people have already been convicted
and are awaiting the execution of their death sentences. It seems as though the
sleeping giant is slowly waking up, at least as far as tax fraud is concerned.
China
supports the world’s biggest bureaucracy and their people earn every penny that
they are paid by having the largest number of forms per transaction ratio in the
world. It is a simple matter for these underpaid national employees to help people
through the paper morass for a fee because the government scarcely pays them a
living wage. One of the reasons that these people are so poorly compensated is
the fact that the Government of China has one of the poorest tax collection systems
in the history of man. In a country now turning out high tech products that are
the envy of the many of their competitors, tax collection at every level is both
arbitrary and manual. Tax assessments can be made to order by a countless horde
of underpaid government officials no one can be the wiser. At
the retail level, all sales are recorded manually if at all and no usable records
exist so that a national or even a regional sales tax can be enacted. Avoiding
taxation has become a national pastime and an example of what has happened in
just one industry will suffice. China has 18 million registered mobile phones
and another 5 million phones that have been smuggled into the country. The tax
revenue that is avoided by using those 5 million illegal cellular phones amounts
to over $600 million a year.
Hit or miss tax collections
along with high import duties have caused people to take the line of least resistance;
smuggling has joined tax evasion as an art form. Because of the fact that the
National Government does not take in much tax revenue per se, the provincial
governments are assessed and their collections are forwarded to the Central Government.
From there, the Government has to deal with paying the military, almost five times
as large as the second largest military in the world, the United States, they
have to pay their bureaucrats, a legion fully 50% larger than the throng that
regularly mucks up India’s economy with unending regulations and government invitations
to bribery.
We anxiously await the day
when China learns how to pare their massive government employment, which brings
corruption and ineptitude. They say they cannot afford better, at least now that
is. At the rate they are going, there may not be a later.
The
World Trade OrganizationThe Government of China is literally
allowing some of the corruption in the country to proliferate because of their
own exigencies. China's acceptance
as a member of the World Trade Organization has created a demand by other members
of that august body who want to know that everything China is doing in this arena
is squeaky clean in spite of the many outrages the members themselves may commit. However, this is not stopping what is literally
tacit approval by Chinas leaders for their denizens to promote the
copying of current western movies on videodisc.
The Chinese population has recently gotten caught up in the play-at-home
movie hysteria syndrome, according to the Government, but they cannot afford Western
prices to legitimately purchase the discs. Thus, large factories exist in China
whose sole purpose is to copy this intellectual property illegally.
We
should not underestimate the economic importance of these unlawful industries
to their host nations. China, even when facing loss of “Most Favored Nation
Status” from the United States, continued turning a blind eye to massive factories
generating immeasurable quantities of software, movies and music in direct contravention
of international law. Although much of the material that is used in China doesn’t
originate there, most of it comes from Macao, which has no intellectual property
laws, but has porous boundaries and bribable customs officials. Any effort to
stop sales of black market goods only seems to occur around the time that the
U. S. Congress reconsiders most favored nation status.
The Chinese
have an avid desire to view western movies, so first run American moves which
sell for about $2 a copy in China were particularly hard hit. No special effort
has been made to insure intellectual property rights in this field. It isn’t so
much that anyone is giving China a free hand at copying and distributing this
material, it is just that American enforcement in practically nil.
Because
these movies are easily available at modest prices and are openly sold at local
stores, they have spawned a massive industry in Video Compact Discs (VCD) which
are very similar to the American Digital Videodiscs (DVD). China is mass-producing
these VCD which are priced in the range at which almost all Chinese can afford
them. With current production in China at over 50 million of these little devils
a year and rising, the video industry will potentially have an enormous market
for its products when everyone wakes up to what is going on now.
We do not
mean to suggest that China is unique as a counterfeiter. Some of the most inveterate
counterfeiters on earth are domiciled in western-thinking Hong Kong and Macao.
Pirates in Pakistan will supply Windows XP, Microsoft Office, Word, Excel, PhotoShop,
Aldus Freehand, Corel Draw and others on demand. ().
Some of the most fragile emerging economies of Eastern Europe depend on similar
industries: “Recording industry officials estimate that 95% of Bulgaria’s CD production
is accounted for by illegal knock-offs being sold throughout Europe” ()
while Microsoft estimated that last year, Vietnam had a 99% software piracy rate.
As the Asian crisis continues to spiral out of control we would expect that the
sale of illegal software will become even worse. This may eventually mean that
no one pays for any of it.
CHINA AND
THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION
The membership
of the United Nations opposes counterfeiting and violation of intellectual property
laws. Most of the member countries are already signatories to documents
such as the Berne Convention, the WTO, ()
and the WIPO Copyright Treaty, which embodies this thinking. However, that
is not quite enough, The problem is that nations must be encouraged to enforce
these agreements, and usually when economics are involved, it always takes some
serious prodding. ()
One of the best examples of this would be China, who recently became a WTO member
in spite of holding contrarian views on just about everything the organization
stands for. Overlooking the intellectual property issues, which previously
pervaded the talks, China found topics to shift the direction of the negotiations
away from its continued violations.
China’s fundamental problem was that its negotiators said that they had a hard
time controlling the ministries that dot Beijing like fiefdoms, eager to protect
the industries they oversee, rather than open them up to competition. Concedes
Yu Xiaosong, a top trade negotiator at the State Economic and Trade Commission:
“There are different opinions in different levels of the government on WTO’”.
What China was saying is that they had literally no control over their own industrial
production. Instead of the WTO saying, "we will talk again when you can tell
us that this problem is solved", they caved in.
However,
most of China’s go-slow negotiating approach was deliberate. China, for example,
wants to protect its automobile industry for 15 years. The U. S. led Western countries
that blocked its membership favor protection for only half that time. Protectionism
is diametrically opposed to everything the World Trade Organization has stood
for and one of the prime examples of too much of it imploding in your face is
the way India has delayed implementing even the most rudimentary elements of leaning
in the other direction. Their economy is a shinning example of what happens when
you protect industries that the state can't afford any more. India had become
an economic democracy and a business socialism, two concepts that cannot co-exist.
China, by pulling the wool over the WTO's eyes on this matter is only prolonging
their archaic social state.
Beijing
also offered minimal concessions on trading rights – the ability to import and
sell products without using a Chinese middleman. Earlier this year, China announced
that foreign and Chinese companies would get equal trading rights three years
after it joined WTO. It turned out China meant that foreign companies could import
products into China, but not distribute them to customers. For that, government-run
trading companies would have to be hired. Once again, China, by demanding
this concession was not gaining anything but prolonging bureaucratic free lunch,
another habit that India can't seem to brake. China's entrenched bureaucracy is
world class and its layers have layers.
The State
Planning Commission is proposed price controls on drugs that would limit the amount
companies can charge to production costs plus a set profit. WTO rules allow price
controls as long as foreign and domestic companies are treated equally, but the
new Chinese regulations discriminate against foreign companies by excluding research
and development done outside of China. This effectively forces foreign drug companies
to accept reduced profits or charge more for their products.” () However,
on this count the jury is still out. In the pharmaceutical arena, it would
appear that everyone has their own rules no matter what the WTO has to say; thus
why shouldn't China be allowed to join that silly little party.
China believed
rightly that if they stood firm, some of the issues will be swept under the table
because of a global desire to bring China into the mainstream. In time, the benefits
of membership will outweigh China’s interest in protecting outlaw industries,
and conformity to neutral judgment would win the day. China was right
and won the day, however some of the biggest victories my in the future prove
to have been pyrrhic in nature.
Freedom of Speech and all That Jazz Chinas
Central Government has not shown a lot of tolerance for competing political parties
and a number of leaders of the China Democracy Party were sentenced to long prison
terms is for only the act of existing. Then we have the Alliance for Democratic
China whose leaders, Wang Yigzheng; only known crime was advocating political
reform to combat corruption. An Jun, the founder the nongovernmental organization
Corruption Watch, was sentenced to four years in prison on April 5, 2000 on charges
of inciting the overthrow over the government when it seems that he was only trying
to get the bureaucracy to accept the fact that bribe taking was siphoning to many
assets out of the Chinese system. Although the countrys fathers are well
aware that corruption is a serious problem in their country, they are just not
interested in hearing about it in newspapers, the Internet or in public forums.
China Finance Information Network
was shuttered shortly after it published a report on corruption. Moreover, on
September 19, 2000, a Hebei court sentenced Qi Yanchen, a founding member of the
Quasi-independent China Development Union, to a four-year prison term, in part
for posting parts of his book, The Collapse of China, on Internet. Huang
Qi, who ran a website out of the Sichuan province, was charged with subversion
after he poster letters criticizing the 1989 massacre. Officials in Sichuan accused
Jiang Shihua, a high school teacher ad Internet café manager, with subversion
for posting articles critical of communist authorities. In August, state security
police in Shandong province shut down New cultural Forum, a website set up by
pro-democracy activists. ()
Worst
yet, at least for the bureaucrats, were the series of articles on bribery and
graft published by Southern Weekend, easily the most aggressive newspaper in China
when it came to saying things like they are. However, longevity sometimes can
be short in China when you start to step on the wrong toes. Apparently, this is
exactly what the editors of Southern Weekend, Chang Ping and Qian Gang, the later
being a former senior colonel who was stripped of his rank when he took part in
the Tiananmen Square protest, did with some of the recent stories. They
were dismissed from the paper and no one seems to know what has happened to them. Loose
CannonsInterestingly
enough, all Chinese newspapers are owned by the government but as time has gone
on, the various editors in many cases have gotten rather aggressive in their reporting.
The editors of the Southern Weekend top them all. Southern Weekend is affiliated
with the Southern Daily which is the newspaper of the Guangdong province branch
of the Chinese Communist Party. However, the removal of the offending editors
was ordered by the State News and Publishing Bureau which is a Central Government
Agency and thus higher in the peeking order than the provincial government. Apparently
the article, which certainly touched a nerve told about the case of Azhang Jun
who was in charge of a group of vicious hooligans that dealt in robbery and murder.
The gang accounted for no less than 28 murders in a period of eight years and
the paper indicated that the cause of them according was Zhang's younger years,
which were apparently spent at a Chinese prison where he was terribly mistreated.
This is a big business with China
itself manufacturing 20-million VCD players annually. By the end of 1998, the last to figures were published, about
50 million homes owned these players, probably more than the number in use in
the Untied States at that time. Movies
on the street sell for a little as 80 cents according to the New York Times, while
the players can be had for around $70. Thus,
an American movie is often dead in the water before it even hits the Chinese theaters
due to the fact that it has literally been seen by everyone and even if it hasnt,
for around a buck, a family of eight can buy the show, a heck of lot cheaper than
going to the theater.
The normal time it takes these pirates
to crank up their copying apparatus is two days from the time an American Movie
premiers. That is pretty fast action when you consider that it takes almost that
long to fly the copy to the Mainland. Officials
say that they are doing their best to crack down on the illegal industry, but
in an business where the machinery can be readily repositioned and set up again
in less than three hours, what good would it do to close a plant.
An official of a legitimate Chinese movie maker that had their own films
ripped off said that trying to put a stop to the practice is just like drawing
water with a bamboo basket. In spite of the pervasiveness of
corruption, Chinas leaders are loath to make any drastic changes. Corruption is only punished when offending
officials make too much of a show of their newfound wealth.
Opulent homes and mistresses are historically unknown in rural China and
are sure tip-offs that improprieties have been committed.
In the meantime, the system continues to flourish.
The quality of leadership is ever more diluted by a downward spiral of
incompetence exacerbated by inexperienced people with bags of cash assuming high-ranking
municipal jobs for which they are totally unqualified.
Novice office holders seeking to maximize the yield on their investment
are constantly on the lookout for new ways to shake down their constituency.
How long before this system reaches the breaking point is anybodys
guess, but retribution is not far away. MoviesWhile
China's alter ego, India, has gone move made producing substantially more films
than any other country on earth and geometrically increasing their output, China
has literally no movie screens and none are being constructed. As we have indicated,
earlier, the Chinese people prefer to see their movies on VCD players and watch
illegally printed Western style movies from the convenience of their homes. However,
the Chinese Government would like to see that change and in order to increase
the number of movies shot in that country they have begun offered nominal fund
matching programs for production. However, this diminutive amount of money the
country is willing to contribute comes at a heavy price in state censorship. That
is not to say that movies not financed by the state are not being censored, censorship
has always been a way of life here and that does not seem ready to change very
soon. The government does not want Chinese life portrayed in anything but
the best light, however that does not conform with reality and serious movie producers
are desirous of making movies that have some resemblance to reality. Because of
the fact that reality is not always slightly, there is a constant battle between
filmmakers and government officials regarding what the ultimate product will look
like. Government censors
are against depicting gambling by Chinese citizens in movies in spite of the fact
that the people are among the biggest gamblers on earth. They are against the
showing of the small and sparsely furnished residences that the Chinese population
lives in and yet, that is the way the great majority of the population lives.
Furthermore, censors would like to have people playing everyday citizens dressed
to the nine's with clothes befitting Fifth Avenue sports on Easter Sunday which
is hardly the case. Censors would like to promote the "big lie" and
make China into something that it is not and the people have little interest in
seeing fairy tales. The biggest quirk of all seems to be the fact
that after the film has been duly tormented by full time censorship on the set
with bureaucrats getting in everyone's way and complaining about just about everything
that is going on; when the film is put in the can, the government usually will
not let it be released overseas. This indeed creates a strange conundrum. There
are almost no movie houses in China and there is no overwhelming rush to build
them, the Chinese made movies are so inferior that there is also no rush to turn
them into VCR's so that they can be played in the only way they can be viewed
within the country and they are not often allowed to be exported so that they
are never seen by the outside world. No
one has yet been able to discern exactly what the government here is thinking
about when on the one hand they promote Chinese indigenously made films by supplying
studios, film, money and expertise but on the other they put these films on the
shelf after they are made; never to be seen again. Most strangely, the best Chinese
movies are not produced officially and these "underground films" once
finished are quickly hustled out of the country to be shown in film festivals
all over the world. Such a movie was "Devils on the Doorstep" which
won the Grand Prix in Cannes but was never shown within China. However, legal
or otherwise, China makes movies the same way they make everything else; "cheaply".
To spend more than $100,000 on a movie here is considered wasteful and if the
film can then be safely spirited out of the country, it doesn't take long for
the principals to get their investments back. In
order to encourage the making of movies, Beijing has created studios throughout
the country where wanabee movie-makers can go to get the films finished and distributed.
However, this is what they are told, but in reality, when the film is finished
it is usually spirited into a warehouse where it will sit for eternity gathering
dust. You see, the bureaucrats in the movie industry are the same as the bureaucrats
in any other field, they are given an quota by the government and god-forbid they
don't make it. However, if the movies are ever locally screened there could
be parts of it that would offend Chinese leaders and the heads of the studios
are not willing to gamble on that. The heads of the official Chinese studios are
only obligated to see that a certain number of films are produced, but being shown
is quite another matter. And even if this was not a problem, the distribution
would cost substantial money and bring no return:
"Since theater ticket sales are dismal in China, especially
for domestic films, there is no prospect of making money here. The
only real opportunity for profit is distribution at a foreign film festival. But
films must obtain new permits each time they travel. Indeed, when Mr. Wang
(a local legit producer) decided he wanted to take "Go for Broke" to
the Rotterdam Film Festival in the Netherlands in late 2001 -- more than a year
after it had been approved for viewing in China -- he and his business partner,
an American named Corey Vietor, were forced to steal a print of their own movie
when the formal approval was slow in coming."
" Shortly before the festival, a Shanghai Film Studio representative had
accompanied the print here for the addition of English subtitles. Unbeknownst
to the representative, Mr. Wang replaced the nine reels of film that were in the
trunk of the studio man's car with nine reels of advertising, thus liberating
"Go for Broke." It has since traveled -- with approval -- to festivals
in Tokyo and Vancouver, B. C., as well." (Making a Movie in China the Hard
Way: Legally, Elisabeth Rosenthal, The New York Times, April 25, 2002. The
bottom line, China is no India when in comes to the making of movies and most
interestingly, the Chinese have no egos when it comes to the cliché, "made
in China" when it comes to films. Chinese produced product just doesn't do
it for these people that are looking for a semblance of reality and a close look
at how the rest of the world looks. Moreover, we see no change any time
in the near future. Mother
ChinaHaving set the stage, now let us
tell you about the real China. The
country is conservative and it is paternal, an almost paradoxical combination. The government plays the role of both
mother and father to the people, attempting to create the environment that they
think in the long run will most help Chinas overall manifest destiny.
Chinese leaders have substantial flexibility because of the fact that China
is not a democracy in any sense of the word, and when something is placed on the
drawing board that makes long-term sense, the leaders usually jump on it.
However, China, as opposed to its neighbors, has not taken advantage to
any great degree of its substantial economic resources because much of the industry
in the country operates both indigenously and autonomously. The
Government is making a concerted effort to pull things together and are starting
to issue plastic identification cards containing a microchip to the entire population.
These cards be able to give bureaucrats substantial
knowledge of what is really going on in the country. Interestingly enough, in
China, everyone already carries a card bearing an identification number, a photograph
and a picture of the holder. The new cards will carry far more information and
can be used to carry medical records, determine whether the holder is a taxpayer
or not, act as a medium for exchanging money and or borrowing and repaying it
(debit card) and a host of other highly sophisticated operations. This will bring
China's tax collection system into the 20th century and tie the provincial regulations
together. It will aid the enforcement of various laws and help eliminate
China's vast underground economy. The systems will require five-years before all
of the people in China will have the cards with college students being the first
to try them out. Talk about big brother!! The
world is a strange place and the things that happen are often not what they appear
at first blush. The Chinese and the Americans can not appear to be giving in to
each other and between the Chinese entry into the World Trade Organization, U.S.
spy planes taking long looks at what goes on in China and the Taiwanese always
never knowing what the Mainland is going to do next. And now and again they have
done really weird things. Lin Ti-chuan a Taiwanese legislator was slipped a Mickey
while visiting Mainland China, collapsed, wound up in a hospital where she was
pronounced dead. Some
say, a kidnapping gone wrong, others say that it was a message to Taiwan that
the Mainland is deadly serious about there intentions relative to what they consider
to be their own territory. The Mainland issued all the right regrets and apologized
profusely but the deed was committed on their territory and a message my well
have been sent. However, the United States has some trump cards that it
is holding and can play them with a degree of impunity. However, while China was
awaiting word on the WTO vote, which as we known know was in their favor, they
suddenly found some religion and started acting like well behaved world citizens.
Now that this is a done deal, we will await whether they continue the act. China
threatens to wreck havoc on Taiwan or to shot American spy planes out of the air,
at that time, they were calmly told that their admission to WTO hung in the balance,
now we have little to threaten them with. . However, the rules state that neither
can rain on the other's parade. A
Game Of ChickenThis
is best exemplified by the fact that China regularly announces war games just
off of the Taiwanese Coast and pretends that they are invading the country. No
one ever knows in advance whether they are serious or not but almost everyone
is well aware that this has been going on since the Communists took over China.
In the Pacific Rim, incidents like these are only meant to show the size of the
leaders male organs to the rest of the world and once they have exhibited their
private parts, they stick their military might back in their pants and go back
to business. The Wall Street Journal in a story by Charles Hutzler recently put
this high risk game into perspective.
"Beijing's decision to hold and publicize
the war games now shows how deeply domestic concerns are
driving Chinese politics. Internationally, the exercises appear ill-timed, coming
on the eve of the annual fractious debate in the U.S. Congress on whether to renew
China's low-tariff trading rights. But domestically, Chinese leaders can't be
seen as giving in to Washington. And the Bush administration has raised the stakes
in recent weeks, selling Taiwan a large array of weapons, vowing to defend the
island from Chinese attack and letting the Taiwan president visit the United States.
A coming political shuffle in China is also pushing political leaders to court
the military. Politicking among party bigwigs has already begun ahead of a shuffle
of posts late next year; taking a stronger stance against the U.S. is seen as
one of the best ways to win points with the military." Interestingly
enough and in spite of opinions to the contrary, China who has the largest standing
army on earth has neither a well trained or well equipped military. Their navy
is almost non-existent as a modern fighting machine and only China's ability to
deliver nuclear warheads sets them apart from being a third rate military force.
The country's leaders are well aware that a nuclear war is not a viable
alternative and China's military spending is somewhere in the neighborhood of
what Japan, a country that has constitutionally banned offensive weapons spends,
you can get some idea how under nourished the Chinese military really is. Their
military outgo absolutely pales when compared with that of the U.S. who outspends
the Chinese by at least seven to one. The Chinese are now becoming more acutely
aware that their modest nuclear arsenal may well be checkmated by America's plans
to cover the United States with a sophisticated missile shield which will destroy
whatever bargaining chips may still exist. For
whatever that is worth, a future American missile curtain has not stopped China
from flexing its muscles at least as it relates to Japan among others in the Pacific
Rim. Japan believes as do most other nations, that their territory begins 200
miles from their shores. China which never stops stirring the pot against their
age old enemy, Japan on no less than seventeen occasions last year alone,
Chinese ships toyed with Japans hallowed space. However, Japan has been supplying
China with hard cash in the form of soft loans and its people are beginning to
wonder, why on earth are they paying a tithe to a country that invades its territory
whenever the whim seems to strike. However, even should that problem be solved,
it would still leave the sore created by the unsolved problem of what the Japanese
call the Senkakus Islands and the Chinese call the Diaoyu Islands. Surprisingly
these are the same islands only with different names. While these islands are
of no particular value and are totally uninhabited, it gives bureaucrats in both
countries the opportunity to rant and rave about the other's transgressions and
cravings. Should either of these nations determine to homestead on these
East China Sea territories, the semi-friendly jostling could quickly escalate
into a much more serious situation. China
has never admitted or discussed the use of germ warfare but a Russian defector
has charged that high ranking Soviet officials were able to determine that a Chinese
experimental attempt to turn the hemorrhagic fever virus into a biological weapon
had backfired and caused an epidemic. What was particularly dangerous about this
accident was the fact that this disease causes profuse bleeding followed quickly
by a painful death. Of course the Chinese should have known better as they had
been used a guinea pigs by the Japanese during World War II who killed thousands
with the insidious biological attacks. This action caused China, a country
not big on signing treaties, to be signatory of the 1972 treaty barring
weapons of this sort. Controlling
the EnvironmentIn
the meantime, it is not only China's external enemies that they have to fear.
The country has evolved at breathtaking speed causing internal dislocations in
many areas. However, it all boils down to the fact that the people feel that they
are entitled to more freedom. Even at the very top of the Communist Party in China
they are beginning to admit serious problems with the masses relative to religious,
ethnic, political and economic differences of opinion with the government. People
in China are tired of massive corruption , official arrogance and bureaucratic
delays. This has shown itself in numerous ways but passivity seems to be on the
way out and the party brass is becoming extremely concerned. This is more than
a small religious minority demanding certain rights, this is a grass roots problem
which doesn't want to go away. The International edition of the New York Times
put the problem into perspective in an article by Erik Eckhom on June 3,
2001 relative to what is called "China Investigation Report 2000 - 2001."
"...The 308-page report cites growing
social and economic inequality and official corruption as over-arching sources
of discontent. The income gap is approaching the "alarm level," it says,
with disparities widening between city and countryside, between the fast-growing
east coast and the stagnant interior, and with urban populations. The report describes
corruption as "the main fuse exacerbating conflicts between officials and
the masses. Protests of all kinds have become more common as China changes from
a state-run economy - a risky course the leadership feels is necessary to China's
long-term growth - and as the public becomes more assertive about rights...The
report provides no estimate of the number of disturbances but its strong language
suggests that the scale of demonstrations and riots has been greater than revealed
by the official press or in reports abroad..."In recent years some areas
have, because of poor handling and multiple other reasons, experienced rising
numbers of group incidents and their scale has been expanding, frequently involving
over a thousand or even ten thousand people," it says." The
bottom line simply seems to be that the more the Chinese people get educated and
can inter-relate to Western ideas, the more unhappy they will become with continuingly
oppressive Central Government edicts. The recent Chinese admission into
the World Trade Organization is only going exacerbate this problem. Among the
numerous reasons for this will be the underlying problem that their recent WTO
membership potentially brings with it massive Chinese unemployment. It will
also directly bring the knowledge to the people on how the other half of the world
lives. They already have television and Internet and are not at all pleased
with what they are seeing. Far from being a homogeneous mass of mindless people
walking around in a daze, the Chinese are educated, industrious and historically
independent and are not going to sit still very long for a government that does
not have the people's interests predominant in the government's order of
importance. The disparity between rich and poor in this country, once not an issue
when communist philosophy was the guiding light, is now a sore that will not soon
close without substantive remedial action. INTERNET Internet
Travel For
the people living in China, these must be heady times. For the most part, it is
the foreign educated Chinese that are now bringing new industries to the country
that had previously not existed here before the rise of the Internet. for the
most part, China's industries were local in nature and whatever you needed had
to be available in the local town that you were in or you weren't going to get
it. Communication was difficult, transportation was poor and not allowed for the
people themselves and even if you could travel, you didn't know where to go for
what you wanted or even if it existed. If your province produced shoddy merchandise
at very high prices, that's what you were stuck with. With foreign educated students
returning to their motherland every day, China has become ever more worldly and
innovations like the "yellow pages" of the telephone book have come
into vogue. In China for the first time the people can indeed let their fingers
do the walking and yet this is something that we have taken for granted literally
ever since the telephone was invented. More
esoteric but just as necessary is travel. Because people were not allowed to do
it, no travel agencies or facilities of any kind had sprung up to assist
a traveler in making reservations. People could not even tell what hotels even
existed in each city and if they did, what there rates were and what there
facilities were being offered. When the government began allowing people to travel
they started out by packaging tours that began at a place certain and ended just
as singularly. You had to go for the specific number of days allocated and by
the transportation mode that the government had picked no matter how much money
you had or how inconvenient the schedule was. The rooms would be the same
and everyone would go on the same tours whether they wanted to or not. Internet
gave entrepreneurs the opportunity of changing that and today, hotels, means of
transportation, restaurants and shops have all made it to the net along with travel
agents that will take care of your itinerary for a price. The work in putting
this together must have been back braking, but so many of those things that we
take for granted in the West are only now becoming a way of life in China. How
can anyone live without yellow pages or travel agents. Maybe that is why China
has one of the best records on longevity in the world in spite of being a population
that is smoking itself to death. SlogansThis
is also a land of slogans. The people are able to judge the government's direction
from the signs that are plastered on the country's billboards and woe unto anyone
that misinterprets their meaning. These messages do not appear as if by magic
and they proliferate primarily for three critical reasons. The first is that for
many years banners bearing sayings were literally the only way in China to get
a message across. Ornate signs hung from tall buildings in critical parts of town
were read by everyone and their messages could not possibly be misconstrued. The
second is that commercial outdoor advertising was banned for many years by the
government and for that reason, the government still dominates the choice locations
which they had gloomed unto early on. The third reason is just as important
as its predecessors. The government decrees by law that advertisers must contribute
3% of all advertising space to their propaganda. China had a flying start at this
slogan oriented propaganda thing as it probably started with Mao who made up slogans
faster than a speeding bullet. He had a saying for just about everything that
could happen and that seems to have set the precedent for what has occurred since. During
World War II, both China and Japan waged a slogan conflict with each side trying
to outdo the other. The Japanese used the slogans to pacify, the Chinese to inspire
their people to fight back at their oppressors. However most students of
sloganeering say that the grandest age for this art form occurred during the Korean
War when all of the people in the country were urged to work harder and harder
for victory against the oppressors. After Mao died, Deng Xiaoping directed sloganeering
into another arena. Deng was much more interested in the country's economic growth
so that the slogans that appeared everywhere during his regime cajoled the people
to better themselves economically. The urge to produce more and better products
appeared everywhere during this period. As time passed, the use of slogans
became much more sophisticated and suggestions to act became much more subliminal
in nature. People were no longer being hit in the head when advised what to do.
Eventually we will probably see the Government of China hiring a Madison Avenue
Advertising firm in an effort to better get their message across. At that point
we can be assured that China will have arrived as a real economic partner
to the West. China
has overcome many problems in its attempt to build a better life for its people,.
however, a better life consists of many parts and the Government is attempting
to address everything at once. If any part of the chain collapses, the entire
system will fall apart and that is something that can not be allowed to happen
according to the heads of the government. China has built massive amounts of new
housing, created new and wonderful ways of stimulating agricultural production,
addressed its infrastructure and has become the world most powerful exporting
nation. It has occupied Hong Kong and added their hard currency reserves to its
own and has become a world political and economic power in the space of less than
a decade. A prodigious feat. China
is flexing its new found muscle in many directions but if it cannot find the necessary
energy reserves, all else will fail. The people have become mobile and they have
learned of the better things in life. New industry in China is becoming more thirsty
for energy. These luxuries require boundless amounts of fuel that presently do
not exist in China. China's own internal estimates show that they will have an
oil shortfall within this decade of over 3 million barrels a day and many economist
feel that this number is extremely low. In order to supply enough natural gas
during the same period of time, China will have increase their proven reserves
by 400 percent, a virtual impossibility. Neither of these is an easy task, especially
when you consider that the only way that this is going to happen is for China
to find reserves in its southwestern most region, which borders an area occupied
by neighbors, Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan. This
part of the world is in a state of upheaval with religious fundamentalists causing
substantial commotion. The Taliban's brand of radical fundamentalism has been
exported to these nations and because of this has gotten the entire region off
balance. Moreover, because this fact, an association has been formed by a group
called the "Shanghai Five". It is actually made up of six countries
which include Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Russia, China and Uzbekistan,
the last to be admitted. This group is in theory is supposed to work together
to solve political and economic problems that are pervasive in the region. It
appears though that they have formed some sort of group that is only looking to
defang the Afghanistan religious fanatics before they infect any of the smaller
countries in the region and cut off oil and gas supplies. There is little question
that Russia is already looking for an excuse to put the Taliban out of its misery
but would like to have some company when it attacks. Mr. Putin is not going to
put up with these folks for very long with or without assistance. Should
the influence of the Taliban continue to expand, China would then be forced to
take matters into its own hands as well to insure a guaranteed supply of energy.
They are much more dependent on outside energy needs than the Russians.
There is little question that any and all of China's neighbors could well become
diner for either of these large countries if they are taken over by fanatics and
start to play hardball. China has already started building a pipeline to carry
fuel from this region to Shanghai, which if things go according to plan should
be completed within the next several years. Now they have to hit oil. It seems
to me that if I was a member of the Shanghai Five, I would be having someone check
to see that armaments were left at the door. Oiling
The Machinery Life
is riddled with anomalies. More often than not yesterday's friends are today's
enemies and vice versa. One of the biggest hates on earth was contained in the
messages that China sent Indonesia after the fall of their Suharto headed government.
During that period, riots were regularly conducted against the wealthy indigenous
Chinese population which had achieved living standards far beyond that of the
natives. The jealousy that had built for a long time, was allowed to take a more
physical form and many Chinese were driven from the country. Many left in such
a hurry that they left their possessions behind them. Moreover, the Taliban or
their counterpart Muslim terrorists had made substantial inroads into the Indonesian
way of life and training camps were constructed for these mass murderers within
that country. Worse yet, these camps were being constructed with the tacit approval
by the Indonesia government officials. China was already fighting a war with these
folks in their southwestern provinces and already had their hands full. Along
with this occurrence, foreign investors had already run for shelter and the funds
that in previous decades made Indonesia a monolith in the region, dribbled to
an abrupt stop. Indonesia had suddenly. at least from an economic point of view
had indeed become a pariah state and no one had much interest in what went on
in this, the largest Moslem country in the world. However,
in spite of the fact that the country had become almost an anarchy while one inept
government after another had shown no ability to lead the people; there
was little question that Indonesia had been well endowed with natural resources.
Among the products that this country had in abundance was oil and China seeing
the fact that by acquiring investments in Indonesia could insure a steady source
of supplies from a nearby country no matter what happened in the rest of the world.
China had been estimating that because of a dearth of new supplies being found
on its mainland that they would need to import 100 million tons of oil per year
by 2005. This was forcing a readjustment of their entire economic plan and they
had been unable up until this point to pin down a reliable source. Government
officials assigned PetroChina and CNOOC, the two largest Chinese oil companies,
the task of locking up this supply. Moreover, they were the ideal candidates because
they both had recently raised substantial funds through the use of stock offerings
of their public stock. Given
free reign to purchase whatever was necessary, in April of 2002, PetroChina Company
bought Devon Energy Corporation and CNOOC Ltd bought Repsol-YPF SA's properties
in Indonesia. The fact that foreign owners were all too happy to get out of the
Indonesian morass did not stop these Chinese companies for a second. In one fell
swoop, CNOOC became Indonesia's largest offshore oil producer and when combined
with the purchase by PetroChina, the two when combined now accounted for 12% of
Indonesia's total oil production of 1.4 million barrels a day. Interestingly enough
these acquisitions came on the heals of ExxonMobil's forced, halt in operations
in Aceh Province because of a rebellion there and a dangerous situation rearing
up in Sumatra where the population has been demonstrating against Chevron Texaco
there. Probably what brought about this sudden thawing of Chinese - Indonesian
relations was the visit that President Megawati Sukarnoputri paid to Beijing during
which time she told them that not only would Indonesia not object to these acquisitions
but that they would welcome them, an abrupt about face from what had been the
facts of life between the Chinese and Indonesians. Moreover,
because oil companies from the western nations were concerned about the political
events taking place in Indonesia, oil production had been diminishing since 1998.
In addition, new exploration had come to a grinding halt with oil companies wanting
to take their cash out of the country rather than explore for new fields with
their cash flow. Having found what they believe to be right partner, there is
little question that Indonesia will also tempt China further with promises of
gas from the Tangguh field in eastern Papua, one of the world's largest non-producing
fields. The problem in developing the field had been that there was literally
no market for the production unless a major client could found to purchase the
output. There is little question now that CNOOC will be given a substantial interest
in the field in exchange for their promise to develop the field and purchase the
output. This is not a stretch because China is developing one of the largest LNG
terminals in the world at Guangdong and has yet to contract for feed stock. It
is only a few years ago that these folks were fighting like cats and dogs. Interestingly
enough, new economics seem to create better neighbors and both countries had developed
a real need for each other in an economic sense. However, China could well have
problems in the future with their large investments here as the country from a
political point of view remains dramatically off kilter and could come apart
at the seams at almost any given moment. The masses here are not great fans of
the Chinese and if the country turns into an anarchy, the Chinese investors will
be sent packing in a skinny minute. China doesnt build small projects. Since they rejoined the
civilized world after centuries of hibernation, the Chinese have been playing
infrastructure catch-up with a vengeance, creating legendary construction products
that have regularly used over half of the worlds annual cement production.
The dam at Three Gorges, the countrys road construction
and the rejuvenation of cities like Shanghai, where 3,000 skyscrapers were erected
in just a few years are the things that set Chinas evolution apart. When
China hosts the 2008 Olympics, it will show us how it is done all over again.
It is interesting to note that they won the nod at the time of their 80th
anniversary of the founding of the Chinese Communist Party. While their only real
competitor in the colossal construction game, Japan, plans and carries out massive
construction projects just to keep people busy and on the payroll, Chinas
projects are of the much needed infrastructure variety, and each one is a more
dramatic addition to the landscape than the last. By contrast, disasters such
as Japans bullet train have put that Government so far behind the eight-ball
that it may never get out of debt.
Multi-billion dollar price tag projects have become de rigueur
all over the world, with airports,
railroads and dams leading the way in terms of massive expenditures. However,
the worlds economies are entering an era in which the inexpensive movement
of energy is becoming critically important; any project that can facilitate this
aim is sure to get priority. The United States Alaskan pipeline,
which linked oil fields to warm water harbors from which it could be transshipped
to the lower forty-eight states has been dubbed one of the great wonders of the
world. However, there are projects on the drawing board all over the planet that
will dwarf that effort. One of them is the pipeline that will stretch across Turkey
and into Europe to supply oil to that continent. Another such project is the West-East
pipeline that is being built in China, which is currently estimated to cost a
tad over $20 billion, a prodigious price tag, even for infrastructure development.
EnergyChina, one of the largest countries on the planet, has a unique problem.
Almost all of its energy production and reserves, coal, oil and natural gas are
produced in the far West, while all of the countrys major population concentrations
are in the East. In addition, China is not exactly an easy country to cross. Its
geographical divisions are some of the most treacherous on earth.
High, jagged mountains, steep gorges and wild rivers abounding in the area
in which the pipeline will be laid. The project belongs to PetroChina,
a quasi-corporate unit of China National Petroleum, publicly traded in Hong Kong.
PetroChina actually makes money, and wields a lot of clout because of its
dual public/private role. This duality will help PetroChina put a lot on the table to attract
assistance Western energy companies as joint venture partners. As a government
agency PetroChina has unquestionable authority to make a binding agreement. As
a public company, no one can question its profit making motives. Among those in
hot pursuit of a deal are Exxon Mobil, BP PLC
and Royal Dutch, each of which could provide substantial and much needed
expertise to this play to pay venture. The pipeline originates in the Tarim oil
and gas region, where a great abundance of natural gas has already been discovered.
However, many believe that the discoveries to date represent only the tip of the
iceberg in one of the greatest energy finds outside of the Middle East.
China has traditionally rejected any business terms that compromised
national integrity, including foreign corporate partnerships, concessions
or sharing natural resources. In this case, though, China has a desperate need
for rapid production of internally produced energy. The country has immense coal
reserves but they are primarily of the high sulfur variety, which is no longer
in vogue. Oil or natural gas are acceptable alternatives, but any substantive
reserves are located in the far West. The distance from Tarim in the Xinjiang
Province to Shanghai is 2,500 miles across no less than 40 rivers.
Currently, natural gas supplied only 2% of Chinas energy, a
figure which the Central Government has targeted to grow to 10% in the next several
years, an incredibly difficult task. However, in China, the incredibly difficult
can often be accomplished in a few short years. Foreign assistance is highly desired,
not because of the money that those companies can throw at the project, but because
foreign logistical and technical assistance can accelerate the projects
completion date.
Politically, though, there is more to this project than meets the
eye. Western China has been shortchanged by Chinas infrastructure investment
strategy, and it is payback time. Competing ethnic groups and religious fundamentalists
are fomenting unrest. China needs a fire extinguisher in the form of a substantially
higher standard of living. This priority far overshadows the
countrys desire to slow its loss of foreign exchange spent on imported oil
and speed the conversion from high sulphur coal to cleaner natural gas.
But
all that glistens isnt gold; international geologists have some serious
questions about exactly how much natural gas is really located in the Tarim Basin.
While foreign oil consortia are more than interested in putting their toes into
to the water to test the temperature, PetroChina is offering only expensive concessions
in the more questionable seismic areas.
Thus, foreign companies are standing in lines to buy tickets in the bleachers
and they may be so far from the playing field that no one can see the game. However,
this is standard operating procedure for negotiations in China. Offer foreigners
nothing to begin with, and when they are given a scrap, they will appreciate it.
Another
and possibly more serious problem from an economic point of view is the fact that
gas from the East China Sea is quickly coming on line and Shanghai is going to
be getting electricity from the highly lauded Three Gorges Dam. Everything in
the energy field seems destined to wind up in Shanghai, which will have an embarrassment
of riches. Moreover, China National Petroleum Corporation has projected energy
needs that are unjustified by current industrial growth rates. With a world recession
on the horizon, this project may be one of the great over-reaches of all time.
However,
in spite of the possibility of a multitude of substantial energy resources coming
on line simultaneously, that is not preventing China from reaching out in whatever
direction they deem necessary to add to their growing cache of reserves. Chinas
newly enlightened leadership is reaching out in many directions and in a host
of industries to force the countrys continued high level of growth. Moreover,
this leadership strongly believes that energy represents power, which you can
never had enough of and if nothing else and they are convinced that those who
control power will be in the global catbird seat. Taiwan
RelationsThe
Mainlands state owned, China National Offshore Oil is the primary company
responsible for exploring property claimed by the government that is not located
within its physical borders and the company is the third largest energy producing
entity in the country. They have found a relatively unexpected collaborator in
Chinese Petroleum, a Taiwan Company based in Taipei. The two countrys have
set up a test-drilling joint venture that could possible tap into some of the
largest oil and gas reserves in the world. In addition, in spite of what is commonly
believed, the companies have been working together for some time in the area that
separates them, the Taiwan Strait and have just put the final touches to an agreement
by the two for joint drilling of some of the choicest locations.
The
two have gone so far as to create a jointly owned company that will be based on
neutral territory somewhere within the general region. However, this is not the
first time the two countries have reached agreement on a joint venture to harvest
the would be riches of this very choice location. The original agreement between
the two was signed as far back as 1996 and ratified by both countries in 1998.
Things were moving along swimmingly until the following year when the Mainland
determined that Taiwan was not moving fast enough in the direction of becoming
a Chinese appendage and all of the understandings were put on the shelf. The negative
rhetoric has died down somewhat and the Mainland view on its relationship with
Taiwan has changed somewhat. China
knows that there are big bucks and a lot of good technology available in Taiwan
that can be utilized on the Mainland. The more aggressive nature of the government
towards a lot of things is gradually rubbing off as it looks like Taiwan will
soon enter that arena more directly. After all, if the Mainland can let the once
hated entrepreneurs into the Communist party, an oxymoron if there ever was one,
they can certainly manage to deal with their own relatives living only an island
away. The Central Government want to tap those resources now and no longer believes
as strongly that dealing with Taiwan will impede their long term goal of reunification.
In
addition, China Eastern Airlines which is the third-largest carrier in China has
concluded a deal to sell 25 percent of its cargo carrying subsidiary to China
Airlines, the largest airline in Taiwan. However, the fact that the two companies
have inked the contract still does not guarantee that the deal will go through.
Moreover, this transaction is more Pomp than Circumstance
because of the fact that, at the moment you cant get there from here. In
other words, Mainland China does not allow direct flights from Taiwan. If anything,
however it is Taiwan that has been the reluctant bride and is somewhat reluctant
to conclude this and other transactions. They have been following a policy of
no haste, be patient: relative to the Mainland which was instigated by Taiwans
President, Chen Shui-bian. This
transaction might send a signal that the Taiwanese Government is having second
thoughts about the careful approach which has produced no discernable results.
However, if this transaction goes through, the Taiwanese side will have little
to say about management and the company will remain in the control of present
officers and directors. As a matter of fact the seems little downside for the
Mainland Chinese because they are giving up next to nothing in exchange for a
substantial injection of money. For their part, the Taiwanese, get to give China
a lot of money and hopefully get some goodwill in exchange, however, we doubt
that. Moreover,
these is not the only deal being actively pursued by the countries and while the
pace of negotiation is often painfully slow, there is no question that there is
substantial inertia present to get something done between the two logical partners. The only problem with the deal which
is still being refined is the fact that the Mainland does not allow direct transportation
of anything directly between the two countries so that the logistics of transporting
whatever materials that are needed by
joint venture and whatever recoveries that are made is still being worked out. There is no longer any question though
that unless some unforeseen political disaster strikes, the issues will be solved
and watch for deals to be made in numerous industries as the two countries move
ever closer together in spite of the delays caused by
the inevitable bickering. Yale
University China
has made some stranger bedfellows in the past than Taiwan. It has a relationship
with Americas Yale University that has remained passionate for a century
and a half which seems to be picking up even more steam. More foreign students
from China make up Yales student body than from any other country; over
three-hundred which for a school of its size is a prodigious number. The liaison
has almost taken on the luster of diplomatic relations between two countries.
Now, when high ranking Yale administrators visit Beijing they are occasionally
invited to receptions at the Great Hall of the People, an honor usually reserved
for foreign state officials. However, whatever honors that have been bestowed
upon the American University seem to be richly deserved. Yale has hung in there
through thick and thin at no perceptible gain to them. Their theory has been that
China is the populated country in the world and it is critical that someone is
their keeping the door open. A
substantive piece of the more liberal new criminal laws that China put into place
recently were innovated at Yale in workshops with high ranking constitutional
architects from that country. In addition, the University has started a Chinese
Law Center for educators and politicians in hopes of creating a more level legal
playing field in the country. Lawyers and regulators along with educators from
Yale are working with members the American Securities and Exchange Commission
and their Chinese alter egos in an effort to create better laws, more flexible
trading practices and increased transparency within the Chinese stock market system.
When someone in China is told to buy a stock, there is literally nowhere that
they can find legitimate information on the company and for this reason, many
people have gotten severely burned. Behind
the scenes training of medical professionals in the area of AIDS education has
been going on at Yale long before China admitted that their country even hosted
that disease. Great strides have been admittedly
made in China in the areas of prenatal AIDS care and work has been done in the
area of preventing transmission of the disease between mothers and their children.
Yale has also developed programs in many other medical areas in which the Chinese
appear to be deficient while associates of the University that set their roots
down in China at the turn of the 20th century, built a teaching hospital
in the province of Hunan long before this sort of thing became fashionable.
The
relationship between the two strange bedfellows began primarily as method for
some of the more overzealous graduates of Yale to bring Christianity to China
substantially before the turn of the century. Most early expatriates were Yale
educated missionaries seemingly with a zeal to impart the wisdom of Western religious
beliefs on a country that was then relatively naïve and backward. For some strange
reason, this didnt seem to overly offend their sensibilities and when it
came time for high-born Chinese Children to attend college, Yale became the school
of choice and so it has gone for decades. If anything, Yale is now attempting
to ramp up its relationship with the Mainland to the degree that their president
talked about how important the country now is at the Universitys commencement
with other department heads singing a chorus based on the same tune. More importantly,
the relationship seems to continue unabated without the ebbs and flows that sometimes
effect countries because of extraneous outside political problems. In all of these
years, no teachers have ever been recalled by either country when their governments
were feuding or when the United States refused to back a Communist Government
in that country. Education seems to transcend politics as well it should and this
seems to be as good a place as any for nations to meet on neutral territory, that
of the university campus where agendas dont have the same anxieties attached
to them.
Infrastructure While
China always seems to be able to put together the manpower and the technical skill
necessary to build infrastructure, it is not
always as successful with industrial projects. As we have pointed out,
China is in the process of completing a national highway system that goes far
beyond its immediate needs. When the project is completed it will encompass a
series of highways crossing the length and breadth of the country while connecting
every major city, and even now the few vehicles on the roads cannot fully utilize
the highways that have been built. China keeps its truck and car import tariffs
high, hoping to fill the roads with home-built wheels. This
is truly the only country on earth where the manufacturing of cars and trucks
is a cottage industry. The first totally indigenous Chinese
car was produced in the early 50s and since that time scores of companies have
gone into that business. There are
some production facilities that crank out less than two-thousand vehicles a year,
a number that would be considered hopelessly uneconomically elsewhere, even with
reference to ultra-expensive limited edition models produced only for high-end
customers. In most other countries differing types of automobiles are produced
on the same production lines, producing substantial economies of scale. This is
hardly the case in China, which has allowed numerous mom and pop automobile manufacturers
to stay in business over the years whether they were turning a profit or not.
This was due to the fact that each small manufacturer had a local monopoly relative
to its own regional highway system. They various automotive companies
literally could not compete with each other because the products produced couldnt
be delivered to remote locations. In
addition, the Chinese manufacturers were turning out vehicles that were designed
for particular local conditions. Cars that operated smoothly in mountainous territory
using low gear ratios were grossly uneconomical in flatter terrain. Many of the
automobiles that were produced in the countryside had to double as delivery vans.
Of the 100 auto manufacturers in China, most are hopelessly unprofitable and have
been so literally from the day they opened for business. In spite of that, each
province wanted the prestige of having at least one manufacturer, no matter how
unprofitable under their aegis just for bragging rights, hardly a survival of
the fittest strategy. For years, Chinas economic central planners could
do whatever they pleased no matter what the cost if it helped keep the people
employed. However, the people that now make decisions in Beijing have now discovered
that this type of provincial arrangement is dissipates valuable resources and
from a purely economic point of view, atrociously extravagant. In
the early nineteen hundreds there were probably as many as thirty automobile manufacturers
in the United States turning out an odd assortment of vehicles that they thought
would sell. No one had yet learned the right formula and these vehicles were produced
one at a time in every conceivable shape and size. Since no one had as yet sorted
out what the peoples ultimate tastes would be, small manufacturers tried to jam
product down the throats of their consumers. Cars, to some degree evolved with
technology and new fangled devices such as air conditioning, radios and rear view
mirrors arrived with great fanfare along with leather adjustable seats, road following
headlights, climate controlled interiors, global positioning systems and the rest.
What
made the United States somewhat unique at that time was the fact that it already
had an existing middle class that could afford these new fangled contraptions
and a highway system that although puerile could at least accommodate Sunday drivers
out for joyride. Under the American system it was not critically important that
too many competitors had entered the game because the existing
competitive system would soon narrow the participants when it was found
that not everyone could turn a profit. When World War II ended there were only
about five manufacturers of importance remaining. A few more entered temporarily
after the war ended thinking that they could use the production techniques discovered
in war production to successfully compete. Some of these entrants produced mechanically
excellent cars but for whatever reason, they failed and soon either closed up
shop or merged with the larger companies. As time passed, even the larger companies
began consolidating and when the smoke had cleared there were only three totally
indigenous American auto manufactures left standing. As time went by there was
additional consolidation within these manufacturers as various models were discontinued. The
same events occurred overseas as many of the smaller companies were taken over
by the larger ones. As cars became technically more and more complex, it became
increasingly difficult to devise or afford spiffy new models every year. Dies
had to be drastically changed at great expense and new models had to be carefully
road tested for deficiencies. By this time, the American consumer had become litigious
and woe upon an automobile manufacturer that used tires that would blow out, engines
that would overheat or cars that would burn too much fuel. However, advances within
these fields allowed the innovator substantial competitive advantages and the
automobile companies learned how to make advertising pay big dividends. Agencies
were soon writing scripts to be used in the media that went something like this,
the fastest this, the most luxuriest that and the smoothest this. In the midst
of all this primping came new problems facing manufactures, government recalls,
warranty competition, (who could write the longest warranty) and lower and lower
lead requirements in gasoline to make it less polluting. Environmental rules were
made stricter literally with every model and this became a business of the super-big
and one not at all for the faint of heart. China
being new to the mass produced auto game, early on was not experienced with these
nuances. Their industry was protected by tariffs and even if it hadnt been,
it wouldnt have mattered because there werent enough people in China
that had money to make the country interesting for the majors car manufacturers. As China changed, their economic order of importance became
dramatically different and today China represents the most appealing market in
the world, but it is also a country that protects its own. It could not find a
way to protect much of the automobile industry though because the manufacturing
throughout the country was universally archaic, luxuries were few and innovation
was rare. The people of China as they became wealthier desired something more
than a car that had only a motor and four wheels. Thus, China made the determination
to revamp the entire industry to make it both universally appealing and globally
competitive. China
is well aware of the fact that by concentrating their production they have the
ability to manufacture with economies of scale that can literally bury anyone
else provided that they deliver a product that has panache. They further see that
this industry which is currently held together by bailing wire could become a
big producer of foreign exchange if it is pasted back together properly. Moreover,
with Chinas entry into WTO, they are no longer going to be able to protect
local manufacturers who will soon be forced to become profitable or perish. Rather
than wait for the inevitable to take place, the Chinese Government recently determined
to "fix" the industry now from the top down. Small manufacturers were
either ordered closed or forcibly merged with larger companies, The
large companies and there were only three, First Automobile Industry Corporation,
Shanghai Automotive Industry Corporation and Dongfeng Automotive Group when the
smoke has cleared will probably be all that is left of the industry, those left
standing will receive government credits to revamp production lines, fold in smaller
manufacturers and to offer credit to car buyers in throughout the country. The
decision making process which had been held in the hands of the central government
will be transferred to the manufacturers who will now have the responsibility
of taking the temperature of their consumers on a regular basis. What models do
they want, what accoutrements should be included and how many cars should be made
are all decisions that the manufacturers will soon have to deal with. Most importantly,
once set adrift they will have to turn a profit or perish. The rewards for failure
in China can often be harsh. An
interesting facet of the industry downsizing now occurring in China is the fact
that alliances were created early on between the major manufacturers abroad and
the local Chinese car makers. Some of the multi-nationals misjudged the survivors
and guessed fatally wrong when it came to picking a partner. The team at General
Motors batted 100% while those at Ford totally struck out. This will make the
coming end game more interesting to watch as Ford tries to re-enter the competition
with literally no way to do it. So
that is the way things seem to stack up as it relates to the Chinese automotive
industry but many economists have spent considerable time trying to figure out
exactly what World Trade Organization membership is really meant to China relative
to its overall production capabilities. An industry that is illustrative of what
could as this saga unfurls is that of the manufacture of textiles. This is hardly
a new industry to China as large factories have been de rigueur in this
country for decades. However, it is interesting to note that after a slow start,
the quality of Chinese production has become first class in the last several years
so that there seems to be no real issue relative to whether or not they are going
to be able to compete on a global level. The next doubt that seems to require
addressing is the issue as to whether the Chinese are conscious enough of changing
fashions and are capable of fine tuning their production to meet this waxing and
waning cycle of ever changing fickle demand. Surprisingly, the answer to this
question is also yes; the Chinese textile manufacturers have stationed representatives
all over the world and are both conscious of change and have recently developed
the capabilities of turning around their production on a dime. Incidentally
coming that far they are even beginning to start flexing their muscles in the
direction of dictating and originating new styles and they have had modest success.
Moreover, many of the Chinese textile manufacturers have gone public in Hong Kong
and are now sitting on big bucks giving them the latitude of improving production
techniques and overall quality control while being able to simultaneously prune
their workforce. This allows them the ability to purchase the preeminent machinery
in the world to make their factories run efficiently.
Provincial Government Throughout
the earlier years, the central government was in charge of things like the military
and international relations but as time went on, it was becoming more apparent
that the country had literally become a diverse group of provincial governments
all marginalized and pulling apart in their own way from Beijing. The provinces
were different from the capital and under the formerly planned economy were order
what to manufacture and plant. Having the freedom do plant and manufacture would
soon result in distortions to the system that potentially would be fatal. Without
bringing everyone back into line with central planning, the people would soon
become once again economically deprived and the food shortages which had finally
been successfully addressed would once again show their ugly features. Communism
was in China in reality was now only history, but a strong central government
was critical to economic advancement. Essentially though the states planners
saw that the problem was that in moving to quickly in the direction of free trade,
democracy and all of the other supposed good things in life could through entire
procession permanently off track. It was a calculated risk taken in the Forbidden
City to have the Central Government take a strong hand in matters, reassert their
control over the provinces, eliminate duplicate sources of production and abolish
high cost producers that needlessly only continued to drain state funds. Another
reason for continuing a rule with an iron fist was the fact that all is not well
in China and there are many groups that given only a tad more latitude would have
their leaders for lunch. The farmers, the workers, the migrants, the women, and
the older people have been overlooked as the society has either progressed or
regressed depending on what color glasses you are looking through and who is doing
the looking. Most
extraordinarily of all, China as well as Russia looked toward the Government of
General Augusto Pinochet in Chile when attempting to relate to a formula of government
that would accentuate the perceived needs of their country and maximize its potential
growth without activist groups getting into the act and causing trouble. It was
determined that it was necessary for the central government to be run with a strong
hand, to be totally dictatorial in nature while gradually freeing industry to
become competitive, one link at a time. Chiles rule of no unions and no
elections was masterfully geared to induce multi-national investment in the country.
It worked like a charm and probably if Pinochet had eliminated a few less of his
competitors and had used firing squads instead of torture as his means of that
eradication and had not gotten to old to manage the countrys affairs, Chile
would still be steaming along in fine style. However, all of those things did
go wrong but the formula was set in stone and China believed that they had the
opportunity of looking backward at the mistakes that were done there in order
to do it better. However
this process in itself caused the already ingrained bureaucratic corruption in
China to grow like Topsy as even greater opportunities to milk the system appeared.
The fact that local government no longer had the same rigid governmental quotas
to fulfill that they had in the past allowed them the luxury of dismissing employees
summarily, looting the companys remaining assets and inventory; selling
these off for a pretty penny and then summarily dumping the skeleton of what was
left to an industrialist that was willing to pay a now substantially lowered price.
The price at this point had become unimportant because the proceeds would go to
the government. What
had occurred is a transference of money from the state to the bureaucracy in one
easy step. In addition, the price of privatization had been reduced by the fact
that the private sector was no longer bidding on all of the things that had already
been unloaded. This allowed for more bidders to get into the act and appeared
to outsiders as a healthy contest between the buyers in a legitimate auction.
Whereas the auction probably was legit, thats about the only thing in the
process that was. As a matter of fact, the state could even offer financing for
the privatization with the money they received in the sale of the asset. In addition
as opposed to having a drain on their books which would never pay taxes, they
now had a productive asset which could pay them dividends over scores of years.
Everyone seemed happy about the transaction, the central government had gotten
rid of a none producing asset, the purchasers received a ready made building and
a franchise and the seller, the state received what money remained after the lead
bureaucrats carved up the gravy. Whoever, there are a lot of people that get thrown
out of work in this process, but that is just a result of coming to gripes with
21st century and progress. And
indeed, a middle class has arisen out of the chaos and there are now indigenous
people that can afford some of the better things in life. However, that seems
about as far as the Central Government is prepared to go at the moment. Business
continues on as usual when the state has to deal with potential dissenters. However
one of the immediate benefits of their new economy is that it is no longer necessary
to jail singular radicals who are preaching religion, democracy or an end to the
death penalty. With the exception of the Fallon Gung, in the new China
it is only necessary to remove the pulpit out from under where one is preaching,
the incarceration of the preacher is no longer necessary. Fundamentally individual
dissenters are isolated rather than jailed in this new regime. However, whenever
there is an opportunity for unified action by any faction the government is programmed
to take strong remedial action. Chile did not succeed with groups of agitators
running around complaining about their lot in life. Unions, Political Parties,
student unions and new fangled religions will set off time bombs in the government
and are rapidly defused one way or the other. In
China, the Central Government evaluated literally all of the plants that were
in the business of turning out textiles and made a determination similar to their
study of the automobile industry as to which of these could be profitable and
which couldnt. Those that couldnt make the cut, and there were a lot,
were ordered shut with ample compensation order to be paid to the provisional
authorities when they turned over the melted down spindles (they werent
taking any chances on paying for a plant to be closed and black-market goods continued
to be produced) to the Central Government to insure compliance. This stipend tended
to diminish the hysteria of closing factories, dealing with the newly unemployed
and losing tax revenue, something that had never been accomplished in China since
the Communists had taken over. Most of those producers that were left were soon
privatized and the top workers from the closed factories were invited to work
in the new company. This kept the most modern and well run facilities churning
out product through the use of the crème of the manpower available in China for
that job. Moreover,
in spite of this plethora of labor, China is no long relying solely on this factor
in their quest to turn out quality goods at a minimal cost. China is now utilizing
sophisticated software programs in their textile production. These high-tech programs
are able to eliminate a great number of employees. There are some interesting
statistics available to graphically illustrate this fact: in the four years from
1995 to 1999, the number of people employed in that industry has plummeted from
6.7 million to 3.5 million according to recently released Chinese Government statistics
and is the number of those employed is continuing to drop while production continues
to rise. Production
in the clothing field alone has risen 1700 percent since 1978 while the value
of exports are now 50 times higher than they were then. China will be geared up
to make mince meat out of the global textile competition in 2005 when export quotas
to both the United States and Europe fall by the wayside due to the generosity
of the World Trade Organization. The World Bank predicted that Chinas production
will increase almost by 400 percent more from the date of their entry into WTO.
The only thing that seems to be lacking in the Chinese scheme of things
is having name brands which cause repetitive buying. These are not all that hard
to come by if you have the loot and at the right time, China will start acquiring
them. In the meantime, all of Chinas looms seem to spinning to the same
tune, they are operating at full tilt and at the moment Chinese Factories do not
need to take on the additional expense of paying for the advertising and public
relations to keep their names in the public eye. When
push comes to shove, it will not become a matter of China against the rest of
the world as many would think. It will become a contest between one Chinese manufacturer
and another for survival. The rest of the world will be sitting on the sidelines
as Chinese textile companies go after one another with hammer and tong. As this
struggle reaches its zenith, branding along with advertising
will become consistently more important as the death spiral continues literally
out of control and China will eventually be sent into textile chaos after putting
most of the rest of the worlds production out of business. The entire scenario
should begin unfolding in the next year or two and it will be interesting to watch
the twisting and turning that will occur.
The effect upon American manufacturers will be negligible except on their
books. Massive expenditures on plants in now uncompetitive countries will have
to be written off. In
earlier articles, we have discussed the fact that new wars will most probably
be fought in non-physically and we have addressed as an example how during the
conflict in Yugoslavia, the American CIA was able to make mincemeat out of the
Serbian banking system, rendering it literally non-functional. Primarily, this
sort of thing represents the future of war, Internet Warfare that
has already become part of our daily lives and some nations are already on the
firing line, China is a standout in this regard facing down three rather prodigious
opponents simultaneously. We have previous mentioned their ongoing information
wars with the Falun Gung as well as their high level confrontation with Taiwan
which is fought in their mutual war rooms. However, these conflicts are not going
to result in armed warfare anytime soon, the United States has dipped its own
oar in the water and will be making very serious waves in this arena in the near
future. All
of us are familiar with the United States strategy of getting its economic
and political message across to the people of other countries an intimate part
of its overall strategy, reflected in the massive and successful reach of the
Voice of America. The broadcasts were extremely important in creating the environment
that led to the collapse of the Soviet Union, which in turn, has temporarily secured
peace on an international level. Moreover, we have been beaming our propaganda
into Mainland China through the facilities of both Voice of American and Radio
Free Asia for decades. While we call it transmission of information,
the Chinese seem to think that we are pushing the envelope and subverting their
government. While we certainly dont feel that this is the case, it would
not be a push to say that we are trying to re-indoctrinate their people toward
a more democratic point of view. However, Chinese officials have determined that
these continuing broadcasts were not at all helpful and started jamming them over
a decade a go.
Communication Enter,
stage left, Internet! This has certainly caused the price of poker to go up, at
least as it relates to the intelligence community. Now the United States had a
way to get its propaganda to the people of China in living color and in three
dimensions. Internet use in China
has been skyrocketing at a rate of over 400 percent a year (in a bad year) and
is now nudging the 30-million mark. However, that number includes the usage of
Internet-Cafés and the like. The CIA thought that Internet was a really neat way
of spreading the gospel according to W. However, the Chinese Government
was violently against the idea in principal and in practice as well and erected
substantial barriers to the process by controlling the server capabilities for
the population. In other words, the house had rigged the Internet to broadcast
only stuff approved by the bur crates. In order to get around this minor irritation,
the CIA began setting up a series of servers that could be alternated regularly,
thereby confusing the attempts of the government to censure our propaganda. Although
you probably never knew it, the Central Intelligence Agency in addition to operating
a high-tech spy network, stays on top of their game by investing in companies
that they perceive to have new technologies that can be put to valid espionage
uses they, the CIA that is, advertise the fact that they are in the venture capital
business and make no bones of what their investment objectives are. This is one
VC that is not interested in their return on capital.
In
any event, the CIA Venture fund, what ever they call it, put some big bucks in
a small technology based outfit in Emeryville, California by the name of safeweb
that is in the business of installing Internet privacy servers. In plain English,
a privacy server disguises the sites that a viewer is watching from so that no
one can tell and he can watch without Big Brother knowing about it.
By providing the CIA with scores of these machines and moving their viewers
perceived location from one place to another before anyone can get a fix on their
location, the CIA creates an environment in which Chinese viewers can travel wherever
they want on the web without any fear of getting caught. Moreover, the CIA does
not believe that it is necessary to send out their regular dose of misinformation
and half-truths, because it is convinced that it is
only necessary to show the average person living in China what is going on in
the outside world. They are probably right in assuming that this should be more
than enough to convince them that some changes are in order.
In
addition, the CIA and Voice of America have teamed up in another intriguing concept:
they are pruning the e-mail addresses of influential Chinese net watchers and
creating a very hefty address book. By utilizing these mailing lists they can
communicate at will with these people as long as the Chinese technicians cant
shut the system down. If the theory works as planned, the CIA would be in pig
heaven, able to proselytize everyone on the Internet in China simultaneously.
In the meantime, nothing in life is ever as easy as it appears. The Chinese Government
has arrested any number of people and made it clear that watching things on Internet
such as the sites of the Washington Post Site or Amnesty International could result
in them becoming unwilling donors to their organ transplant program, an unforgettable
experience. China
is rather desperate, considering that their leaders are convinced that the next
war is going to be fought with computers, rather than armies. They are so convinced
that they are right that the government is considering adding another service
to the army, navy and marines. This would be some form of computer disorganization
group which would attempt to destabilize their opponents during hostilities, working
to throw their economies into chaos through the use of highly sophisticated computer
programs, to redirect the internal flow of utilities by interfering with the programs
which determine where energy is supplied and locking up communication systems
by interfering with circuits. If this werent enough, they probably have
the capability of creating havoc with flight control systems, causing transportation
backups, and in addition are fully capable of sending bogus information on the
targets of their ordinance, causing interception to become difficult if not impossible.
Furthermore,
they have established a fiber optics networks which extend the length and breadth
of the country. Fiber-optics make communications impervious to foreign attempts
to disrupt the systems because for the most part they are impermeable. People
in the National Security Agency of the United States are saying that this was
what caused the EP-3E (Peter Rabbit as it is called by the Navy) incident. U.S.
intelligence had to get closer and closer to the Chinese border at the source
to read the encoded signals that intelligence was trying to interpret.
Contrary to what appeared in the American press, this is what ultimately
caused China to bring down the plane.
Burma leads the pack in creating
methodology to constrain purported Internet abuses. Simply put, the unauthorized
possession of a computer with networking capability will bring the lawbreaker
seven to fifteen years in the clink. In Burma, that usually means that we will
not be bothered by that perpetrator again, at least in our lifetime. China and
Vietnam have done Burma one better by nipping Internet offenses in the bud. They
have required that all networks install filters so that any material observed
by Chinese computers is sanitized at the source. In spite of all these precautionary
steps, China has felt the need to enact a new series of laws regarding Internet
usage, creating penalties for what would be normal usage in other societies. Paranoid
leaders are convinced that the Web is being used to leak state secrets, to distribute
pornography and to support separatist movements in Tibet and Xinjiang. Singapore
has used a similar system to block out decadent materials such as the Playboy
site. Moreover,
we were reading them like a book and they werent going to have any more
of it. Although, the Chinese were able to acquire some very advanced and sophisticated
equipment, most of it is of no value to them because they dont have the
delivery systems to read anything we have. In order to do that, they would have
to have an armada of aircraft patrolling either the Mexican or the Canadian border
on a full-time basis. In addition, this assumes that they were able to figure
out how to work our systems, which would have been literally impossible. However,
there is no question that they did receive a valuable cache of high-tech equipment
which you can believe they are studying intently. Be
that as it may, the worst torture known to man is being suffered by most high-ranking
Chinese intelligence officials. Almost all of the computers in China contain equipment
and software purchased from either Microsoft and/or Intel, both American companies.
The Chinese officials are being driven crazy by the fact that there could be Trojan
Horses planted within either Windows or the Pentium devices. These horses of another
color could take various hues and shapes. They could be viruses that are only
waiting for an incident to occur that makes the United States unhappy and they
release their deadly toxicity. They could take the form of a hidden switch which
at the proper time can be simply turned off from any location in the world or
they could even be programmed to start giving off disinformation at the proper
time, causing mathematical computation to be off a digit or so. This could render
missile guidance systems hopelessly worthless or even worse; conceivably they
could be programmed to take a circular route landing back exactly where they started.
All of the above could be hidden within some legitimate program and allowed to
lay fallow until needed. One
could certainly wonder if Microsofts cooperation on matters such as this
with the National Security Agency didnt help them avoid the wrath of the
Justice Department who wanted to break them into little pieces.
In addition, there is no question that between the Pentagon and the National
Security Agency, Intel has two of the largest clients in the world. They could
easily be compromised in the name of national defense or if that didnt work
they could be compromised relative to having their business taken away. This in
itself could be a disaster of substantial proportions and could literally cause
the companys collapse. No matter what the bait, there is little question
that American companies could soon be shown the light on these issues, and that
cooperation could soon be worked out. In
the meantime, the United States is far ahead in utilizing the technology of future
electronic warfare and that is what is quickly driving China up the wall. The
Chinese are also profoundly aware of that one American nuclear sub lying undetected
off of the coast of Mainland China could unload more atomic weapons on the Mainland
in shorter order than the entire country has in its arsenal. In French we call
that the ultimate equalizer, but then again as Einstein said when
asked what weapons the Third World War would be fought with he said, I dont
know but I can tell you with what
weapons the Fourth World War would be fought with, rock and spears. As with
all things, the problems revolving around the EP-3 over flight were resolved.
It appears that there is an agreement that the United States and China were signatories
to called the 1998 Agreement on Maritime Military Consultation. This agreement
seems to cover matters concerning the high seas and international airspace. The
fact that the doomed the doomed plane was flying over international waters when
the collision occurred seemed to make a conference under the auspicious of that
agreement more than logical. However, not on the agenda in Guam is compensation
with the Chinese still demanding a cool million and the United States offering
chewing gum money. Dont hold you breath on a payment but, the worst is over
relative to hard feelings. Computing
China Style
One of the most glaring
problems facing the Chinese is their use of sophisticated computers. The
original Mandarin Language has 13,000 characters and even when this number is
reduced into what they call the "simplified" alphabet, that reduction
brings the grand total to down to a hardly manageable 5,000. Try to analyze where
China can go in that field, which as we know is where it is going to be in the
21st century. Picture fitting 5,000 characters. Thus, nationalism aside,
the Chinese need the English language to communicate with their computers,
either, they must be conversant with English or they must be able to make the
English language phonetically translate into Mandarin a literally impossible task.
The few Chinese keyboards that have been created require up to six keystrokes
to produce one character in Chinese. The only hopes for the future lie in speech
or handwriting recognition but sadly, these are complicated by the sheer number
of characters and sounds that have to be analyzed.
The only hope on the immediate
horizon is the Lexicus Recognizer, developed by Motorola, an gigantic achievement
that is rated at 95 percent accuracy, using the entire 13,000 character alphabet.
Motorola attributes the fact that they have been able to get as far as they have
with the fact that the Chinese handwriting or printing is much more uniform than
English and in spite of the large number over transliterations necessary, they
are highly accurate. The problem with this type of system is that you can
create two-way errors, those coming in and those coming out. You fist have to
convert the system to English and then after you have arrived at the data, it
has to be again converted to Chinese. Thus, what may have seemed like a small
error at the beginning of the process can be magnified geometrically.
Others are working in the
same field because whoever makes it work is going to hit a home run. Apple has
a machine voice recognition machine that can convert 60 characters a minute. This,
at the moment is far to slow for commercial applications and Multi-Corp Inc. of
Calgary has dusted off a new type of keyboard that can create Chinese characters
by a process of elimination. Although the Multi-Corp device represents stunning
technology, it takes an average of 2.7 keystrokes to create a Chinese Character,
still far to slow. Another company that is still in the picture is Xiaojun Computer,
a Beijing technology company, that uses a phonetical conversion system to make
Mandarin work with only 24 keys. All these models have a long way to go and until
they get it straight, the only ones in China that will effectively be able to
utilize computer technology are those that a proficient in English. SCIENCE
China has always been known
as a scientific innovator rather than a copycat. Science is considered to be a
noble undertaking in a country that prizes internal technological progress. On
the other hand, science and bureaucracy seem to be diametrically in opposition
and while China has research and development centers galore; they also lead the
world in progress numbing government interference. China’s almost nine hundred
laboratories, institutes and academies employing 1.5 million scientists and technicians
are using outmoded equipment, following government polices evolved during the
dark ages and are being paid on a monthly basis what a starving New York cab driver
takes home in an afternoon for a months work. Fully half of China’s scientific
community has been driven to pure research into esoteric regions offering little
or no hope of success. China’s unique innovations over the last decade, beyond
some minor agricultural advances are not enough to fill a small thimble.
Thus, the government has had enough and is rapidly transferring the scientific
elite into real-world industries that are dealing with real-time problems.
China has become more interested
in getting a return on its research dollars but unfortunately has reacted a little
late. Many of the brightest stars were sent to the United States and other western
countries for advanced training, but when they had completed the prescribed curriculum,
most remained to enjoy the good life while staying put. Thus, in the United States
alone, 175,000 of China’s best scientific hopes have opted out of the system and
remain here. Although the expatriates undoubtedly have some ingrown chauvinism,
without super-colliders, Tokamaks and Cray’s, many feel that there is no
ability to even start competing in China which can not afford even the down payment
on the newest and most sophisticated of scientific apparatus. Since the
west pays the highest wages in the most critical of industries, talented software
programmers as an example, hardly ever find their way back to the mainland.
One of the major problems
in China’s science was the Cultural Revolution, which seemed to think that being
smart was a crime against the state. The universities literally shut down in 1966
and it wasn’t until 1971 that they began taking students again. But then, a student
was accepted on a hit or miss basis with only political connections being a guaranteed
path to a higher education. No entry exams were given and for the most part, pure
research became about as acceptable as mad cow disease. Scientists had to go through
reorientation and they were held up to ridicule. Thus, even if the schools and
the programs had survived the cultural revolution, it was not an exciting thing
to be a scientist during those times and the country lost over a decade before
sanity returned in 1976.
Other problems abound, but
the most critical is that Chinese scientists now have an open wire to those in
the rest of the world. They are getting a taste of the scientific freedom that
exists elsewhere as opposed to the closed society in which Beijing forces them
to operate. They are asking for more academic freedom to publish and share information
with their global peers and you can expect that to happen on the same day that
China announces that they no longer have any interest in reuniting with Taiwan.
THE MILITARY
Every
once in awhile, especially when the Pentagon is negotiating with congress for
more money, an article mysteriously appears in the newspapers about a new weapon
that the Chinese have developed and that our military needs funds to counteract
it. While there is not much question that China has made some strategic advances
in the areas of long-range missiles (potentially at the expense of United States'
security), for the most part, their delivery systems are still relatively archaic
and uncertain. Their enormous army, the People's Liberation Army (PLA) which includes
the all branches of the military is basically a low tech force incapable of fighting
a war in which the enemy is not reachable by land.
The best planes in their air
force were supplied by the Russians who are not in the habit of giving away anything
good that can potentially be used against them when the chips are down. The navy
lacks even one aircraft carrier and their submarines are primarily of World War
II vintage although, these are being replaced with adequate newer vintage models.
Literally all equipment that exists is second rate and communicates equipment
for co-ordination between units is non-existent. They have insignificant night-fighting
ability and little or no gear designed to protect their troops from chemical,
nuclear or biological weapons. However, as an industrial power, China is
moving smartly forward. Advances in every field are coming amazingly swiftly.
While they are still not in a class with the United States, they are moving in
that direction are are not to be taken lightly.
While I wouldn't want to be
Japan if the Chinese become really ticked off at them, I thing that the United
States has a decade or so before China can be serious threat. By that time, we
will have created a missile defense system, probably buying yet another decade. Birth
Control China
always seems to do what it takes to get by.
Although some of their theories seem strange to us, the reasoning is basically
simple. As an example of what seemed to be bizarre thinking when it originally
was announced by the government the regulation that couples in China could only
have one child. This horrified people in China and its implications were soon
discussed all around the world. However, when you consider the fact that in
1980 at the time the regulation was put into effect, the country could not feed
the population that then existed let alone, fed its projected additional population
of hundreds of millions more in the years to come, you can certainly understand
the reasons for its existence. Moreover, there were substantial problems with
this regulation as boys were more highly regarded than girls in China and as we
have pointed out earlier, United Nations analysis pointed out that they believed
that there were 50-million less girls unaccounted for in the Chinese census than
should have existed and that most of these had probably been done in at birth
by parents wanting a boy. However,
eventually the Chinese were able to address their agricultural problems and the
government became more comfortable that no one was going to starve to death. Most
of the people in China had been unhappy with the one couple, one child rule
and had lobbied long and hard for its softening. With Chinas population
still growing at gargantuan proportions, this view could hardly be tolerated.
However, the bureaucrats determined to throw the people a meatless bone.
They came up with a convoluted plan which in essence would allow any couple in
which both parties were the second generation of one-child families, to have a
second child. In plain English they are effectively giving away ice in the winter
time. First, back as of 1980, Chinese families were large because big groups were
needed to till the soil. Thus, the larger the family the easier it was to address
all of the necessary chores. In addition, considering the fact that there was
no social safety net, the boys usually were responsible for taking care of their
parents in their old age. Thus, the more the better had become the Chinese rule
and families always tended to be large.
Thus, the percentage of people that were born into one-child families over
21-years ago had to be about as rare as the extinct Do- Do Bird. Furthermore,
since the rule went into only 21-years ago, it covered only people who were married
with one child at the tender age of 21 or younger.
This was a tough trick to pull off, because
the Chinese were now marrying at a more advanced age couples who at 21-years of
age already had a child were rare. Once again the chances of this were about the same as getting
caught in a flood in a telephone booth. When you combine the chances of coming
across a live Do-Do Bird with getting caught in a flood in a telephone booth,
you can see that the Chinese Government officials have put literally nothing on
the table at all. However, the bureaucrats probably feel better for it and they
can point to a projected target population of 1.6 billion in 2040, an increase
equal to the projected total population of the United States at that time. Everyone
was overjoyed at the announcement, however no one had taken the time to analyze
it. In China though, things are done a little step at a time. Another
factor was a tremendous shift in production going on within the country. For the
most part, people were leaving the farms and moving to the big cities where work
was available in many new industries. Moreover, the people believed that they
had a better chance of striking it rich in the larger metropolitan areas than
they did down on the farm and they were probably right. This movement of people
was unusual to China, a country heavily into family values and ancestor worship.
Most people in the country had never traveled more than 50-miles from their place
of birth for two reasons: cultural ties and government prohibitions would not
permit it. The governments theory was that it was much easier to keep track
of folks if they stayed put. In addition, if they moved around too much, they
could end up on the dole when they finally settled in a new area. Thus
the Chinese Government enforced what was known as the hookup system which
literally had been in place since the Han dynasty around the time of the birth
of Christ. Hukou is a residence permit without which you cannot move around China
freely. In a highly populated country, it was about the only way to maintain control
over crime, and to be sure that there were going to be enough people to staff
any new industrial plants without economic incentives. In other words, historically,
if someone new suddenly showed up in the neighborhood, you knew that something
was amiss. It was always the case that people clamored for Hukou's in the larger
cities where opportunities were greatly expanded, and there was always a flourishing
black market in these permits. For example, the price of a Beijing Hukou currently
runs about $12,000. Because bureaucrats are free to issue these permits to a certain
number of qualified people each year, they have become a prime source of graft.
People
with a good Hukou are able to marry better as well, because the Hukou is similar
to a dowry. Should a man from the country marry a woman from the city, he will
probably receive a Hukou from that area as a right. Parents will tend to save
for many years to buy these Hukous for their children believing that this
is their only chance to get ahead in life. This created an environment that changed
the historic marriage ritual. Usually, these were planned affairs arranged for
by the parents on both sides. This was no longer easy to do when the ratio of
males to females changed. While females were not valued highly at birth, when
they reached marriageable age, their value increased. The movement to the cities
created another problem, people didnt know each other and the Chinese being
a proper people, it took them some time before they did. This also put off the
raising of children from some time. All
of these changes in China brought with them substantial dislocations. Modern plants were usually erected in the big cities. The older,
uneconomic plants located in rural communities were summarily shuttered. This
created a demand for workers in the urban areas and left many of the rural communities
without any industry with the exception of farming. Because of the Hukou system,
the attraction of higher wages and bright lights could not do the job by themselves,
and China had to look for another way to solve its employment problem. Eventually,
the bureaucrats put a toe in the water and announced that they were going to allow
a small change in the way things had been done for 2,000 years. Residents of rural
communities would be allowed to apply for Hukou's if they wanted to move into
the small cities around their community. However, they would have to show that
they had a legal home and a source of income in that community. There are already
150-million excess workers, so this requirement was more than just palliative.
Note that the number is 150-million excess workers, not people. That is certainly
a large number and China is going to let many of them move but they must show
the ability getting a job. This
is going to be rather difficult when you consider that these towns where they
are going to be able to go are not the places where either industry or demand
exist. Bureaucrats are saying that
it is their intention to build more new plants in these smaller cities but it
appears as though the plan will only tend to line the pockets of local officials
who will be able to up their income by issuing the permits. While the program
shows a small attempt at progress, China is about to explode with all of these
people out of work and a plan being put forth that may start to have impact at
least several decades. The country has literally no social programs and when people
are hungry they tend to get a tad ornery. China has figured out how to deal with
the outside world but as yet does not have a clue in dealing with their own country
and they had better get it figured out before too much longer. Whatever
else, China has accomplished much in the last several years. In spite of the fact
that at times, the country seems to be moving ahead in spite of itself, has the
most vibrant large economy in the world. In the future it will be hard to sustain
the rate of recent progress because China will be expanding from an ever enlarging
base and many have said that the easy progress is behind them. As social reforms
continue and more rights are granted to the people, cheap labor will no long be
so readily available, social systems will have to be put into place that will
drain money that normally would have gone into infrastructure development and
other countries will have learned how to compete. On
the positive side though, Chinas entry into the World Trade Organization
is causing a quick economic pop. However, none of this progress came by chance.
All of the recent advances can be attributed primarily to one man, Zhu Rongji
who is at present the Premier of China. His term is going to end shortly and a
leader of his quality, tenacity and self assurance is not likely to emerge any
time soon from the pack of conservative old men that make up the remainder of
the ruling hierarchy. Zhu was willing to make the hard decisions that could have blown him away, and he stood behind them. He derided his
compatriots who did little or nothing to advance China or who questioned his direction.
Recent
History - ZHU Lets
take a look at what the man has accomplished in a short period of time. The 72-year
old Zhu, who left office in 2003, started to gain prominence as the mayor of Shanghai
at the age of 62. He was invited into the cabinet at that time with the not too
shabby title of Vice Premier, and as such he oversaw financial reforms while running
the central bank. It was Zhu who was eventually able to rein in the omnipresent
inflation that had plagued China had since the Communists took over, and controlled
the expanding money supply which indirectly had been its cause. Before
Zhu got involved, China had a number of differing types of money within their
system which allowed them to keep careful track of who had what, but this system
had a murderous downside. Primarily, it was just plain confusing and required
bureaucratic permissions to exchange money going in one direction or the other.
In other words, each type of money in China was used for different purposes and
you had to use this money for this and that money for that with no right of automatic
exchange. As a result, Chinese companies were unable to deal in the international
market and drastically restricted foreign trade. Chinas exports were severely
hampered by this system. It was Zhu who did away with it, opening Chinas
markets to the rest of the world and vice versa. Indirectly, this was the biggest
single step towards WHO admission and without it, WHO would still be a dream. His
next job was to take on the federal bureaucracy, and he did a brilliant job, cutting
the number of jobs substantially, at least by 30%, something considered unachievable
in the United States, 10 percent would be a startling number here and he did it
in literally a few short years, made the decision process more streamlined and
eliminated the opportunities for graft in almost every area he touched.
He closed or privatized unprofitable state businesses, and in doing so
brought in much needed money into the federal system and he bailed out the financial
system which was overloaded with loans that were in default. He changed banking
laws along with those of the nascent stock market and created a more level playing
field for doing business. Under
Zhu, abject poverty has almost vanished and China is rapidly developing a moneyed
middle class. Overall, we would rank Zhu up there with Jack Welch of General Electric
in his management instincts and abilities to lead and control. However, Welch
had a score of years to turn GE into the behemoth that it has become while Zhu
did the job in China in less than a decade and was facing entrenched bureaucrats
wherever he turned. He overwhelmed them by the assurance
that he was right and his willingness to forge ahead in spite of substantial odds
and a number of co-leaders who were anxious for him to stumble. Zhu is China and
they will lose a very important cog in their wheel when he steps down in the next
several years. While
Zhu has indeed done a great job, everything is still far from perfect and the
further away from the glare of Beijing you get the looser the controls seem to
be. It is always the bureaucrats that are getting into trouble in China. It seems
that there is this small city near Hong Kong that during the years before the
former British Colony became absorbed by the Mainland, the city was held up as
an example of entrepreneurship under Chinese rule. Someone seems to have spoken
substantially too soon on the matter, and today Shantou City is considered the
Wild West. Eventually, Shantou became known in nearby Hong Kong the
home of pirates, a place where contraband of any type could be purchased for a
discount price and if necessary moved out of China into a friendly nation of the
buyers choice. At
least, that was Shantous claim to fame until people in the neighborhood
noticed the really bizarre things going on at the Shantou City Commercial Bank,
an affable little spot owned by local politicians and used to subsidize the modernization
of the region through economic development of a unique brand. The bank was formed
in a merger of 13 credit co-operatives in the region, whence it derived an instant
and substantial customer base. Furthermore, the bank was located in one of the
special economic zones personally established by Deng Xiaopping as
capitalist showcases. The central government in Beijing
was anxious that they perform admirably because they were being watched by the
world. Banking
or the Lack Thereof Beijing
was constantly in touch with the local politicians, cajoling them to show the
world how well China could run its banking businesses.
The authorities, anxious to please their leaders, went all out to achieve
that goal. The bank became a bank for all people, including the local
pirates and drug dealers, prostitutes, petty criminals and even murderers; everyone
was welcome within their four walls. Although
they considered its policies overly aggressive, honest local people would still
deposit their paychecks into the institution. However, they did not necessarily
do it because they liked the bank. The government had a rule: if you work for
the city or state government you will be a depositor at Shantou City Commercial
Bank, or you will be looking for work elsewhere. The people found that this was
a strong incentive to make regular deposits at the bank but as we have said this
was not your normal bank. It didnt pay one pennys interest on deposits
of any kind. Furthermore, it was very dangerous to complain about that fact, as
several people who were last seen in the bank lobby arguing with tellers had disappeared.
Eventually people forgot about the fact that the institution was of the non-dividend
kind variety, and chalked up the anomaly to the price of having a nice job. However,
while the bank would not pay interest on their depositors money, it was
extremely generous in making loans. Literally anyone that wanted to borrow money
at the bank was able to do it, and bank management prided itself in the short
time that they could arrange a lending package. One of the unusual services that
Shantou City Commercial Bank provided for borrowers was fake collateral if you
did not have enough assets or earning power to get the loan on its own merits.
While this was indeed a most generous add-on service, and one used by many in
the community, the collateral came at a price. Customers really took out two loans,
the first for the money and the second for the backup collateral. The
money was lent under fairly standard terms, but the collateral came at a rather
high price, and had to be repaid on a weekly basis in cash. The rate was rather
high and most people when they started analyzing the interest that they were paying
became concerned. The rate for having the bank provide collateral was called 6
for 5. In other words, for every 5-dollars that were borrowed, 1 dollar in interest
was charged every week the loan was outstanding and this didnt include the
more normal rate of interest on the loan itself. Furthermore, it was a good policy
to stay current on the interest on these loans as the bank had a habit of sending
a team of collectors to visit defaulters. These were rather large people that
carry sticks and somehow by the time that they got through with you, you paid
or were not seen again. Many in the city found the banks tactics crude,
but there was no where else to borrow money.
With
stories like these circulating around the city one would think that the bank would
have had a tough time getting new depositors. However, they had an excellent public
relations department which would regularly match the list of the businesses in
town with depositors in the bank. Should you not be lucky enough to be a regular
depositor of the bank, these pleasant public relations people would send you a
lovely letter extolling the banks virtues and suggesting that you would
find Shantou a lovely place to do your business. However, the letter also gave
you only a short time to make a positive decision, and if you did not respond
quickly enough, they would send a team of their employees to make a house call.
You see, Shantou believed in hands on management and more importantly, regular
visits with members of the community to convince people of their eagerness to
please. The problem was, that if upon the visit you still werent convinced
that this was the place for your money, you were usually taken out in back and
beaten until you changed your mind. Most people were
eventually convinced by the banks public relations department to
give the bank a try. When
the bank determined that they needed money for more important purposes they sent
out a notice to clients that they had capped their withdrawal rate. This could
cause some degree of pain to depositors because when this sort of thing happened,
and it seemed to happen regularly, customers were not allowed to withdraw more
than a few-hundred dollars at a time. This caused some severe hardships in the
community, but the bank had a solution. Although you could not withdraw your own
funds, the bank would let you borrow whatever money may be necessary to tide you
over. Naturally, this type of lending was handled by the phony collateral department
and the large men with sticks. In spite of the fact that this service was seemingly
a great boon to the community, very few people used the privilege and seemed to
be able to find other sources for getting their money like selling their most
prized possession in neighboring Hong Kong for a pittance.
But
whatever its reputation, the bank was indeed profitable. In spite of the fact
that it was a quasi municipal enterprise, it was owned independently by local
political officials and as such was a private tax paying institution. In spite
of rolling up gigantic profits with the banks aggressive banking procedures,
they somehow never were able to show a profit, and therefore did not pay any taxes.
Beijing became concerned by the fact that if the bank remained in good standing
from a regulatory point of view, which they were and their assets had grown mightily,
how then could they not be making money. Beijing sent in their auditors and found
that they were indeed right, the bank was making more money than they could handle,
and were siphoning it off into overseas accounts belonging to the principals.
When the investigation was finished it showed that the scale of tax evasion set
an all time record in China. The
money was sent off shore by a complicated system of export rebates which allowed
profits to be made in other countries, an excellent reason to do business with
Shantou and one of the factors that caused the surrounding region to grow so quickly.
And
what about the retail clients of the bank? All of the money had been siphoned
overseas and there was nothing left in the coffers. The Chinese Government didnt
have the money to pay them back so they set up a tax to allow the people to pay
themselves back. Today the city is the highest taxed in China and will remain
so until the bank is once again on solid footing, but the people will have deposited
their money twice, once from their wages and the second
time from taxes. This indeed was a very unusual bank and one that certainly got
the attention of lenders all over of the globe for their unique banking practices.
This was not the success story that China had planned. CHINA
AND THE WORLD BANK
Many have
called the World Bank misguided and those maybe the kindest words of all. This
organization seems incapable of determining when a country no longer needs its
help in backing projects and can rely on internal funding or private sources for
funding. An example of this particular type of confusion has occurred over and
over again in China where private lenders stood by, ready willing and able to
provide infrastructure financing, only to be rejected because the World Bank was
offering lower rates. This is world class strange.
The World
Bank’s mandate is clear, it is only a “Bank” of last resort and was not
created to become a competitor with private financing sources. Furthermore, the
World Bank’s terms are far more lenient and often more forgiving than private
sources who make sure that the I’s are dotted and the T’s crossed before loans
are completed. China is one of the world’s wealthiest nations in terms of hard
currency reserves and its current account surplus is particularly awesome. It
is more than a stretch to figure out what these World Bank people are doing in
the country at all. However, China's repayment history has been excellent and
the World Bank's collection history has been dismal, this may be the reason for
the madness. On
occasion, China has been placing its excess money into U.S. Government Debt
instruments when it has borrowed from sources such as the World Bank, in effect
earning money on its borrowing. ()
We think that General Marshall would be turning over in his grave if he saw what
was going on. Not only is the World Bank loaning money to countries that
do not need their help but by their own admission they have had disastrous results
in one of their highest priorities, the building of dams to create agricultural
independence, electrification and navigability. The only problem was that people
that did not need to be resettled were, people that needed to be moved weren’t
and even when things were worked out correctly, compensation was often not adequate.
Even worse, the dams are created without even the slightest thought as
to a grid that can transport it output or the people that can use it. Consider
the wonderful generating plants built in Zaire where the people have neither grids
or electricity. An amazing boondoggle that only the hapless World Bank could have
foisted on them. Then they want to be repaid!! Good Grief.
The World
Bank stated, “The bank intends to reinforce the vigor with which it addresses
resettlement issues and to ensure compliance with its policies that set environment,
social and international law safeguards. While several steps have been taken over
the past few years to improve the quality of resettlement, there is a long way
to go, especially with respect to improving resettlement performance during the
implementation phase of the project cycle.” As is this wasn’t bad enough, in India,
Human Rights Watch stated that “villagers were beaten and arbitrarily detained
for peaceful protests.”()
(over relocation relative to a World Bank financed dam in Central India)
And complaints
have circulated from all quarters that World Bank Funding has provided an opportunity
for corrupt dictators to stuff their pockets full of cash. Many have said that
the Bank was just plain not doing its homework relative to transnational corruption.
Others have seen to it that corruption begins at home. James Wolfensohn, the World
Bank President has recently found the same kind of infrastructure problems as
home as he and his organization were fostering elsewhere. It seems that a few
of the Bank’s loyal employees were feathering their own nests while out stamping
for good old World Bank U. Wolfensohn didn’t hit the panic button to hard, he
only called in Price WaterhouseCoopers, set up an internal fraud investigating
team, hired outside specialist and issued an internal memorandum requesting employees
to call an emergency hot line to allow them to rat on their fellow employees anonymously
and with recourse.
This is
an organization that has been warning every country on earth that if the World
Bank “secret police” finds signs of corruption in a country, they will either
not be eligible for the Bank’s largesse or at least they would only get a fraction
of what normally would have been advanced. Some wags are wondering whether the
same thing will happen to Wolfensohn’s vaunted salary and benefits now that corruption
has been uncovered in his own home.
So, unbearably
archaic at birth, ill-equipped to adjust to a changing world and structured so
that the stronger members would dominate the weaker, the United Nations has spent
enormous sums of their members’ money accomplishing little, other than providing
a home for senior diplomats that have seen better years. Pontificating and posturing
have become the essence of its existence, and its brethren at the World Bank and
the IMF have not fared much better. For the most part, humanity has given up any
hope of its dreams being fulfilled at that cathedral of bureaucrats. Amazingly,
we no longer even visit the edifice. ()
However, China has been able to work these folks to their advantage in ways only
unworldly folks can imagine and in spite of having more hard currency than anyone
else in the world, they are constantly on the World Bank's dole.
CHINA AND THE
UNITED NATIONS
Many have
stated that the United Nations was created in another era and no longer addresses
the exigencies of the modern world. They have said that reform was essential,
not mandatory; yet political convenience, not experience, education or intelligence,
continues to dictate the selection of the UN’s management. John D. Rockefeller
would not have kind words for his son who donated land, today worth hundreds of
millions of dollars, to an organization that has drained the treasuries of the
poor and contributed only a series broken dreams.
Power remains
unbalanced with political exigencies of greater importance than logic. All
the nations should have a forum in which to resolve their differences; yet Iraq,
which attacks its neighbors, pollutes the atmosphere with burning oil wells and
plays with chemicals and missiles that threaten the destruction of the globe,
remains a member in good standing do such friendly countries as Belarus, North
Korea, Syria and Iran. Taiwan, an economic miracle, has no voice at all because
a relative across the straits threatens world chaos if Taiwan is allowed to speak.
Two of the most powerful nations on earth are not members of the Security Council
because they lost a war, Japan and Germany. If every country that lost a war were
eliminated from the Security Council, it would have no members.
The Financial
Times on July 14, 1997 put the financial plight of the United Nations into perspective
in a series of vignettes. CHINA DRUGS Interestingly enough, in spite of the fact that more often
than not, there are not enough drugs available in China to provide anesthetics
during operations, antibiotics or shots to ward off diseases or even topical ointments
for infections and burns, there is now a profusion of the illegal stuff around
for domestic use or export into other countries in the region. This indeed is
a massive turnabout from the time during the 1800s when the British hooked the
Chinese on Opium both for fun, profit and population control purposes. Chinese
gangs are in the game today, but do it only for the bucks they receive and it
almost seems that they are now trying to hook the entire region on a synthetically
manufactured product that has a made in China stamp on it. The newest craze is something called ice. It is
a stimulant, it is cheap and it is addictive as hell. Interestingly enough, the
same economics that allow China to mass produce quality products
for global markets allows them to undercut other producers in the illicit drug
trafficking. However, this really is not as important as it would seem. The Chinese
gangs are viscous and if they dont take over an area based on price or quality
they will take it over by force. It was as that great philosopher Al Capone once
said, While you can make a lot of friends with a smile and a kind word,
you can do even better with a smile, a kind word and a gun. The Chinese
seem to have learned his credo well. Formerly Myanmar was the country with the
highest illicit drug production in the region, but China, not to be outdone by
their neighbors is going for total dominance in everything that it touches and
drugs have become no exception to the rule. Myanmar has already slipped to a very
poor second to China and totally lacks the delivery
system and heavy handed backup to impress its cliental in the proper fashion.
However, this is not to say that this illicit production is sanctioned by government
officials. Many say that Chinese police are probably doing everything within their
power to put a stop to at least a portion of this traffic but so far they have
had little success. Moreover, they probably wouldnt care so much if the
indigenous population wasnt becoming themselves the best client of the drug
dealers. Whole villages have succumbed to ice and more often than
not everyone in the local village can be walking around in a daze while mumbling
mysterious inanities at the same time. Previously highly productive areas
in China have seen the both the quality and quantity of their production dip drastically
as a result of drugs. Some of the recent arrests have produced scary results for
the Chinese, the Wall Street Journal report in an article entitle Chinese
Criminals Gain Ground in Asian Drug Trade on February 4, 2002:
In
October 2000, Chinese authorities arrestee former employees of a pharmaceuticals
factory, for acting as technology advisers to ice production in three
different provinces according to the governments 2000 annual report on drug
control in China. Some companies licensed to trade chemicals are illegally selling
them to meth labs. Authorities seized 20 tons of methamphetamine in 2000, up from
just 1.6 tons two years before. According to the same report, China now supplies the Philippines
with 95% of their methamphetamine supply and rakes in a total of over $6 billion
a year. Moreover, it was reported how effortless it was for the Chinese dealers
to get into the Philippines and from their, initiate their nefarious career as
drug dealers. The Philippines is an extremely lenient place to set down roots
as it allows new residents special visas available if you have the necessary $70,000
required to invest in the country. Criminals from the Mainland customarily
deposit the requisite amount in a local Philippine Bank and then for a while enter
into a high-profile legit business such as becoming a food vendor on street corners.
After a socially correct period of time, the remaining money in the bank is used
to import street drugs disguised as just about anything. Many street
vendors were able to disguise drugs as food toppings and were thus able to bring
massive drug quantities in with great success. Obviously customs agents in Manila
are not too swift at best and very little of the processed material is ever caught.
High level payoffs are also helpful to the bad guys. The street vending business also offers and excellent platform
for moving product however, the Chinese gangs have recently become more interested
in the wholesale end of the business than hawking their wares on local street
corners. As they become more wealthy and powerful, for the most part they had
taken to using employee locals to assume the risks in moving the illicit
materials down the food chain. Many of the major Philippine cities have literally
become overwhelmed with overzealous drug traffickers and they are polluting an
already injured economy that is suffering from series governmental mistakes and
political disruptions. In the meantime, the indigenous population now borders
on something between euphoria and hypertension as drug fever approaches the boiling
point. Chinese labor and production sophistication is capable of triggering
a result that a good part of the entire country could well become drug dependent.
Tensions have become high between Chinese officials who are acquiesced of not
doing enough to stem the flow and Philippine officials who are worried that they
will soon be governing a nation of addicts if drug use continues to grow much
longer at the same pace. Speaking of Drugs Globally, everyone that was anyone was getting really annoyed
at China for their policy of putting people
to death with a bullet deftly administered to the head. I for one happen to think
that it is easily as humane as the electric chair so I am not sure what all of
the fuse is about. I mean, it isnt like these people arent going to
be put to death one way or the other and a bullet to the head administered by
a pro is just about as quick and clean as it can get. However, it was thought
of as inhuman and more than that, it was sloppy many people were muttering. They
said that one of the problems with these types of executions was the fact that
it was difficult for the bereaved family to identify the corpse and when the execution
required more than one shot, it became virtually impossible. Facial features literally
became obliterated. More often than not, most of the bodys insides had been
removed for charitable and humanitarian purposes; which included the
transfer of the now unneeded organs to those with big money who were fighting
for life and could pay the price of a transplant. Between trying to identify a
body that often had been skinned to provide cover for burn victims the bereaved
family members could not even be sure at what they were looking at. Headless and
without any skin or organs, the family had little left with to identify their
kin. This process often made them hysterical and between the familys complaints
and world criticism, China eventually had to make a
concession. Human beings had become what Steinberg had once said of the giant
meatpackers in Chicago, When they were done with
a pig they had removed everything but the oink. However, the Chinese people
that received capital punishment for the crimes hardly cared and for the most
part, their relatives never even knew what happened to them and why. The uproar continued unabated and eventually China was able to create drug that
would preserve organs even if a lethal injection was used on the victim. This
great move forward was trumpeted in the press as the humanitarian thing to do
and China was highly lauded for their great leap forward. However, as we have
pointed out in the past, China, an unwieldy giant is like a giant ocean liner
that once headed in a direction has some trouble turning but is almost impossible
to stop. Its mass does not allow it to slow down quickly and in spite of an article
in the China Daily which talks about this accommodation to human dignity (lethal
injection), This change proves the countrys respect for the dignity
of human beings, even those who committed serious offenses. However the press does not point out the fact that less than
100 lethal injections have been used out of the now possibly 10,000 executions
of criminals that occur each year in this country. Moreover, most Chinese newspapers
talk about the fact that injection is cheaper than wasting money on bullets to
dispense with criminals. They know full well that this is not the fact, the families
of the dead victims are forced to pay for the bullets, and they are obliged to
pay a retail price, not wholesale. So when push really comes to shove, the provincial
government and the army are actually making money on the transactions. In spite
of this seeming cost saving if you are serious about your cost accounting it would
be necessary to include the cost of the executioner who is normally paid $85 to
carry out the act. Moreover, added to this number must also be the cost of the
cleanup after the execution. In addition, there is not much question that the
cost soars and especially during periods when the government is conducting an
anti-crime campaign, more often than not, there are not enough trained executioners
to go around. The various districts often get into a price war during these periods
offering premium dollars to executioners that do not leave a substantial mess
and can get the job done with the requisite one bulled. Those districts that can’t
afford the price increases brought about by the numerical increase in executions
and the necessary overtime payments are forced to bring in trainees who usually
mess up the place and leave the officials responsible for the execution highly
embarrassed. There are other advantages to the new-found execution methodology
brought about by extensive technology research in Chinas laboratories. Because
the new formula is so effective, prisoners can now be given the narcotic-poison
mix that does not damage the organs in situ which allows the body parts removal
operation to be conducted in hospital rooms. After all, it is highly distracting
for sick people in hospital rooms to a gun shot followed by screams of anguish
so that historically the executions have been concluded out of doors and the organs
stripped in ambulances. Hardly the best of conditions and every once in awhile
the already mourning family can be in the neighborhood and that makes for unnecessary
trauma to everybody involved. Entire wings of Chinese hospitals are being
outfitted for this new methodology which allows more sterile conditions and a
higher degree of professionalism. Moreover, even the executioners are not happy about anything
more than the money that they receive. Many of these criminals have all sorts
of diseases or are on drugs. Shooting someone in the head at close range causes
body parts to fly on every direction including right at the executioner who usually
has to bath for hours after finishing a days work. Even the most perfectly
aimed shots cause organs to be splattered all over the site. More than one executioner
has died from the effects of the bullet-in-the-head death penalty when executed
in this manner and now, because of a bad history, the person carrying out the
execution is forced to wear surgical masks and gloves. In the United States, it is the doomed
person that is palliated before the execution with drugs to calm him down. Conversely,
in China the execution is so grisly that traditionally in some areas; the sentencing
judge takes the executioner out drinking the night before the event to calm his
nerves. We are not sure what the overall effect on this new mode of execution
will be on the convicted, but we are certain that the man pulling the trigger
is going to sleep a lot better at night not thinking about the grisly act that
is brought on by the execution, however, in China, a living is a living and $85
per is a lot of money. Mental Illness and Foot in Mouth
Disease All governments have their share of people that are citizens
that dont like what is going on and while most of the time, these folks
are quiet in the complaints, once in awhile you get someone much more vociferous
in their views than others. When a loudmouth nut-case just wont fold his
tent in spite of numerous strong indications that they are going nowhere with
their particular line of rationale, it has become somewhat of a tradition in China
to lock the troublemaker up in a psychiatric hospital until the urge to complain
is channeled into more acceptable pursuits. After several visits to the nut-house,
even the toughest advocates of change seemingly become capable of seeing the light
as it shown to them by political bureaucrats. While the situation in China has been historically effective,
it still remains far more benevolent than the Russian garden variety of Siberian
Gulag psychiatric wards which were really prison camps in disguises. While most
Russians that had mental problems that were brought on by government
abuses were never seen again, the Chinese psychiatric wards are more or less holding
pens for angry citizens to be used until they permanently re-adjust their
thinking. One form of dissent that is looked upon here as having roots
in mental problems would be becoming religiously and vocally attracted to a religion
such as the Falun Gong, which is hardly in high favor in China. The followers of this religion
tend to congregate in public places, bringing world attention to the lack of religious
freedoms in China. While various religious practices are tolerated here, there
is a point that when the fanatics, as these people are known as here, get a little
too boisterous, the government believes that it has to step in. The really hard
core dissidents which are not deemed to be re-trainable are either executed or
thrown into prison but the government believes that many of the loudmouthed followers
of the religion are nuts and should be put into the countrys psychiatric
hospitals until their mental bout with organized religion has ended. At last count
there were over one-thousand Falun Gong sympathizers locked up in crazy-houses
throughout the country.
Almost as bad as religion is to Chinese bureaucrats are what
are called the infernal petitions. The Chinese are an organized lot
and while they are not often given to rioting, they do meander in an out of crowds
looking for someone to sign what are called by government officials the nomenclature
of infernal petitions. A petition can be written for just about any
purpose, but when it hits the government where it hurts, the writer as well as
possibly the petitions signers had better run for the hills. Particularly offensive to Chinese officials are those that
ask for the officials removal from office for incompetence or bribery. These are
the kinds of nonphysical offenses that tend to get the Chinese officials unnecessary
riled up. Should the person be jailed or executed for their feelings it would
probably lend credibility to their position, so that officials here have taken
the high road. The party line in this payoff oriented country has become that
any one that thinks that the bribe taking Chinese officials are being paid off
could set a bad example for the rest of the people and therefore the offenders
are deemed nuts and carted off to the loony bin in a straight jacket.
Once out of sight, adjustments can readily be made to the offenders
personality by a series of electric shock treatments and or padded cells
with little or no light. In addition, medications and injections are extensively
utilized to palliate even the most vociferous of these rabble rousers. International
civil liberties groups have made a big-deal about these abuses and have asked
the Chinese Government for answers. Whenever officials are backed into a corner
regarding this subject, bureaucrats historically have trotted out a real mental
case just to show the world that everyone locked in an asylum in this country
is not just a political prisoner. Some of these folks that have been trotted out
in front of the international news media are so off the wall that they would have
to adjudged insane even if they lived in Wonderland with Alice and
her strange assortment of bedfellows and that by any standards is about as far
off the beaten-path as you can go. However, every country has their share of weirdoes and China
is no different. Obviously there are people here that are over-the-wall mentally
and just as logically there are people that have been placed in these institutions
to keep them permanently out of the public eye. Where China seems to be totally
out-of-step with reality, it is their policy of allowing many of these nut-jobs
to be retested in legitimate mental hospitals in the bigger cities where more
often than not they really get a fair shake. Upon re-testing many of these folks
that were originally determined on a local level to be hopelessly insane are determined
to be every bit as normal as you or I. In addition they are given a certificate
of normalcy by some of Chinas world-class psychiatrists. However, this is primarily where the system seems to break
down. China seems to have its own agenda; the guy takes his certificate back to
his hometown expecting all to be well but once again he begins his infernal petition
making, churning them out like beers in good housekeeping certificate does him
no good whatsoever. It is apparent that stubbornness, unapproved speech making
and ratting out corrupt civic officials are determined to be severe forms of insanity
in this country. Those people that make too much trouble for officials here can
be promptly carted off without any respect to their human rights and labeled as
whacko's. Once back in the padded cell, no one else is going to become too excited
about getting a petition together to get the offender out based on the simple
fact that, should they do it, there is little question that they will soon be
sharing the cell. This system works extremely well and is not subject to judges,
juries or even for the most part, publicity. No one likes a nutcase, not even
in China and they seem to have the
system down pat. AIDS The United Nations recently sent a private warning to the Chinese
Government informing them that they were soon going to faced with an AIDS epidemic
of inconceivable proportions if they did not do something about it now. The United
Nations talked about China
facing the unpleasant task of soon having to deal with the largest collection
of AIDS sufferers in the world. China is on the verge of a catastrophe that
could result in unimaginable human suffering, economic loss and social devastation.
While China currently only officially has 600,000 cases, most experts on the subject
scoff at that number and most confirm that the true cases of the disease are at
least a number of orders of magnitude higher. Interestingly enough, in spite of
facing a literally uncontrollable outbreak and substantially low-balling its dangers,
most people living in China have still never heard of the
disease. The China State Family Planning Commission found that only
20% of the people in the country ever heard of the disease and of those, only
half realized that it was sexually transmitted. And yet, the practice of selling
blood without thoroughly checking it goes on unabated with recipients often
getting much more than they bargained for. Prostitution which flourishes all over
the country to a degree that it almost seems legal, also adds dramatically to
the spread of this disease. Many of the girls engaged in this profession are also
drug users who share needles with others. They are then capable of infected countless
numbers of their clients without even knowing that they are carriers because of
a lack education by the health ministry on the subject. Another method by which the disease is spread is rather interesting.
There is the traditional taboo against homosexuality in this country but it only
keeps people in the closet. Due to the fact that homosexuality is not practiced
openly here, there are few support groups and the disease is transmitted from
one person to another with unrelenting rapidity. . It has been estimated that
fully one-third of the total cases of AIDS in this country are resident within
the homosexual community. Moreover, in this country most homosexuals strangely
live two lives. One with a wife and children because of the weight of family tradition
which believes that homosexuality is unthinkable and the other is their underground
participation in the secretive gay community where the worst of the AIDS spread
takes place. Wives, who are not even aware of their husbands extra-curricular
clandestine sexual proclivities are routinely infected by them and often carry
the disease to their unborn children. Medical officials are usually unable to
find the ultimate carriers because of the horrific shame that would come to the
man who admitted homosexual relations. In China they believe that the mans
ancestors would stir in their graves it something like this ever was to come out.
However, many of the ancestors were in the closet as well so one never knows
really how much stirring would really occur. While there are methods of controlling the spread of AIDS such
as condoms, knowledge about the disease is hard to come by in a country where
the government would not even admit that it existed until very recently. If the
truth were known, the Government has itself been in the closet on this subject
and only now are they playing catch-up. However, the hour is late and the disease
is already deeply embedded within an unrepentant and still ignorant society. For
a country where blood selling is a way of life, prostitution is rampant (Today,
paid sex is common activity associated with business trips, official junkets and
sometimes tour packages. Even small towns have businesses that function as brothels
normally in beauty salons, dance halls, saunas, massage parlors or karaoke
bars)
and homosexuality for traditional reasons has been pushed far underground, it
will be impossible without major structural changes in the entire society to marshal
the forces necessary to make China something other than a gigantic hospital for
highly diseased people. Moreover, China
is not accustomed to dealing with the fact that for the first time; literally
in its history, there is substantial mobility in this country. At one time, no
one ever ventured far from home for two reasons. The first was that identity cards restricted them to the local
area of their birth and the second was simply the fact that there was no way to
get from here to there and more importantly, no money or reason to go there. Today,
traveling salesman, bureaucrats, travelers are able to take planes, busses and
trains the length and breadth of the a country that still has no uniform medical
protocols. The women who a generation ago, would have been assigned work in factories
or on the farms are no longer in demand and must “hustle” to find work. Without
an adequate education and often living in a rural area, this is not always the
easiest things to do. Prostitution is, for most of these women the only way out
because the State has still not come to grips with the massive sociological shift
that they have created. Under the strong arm of Mao, AIDS would have at least
been restricted to a small area and the people living their would have already
been quarantined so that the disease could not have spread. Prostitution did not
exist simply because women had a better way of making a living and even as a last
resort, the state would support them. Worst yet, and you may want to chalk it up to social tradition,
but China does not like to show the world
its weaknesses and as a result it has a hard time admitting that it is subject
to the same vulnerabilities that humans throughout the world suffer. Eventually
this attitude can be their undoing as continually more resources are going to
have to be channeled in direction of combating HIV as time goes on. A massive
public relations campaign would still help but that would make this monolith appear
fragile and that is not the message that China wants to convey at this point
in time. Although China has made it mandatory this year that AIDS education be
taught in clinics throughout the country, the clinics are under-funded and for
the most part cannot even provide the services for which they were created, usually
family planning let alone educate the population on a disease that even the medical
people here know little about. And the beat goes on with Chinese authorities are
erroneously trying to stamp out the disease with giving endless lectures on morality
to starving prostitutes who couldnt care less unless someone was going to
support them. Moreover, condoms are seen as an advertisement for immorality and
for the most part people in this country can not even advertise safe sex let alone
birth control. War, a far Better Use of Money Whatever their area of interest may be, China like the monolith that it
is seldom changes course. Such is the case of Taiwan. There was little question
in the minds of the British when the Chinese Government informed them that in
1997 they would be returning Hong Kong to its rightful owners that his was going
to happen one way or the other. Rather than sacrifice the Empire they capitulated.
There was even less question in the Portuguese mindset when they got the same
kind of tap of the shoulder from the Chinese who told them that Macao would once
again become part of China. Since China has started to flex their international
muscles, there are few demands that they have made that go unanswered. Membership
in the WTO was thought to be unthinkable when China made their pitch for membership.
When you consider the fact that literally everything that the World Trade Organization
stands for is literally the antithesis of the Chinese philosophy; however, when
the chips were down, China made some mild compromises and the West caved in. Or
what about the Olympics? No one ever believed that China could ever host
an event which is an exclamation of human rights and dignity, but tyrannical China
with more criminal executions than the rest of the world combined not only got
what they wanted but the committee gave it to them in spite of that fact that
two far more qualified countries were putting a better deal on the table. Thus,
when the Chinese indicate that they are desirous of becoming reunited with Taiwan, one way or the other, who are
we to scoff. The Chinese if anything know how to be extremely patient. However,
they also know how to get what they want and are most careful in carefully picking
their spots. Recently in certain circles their level of interest in this unification
has picked up quietly but however, dramatically. In 1949 there were two forces
in China, one representing
the Communists headed by Mao and the other representing American interests led
by Chiang Kai Sheik. In spite of being in charge of a rag-tag army, Mao easily
dispensed with Chiang and sent him packing to Taiwan, then a Chinese possession.
Chiang set up shop in Taiwan and in spite of some serious early
overtures by Mao and his troops to seize control, they just didnt have the
necessary material in either trained men or equipment to cross the straits and
grab the island. Since those early years, the Chinese have never changed
their tune, sometimes, it rises in crescendo and sometimes they talk of negotiation.
However, their resignation drones on like an endless play. Recently, however, the price of this international game of
chicken has quickened with the Chinese stockpiling armaments from all over the
world totally geared to crossing the straits by and taking the island by force.
During this recent period they have become the worlds largest arms purchaser
in spite of having indigenous weapons production facilities capable of turning
out prodigious quantities of military machinery. No less of an authority than
the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute claims that China took delivery last year of
over $3 billion of ships and combat aircraft primarily from Russia. The Chinese
arms imports represented twice the total of any other country on earth. Interestingly enough, almost every country on earth has joined
Chinas supply chain with, of course
Russia and Israel leading the parade in spite of the fact that in 1989, Western
Nations horrified by the Tiananmen massacre embargoed all weapons trade with that
country. However, since that time, supplying Chinas ravenous military appetitive
has become a morsel too delicious to resist. Even the United States, the self
anointed global moralist has supplied China with high-tech, sensitive computer
parts during the decade since Tiananmen to the tune of unbelievable $15 billion.
The Wall Street Journal gives a chronology of high-tech international weapons
procurement being provided to China:
British engine maker
Rolls-Royce PLC confirms that it recently supplied as many as 90 Spey jet engines
and spares to China that defense analysts believe the Peoples Liberation
Army (PLA) intends to fit onto its JH-7 fighter-bombers also being modified
with modern and long-range missiles
Earlier British sales have also boosted
PLA capabilities. In 1996, Racal Corp., now part of the French Thales Group, sold
as many as eight Skymaster longer-range airborne radars to be fitted on PLA Navy
Y-8 aircraft. Britain said the sales would help Beijing fight smuggling, but defense
analysts say the aircraft are also helping Chinese missile warships locate targets.
Should China go war to regain Taiwan in the near future, its air force will rely
on Russian-designed strike aircraft alongside locally built fighters based on
an Israeli design partially funded by the U.S. Other Chinese-made aircraft will
carry Russian and Israeli missiles that will find their targets with British and
Israeli radar and electronics. Chinas navy will deploy powerful new Russian warships and submarines alongside
locally built vessels fitter with U.S. and Ukrainian engines and Italian
torpedoes. French companies have supplied air-warfare missiles, tactical command-and
control systems and helicopters. "On land, the PLA will field
modern Russian tanks and artillery. Many armored vehicles will be protected with
advanced Israeli-designed armor cladding. Older Chinese tanks have Israeli gun
and gunsight systems. Overhead, satellites built with British and German help
will keep watch on the battlefield, fix positions for ground forces and feed data
to ships and aircraft. Meanwhile, Chinas nuclear deterrent will be mounted
on launchers improved with assistance supplied by the U.S." Does the purchase of all of this military equipment indicate
that invasion of Taiwan is becoming imminent? Well, it
may not be but it is sure enough to scare the daylights out of anyone living in
Formosa and probably the rest of the world as well. There is some point at which
the force that China can bring to bear may make the thought of outside intervention
mute and force a non-military settlement on the Island country. China will not
go away in this matter and at some time and some place, it will be dealt with,
maybe sooner than later. The Latest from Hong Kong While China goes about its business with
lumbering consistency never looking back after making a decision, some things
here do change. I remember being in Hong Kong in the middle 80s and was
totally awestruck with the magnificent buildings along with the culture and the
wealth. From downtown Hong Kong it was only a stones throw to the Chinese
border and the city of Shenzhen. Although crossing the border at that time was hardly an option,
you could gaze from Hong Kong unto what appeared to be one of the most desolate spots on
earth. One that reeked of both poverty and helpless despair and at the time, viewed
this entire panorama as one gigantic open air jail. I thought at the time of how
these miserable Chinese must have felt as they gazed back across their border
and watched as their ethnic Chinese brothers drove around in Mercedes Limos, wore
the latest of fashions and built monuments to modern society. The Mainland Chinese
for their part were dressed in drab quasi-military green or grey uniforms with
their peaked hats and military-like work ethic. They were marched everywhere,
always seemingly headed for the next job. My, times have certainly changed. While Hong Kong is suffering their second
recession in four years sending many into unemployment lines and unemployment
soaring to over an unheard of 6%, neighboring districts in China are making the
countrys annualized 7% growth rate look pale. Shenzhen in particular
is doing spectacularly and are now holding job-fairs in Hong Kong in an attempt
to attract their residents with remarkable job offers. Salaries begin at $3,000
per month and some as high as $10,000 are not unusual. This turnaround has literally been amazing but it cause is
simple enough. Hong Kong high wages forced them to look elsewhere for production of the goods that
they historically supplied the West along with the Pacific
Rim. Where better to create these factories than in Shenzhen. Wages were low,
the people well-educated and moving the finished goods through Hong Kong ports would be a simple matter. In addition, management of
Hong Kong Companies using production from Shenzhen could visit the factory whenever
they desired because of the proximity and add their know how to the mix. However, there is a danger from this Shenzhen production to
Hong Kongs economic recovery because it is only a matter of time until their
Chinese brethren will also learn where the buyers for these products are located
and no longer need Hong Kong middlemen. Hong Kong has literally become
a service industry for both production and banking acting for others. While at
one time when Mainland China was not part of the global business
network this was necessary, but since their entry into the World Trade Organization,
paying for this service is redundant and redundant while being costly to the end
users as well. Unless Hong Kong finds another use for their cadre of five-percenters,
they are going to have a recession that is going to last for some time. The Bank of China However, in spite of the apparent prosperity of Mainland China,
Hong Kong can still teach them a thing or two when it comes to banking. The Chinese
Banking System is riddled with systemic fraud and they folks in charge dont
seem to be able to get their arms around it. Moreover, the system is Mammoth and
it contains almost $900 billion in deposits.
Most of Chinas banking tribulations stem
from the fact that their antiquated system of checks and balances leaves a great
deal to be desired. There is no system of checks and balances leaving one person
is usually totally in charge of a division without mandatory reporting requirements.
Moreover, that is the very same system that allowed Nicky Leeson to bring down
a 200-year old English Bank (Bearings) because no one was watching his store.
The same thing is happening with The Bank of China over and over and over again.
And guess what; these folks that run Chinese banks are not even necessarily bankers;
for the most part they are people that have some economics background but are
party loyalists and political hacks. The Organization Department of the Communist
Party is in charge of appointing the bank presidents and this creates an immediate
conflict of interest because party officials become the first to stand in line
for loans for their pet infrastructure projects. More important even than that is the fact that Chinese laws
on embezzlement leave a lot to be desired and seem to be widely interpreted so
that if take goods not belonging to you but return them within a three-month window,
no crime has occurred. Added fuel to that fire is the fact that senior banking
executives in China are paid literally coolie wages
and in order to present a typical banking demeanor they are forced to live substantially
above their means. An article in the Huaxia Times, a Beijing newspaper was on
the mark when it stated that Chinese bank chiefs actually seek opportunities
to be corrupted. They treat their power to grant loans as a tradable commodity
to be used to benefit themselves. Moreover, oversight is strangely a perennial problem in the
banking industry that has only four major players, Construction Bank of china,
The Bank of China, Commercial Bank of China and the Agricultural Bank
of China. Part of the problem is based on the fact that communications among bank
employees, officers and customers are archaic to say the least that branches once
created are almost never closed,
and employees, once hired seem to die at their posts or worse. The four banks
previously mentioned employ almost 2-million people a statistic that graphically
demonstrates how inefficient the industry is. Almost everything is done by hand
and ATM machines only exist in the large cities and then only in restricted locations.
Loans are made because of political and social alliances and
most often have little to do with sound banking practices. Letters of credit are
written without even an inquiry into the underlying transactions and collateral
is rarely if ever checked. Things became a disaster in the Bank of China branch
located in the United
States. It runs out that the U.S. Branch of the bank was literally doing business
by feel rather than by any banking regulations. If they like the borrowers and
could get something back in exchange, they would make the loan. If not, it did
not matter how sound the transaction might be, they just werent going to
consider it. This brought on an investigation by U.S. banking authorities which
recently resulted in a $20 million fine. The result of the indication revealed that the bank was literally
operating out of control by facilitating fraudulent letters of credit, allowing
borrowers to sell assets that were pledged as collateral for loans and by extending
loans to people friendly with management without regard to their viability. When
the loans were not repaid, the borrowers defended their actions by stating that
the bank had put them up to the whole thing. The U.S. Office of the Comptroller
of the Currency stated that the bank was totally out of control and was engaged
in numerous nefarious dealings and they named them, chapter and verse. Two clients, John Chou and Sherry Liu, a Chinese-born
New Jersey couple assert
that the bank asked them to take out loans and put the proceeds into shell companies
that the branch could count as new customers to impress bosses in Beijing. They
also say they and others were solicited by the bank to help support the slipping
value of the Hong Kong dollar in a scheme where they were loaned money specifically
to buy Hong Kong dollar certificates of deposit in 1998 and 1999, said Steven
L. Kessler, a lawyer representing the paid. Mr. Zhou invested over $50 million
in the plan. The bank charged him 1 percent interest on the loans and he was guaranteed
a 10 per cent return on the year.
The Hong Kong and Macao
branches of the bank became a money launderer's paradise, their Canadian branch
was the receptacle for the Hong Kong underworld and the main office in Downtown
Beijing was found to be loaning money to non-existent Corporations. However, the worst news yet is the fact that the Bank of China
is probably the best run of all of the banks in the country and yet their former
president and CEO is awaiting a really healthy jail sentence for embezzling millions.
This is particularly strange when you discover that this was a man that
never made much more than a $1000 a month and yet between him and his wife, they
owned businesses throughout the Mainland, lived in luxurious style and had a cadre
of servants along with a limousine and driver. The threat of a massive stench
relative to the results of the Chinese Governments investigation into the
affairs of their former president, Wang Xuebing is so serious that a lid has been
placed on the entire incident. Banking officials in China
are concerned that when the people really find out what was going on in the Bank,
there could be a run. For China this would be a most unusual event and without
shoring up the banks could result in serious economic dislocations. If you deducted the apparent losses from Chinese Banks that
are caused by blatant fraud and subtracted that sum from the industrys total
net worth, the growth rate of China in terms of net assets would
be a fraction of what is currently being reported. Bank theft in China is not
done with a mask and a gun; it is simply accomplished from the inside with a pen
and paper. While not unheard of elsewhere, the massive number of unrelated participants
in this occupation is frightening to say the least. It almost seems that there
is a unknown disease rampantly slithering through the Chinese Banking system that
infects accountants, housewives and anyone else hired to do their bidding. The basic problem arises from the fact that the heads of the
main Chinese Banks are politically appointed by bureaucrats that often ask to
be repaid for the job with hastily manufactured loans with little collateral or
substance to back them up. Government officials sheepishly admit that fully 40
per cent of all loans made in this country are in default or have already been
written off. One of the most prevalent problems though is that few of the loans
are dealt with in any realistic manner. Rather than take the charge on their balance
sheet by putting loans into a none-performing column, many borrowers are lent
ever increasing amounts of money and the additional funds are partly used to pay
back what has already been borrowed, a tactic that is against nearly every countrys
bank policy. This naturally inflates the bubble dramatically and increases the
long term problem while not fully reflecting the true health of the banking system
here. We believe that the real situation in the Chinese banking industry is more
realistically the fact that no less than 60 percent of bank loans in this country
are in default, written off or have new loans that are paying them off. The New York Times wrote a story that puts the Chinese problem
in perspective: Before the mid-1990s, the state banks merely extended
credit to state enterprises on government order, and they had little experience
with standard financial practices like risk assessment, due diligence and securing
collateral. Today, Chinese economic officials, many with Western educations, feel
a sense of crisis about the banking system, but are unsure how to
solve the problem, financial experts here say.
Any solution without changing the political nature of the system is literally
impossible. Appoints to the major banks without any sense of the appointees ability
or morality is not the way to run a Laundromat much less a major bank. But the
problem extends far deeper; the cadre of people overseeing and auditing the banking
system is few and far between. Reporting procedures are nebulous and loans are
not double-checked. Quill pens predominate in an era that the systems should even
be operating without computer generated controls. Unless China
can get a better handle on the situation, for whatever their growth may be in
the future, it is firmly placed on a three legged chair that can tip over the
entire sector with little trouble and send the economy into a catatonic state
of free fall. The
Junk Yard Dog and His MastersSome occupations in China are extremely dangerous
to the country's health, others are dangerous to the people, but both can excess
synergistically in this strange land. In spite of the fact that from an economic
point of view China has made almost inconceivable strides over the last several
decades, this hardly means that it is a nation of full employment. As a matter
of fact, only about one-quarter of Chinas population lives in economically
vibrant zones, and the advent of capitalism has created a desperate situation
for many rural peasants. New occupations are few and far between,
and can be risky. Take, for example, the job of collecting re-usable metal from
electronic waste. This job has kept residents of Chaoyang County in Guangdong Province, one of the wealthiest areas of |